Kelly's Dockside Cafe

After much unnecessary negotiation for seating, our party of 6 was sat down on a dirty table, which despite asking for it to be cleaned was not done. Long wait times for food, and service was horrendous. Waiter was rude when we asked questions about the menu. After we decided not to tip, she asked whether we were going to tip and proceeded to stand there until we did so. The food was middling. Would not recommend coming here at all for its poor service.

Service: 1

You can tell that the place has seen better days. It's from the 70's, and it looks like the owner has no interest in keeping it up any more. Look into the corners for the dust and grime (like the electrical power strip at the end of the bar, covered in black caked-on dirt). Even the menus are cracked, tired, and faded. It seemed like morale there had walked out the door and left for good. And the food was...average. And overpriced maybe, but that's not unusual anywhere these days, right? The best part of our meal was the server, who did a great job (thank you!) with what she had to work with.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 5

I love this place. Old school diner that has just about everything you’d want, and it’s right on the water.

Nice view BUT, dirty restroom and bad bee problem on outside patio...food was fast and doable,BUT over priced,,do not think we will return...

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

A spot that makes you want to return.

Food: 5

Had breakfast there this morning.
Menu said coffee included kne free refill
The first cup was maybe 3/4 full since I wanted cream. Fine.
I asked for more during my average tasting omelet. It was barely half full. I figured Fine, it's free.
When I asked for the check the guy just tells me how much. After I paid I realized I was charged for the 2nd coffee. Plus he never asked if I wanted change. Only 0.21 but still....
I was going to leave a tip but the 2nd cup paid for was the tip

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 1

I came here with my family yesterday and one of the workers just told us to be seated outside. After waiting approximately 25 minutes and unsuccessfully trying to get the attention of three waiters who served other people that came in after us, we left. We went to a nearby restaurant called Ole, Ole, and had a phenomenal meal. I guess it was for the best.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

By far, one of the more bizarre dining experiences I have ever had. Nothing spectacular about the food (which took a long time to get (even ordering took too much time)), but the service (friendly waiter who would announce meals when he brought stuff and people would be raising hands, swapping food, fellow diners sharing laughs and glances) was entertaining. Upon arriving, a man barked at us to take menus and find a seat, while departure was welcome because an older man was gruff and complaining while we were paying. Location is excellent if you are on the canal, but otherwise, hard pass. Will probably not dine here again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 1

Good Bloody Mary, fried 🍤 and Roast beast club. Wedge fries were crispy got

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Service wasn't great. Chicken Alfredo was not too good, scallops were not good either. Definitely too expensive for the quality. I will not go back to this place. We did enjoy the seating near the canal.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 2

It's lovely to eat on the deck overlooking the canal! The Ruben was very good
It came with a pickle. Chips would have been nice with it. I love seafood chowder...this was good but a bit salty. I did not like the taco salad. The only taste was from salsa and sour cream. No taco taste at all. I'll go again but try something else.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

I can't even comment about the food. It was impossible to get any. They took a really long time to take our order and then never delivered any food despite asking for it several times. We did manage to get drinks. A flat Coke and a tasteless Bloody Mary. My suggestion is not to come here. I've had slow service but to never get our order was just ridiculous.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

never got served, looks nice, short on experienced staff, but maybe a nice place

Kelly's Dockside Cafe is a hidden treasure in Ithaca, offering a perfect blend of lakeside charm, delicious food, and a laid-back atmosphere. Situated right on the water, this cozy café provides a relaxed setting to enjoy a meal while taking in the serene views of the surrounding natural beauty.

The menu at Kelly's Dockside Cafe is an inviting mix of classic American comfort food and seafood dishes, with something for everyone. One of the most popular dishes is their fish and chips, served with crispy batter and flaky fish that’s perfectly seasoned. The lobster roll is another standout, packed with fresh lobster meat and served on a buttery, toasted bun—simple yet indulgent. For those looking for a lighter option, the Caesar salad with grilled chicken or shrimp is always fresh and satisfying.

The café also offers a fantastic selection of drinks, including local craft beers, wines, and refreshing cocktails. The Moscow mule is a favorite, served with a nice balance of ginger and lime. Pair it with some fresh seafood or a juicy burger, and you're set for a relaxing and delicious meal.

What makes Kelly's Dockside Cafe even more special is its scenic lakeside location. Whether you're dining inside with its casual, nautical-themed decor or enjoying the outdoor seating area, the views are always stunning. The outdoor deck, especially on a warm evening, is the perfect place to sip on a drink and watch the boats go by.

The staff at Kelly's Dockside Cafe is friendly and attentive, making sure guests feel right at home. The service is prompt, and the overall vibe is relaxed yet lively, ideal for both casual lunches and evening dinners with friends or family.

If you're in Ithaca and looking for a place to enjoy delicious food with a stunning view, Kelly's Dockside Cafe is a must-visit. Whether you're a seafood lover or just in the mood for a classic American meal, this charming lakeside café is sure to deliver a memorable dining experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Menu is diverse, offering everything from ramen to vegan curry