Upscale. White linen tablecloths. Great menu variation, little bit of everything. Steaks to seafood to burgers. Classy place with a great bar
Tony Hume
Lovely atmosphere and locals. Friendly staff. Prompt service. Great Mediterranean salad. Ordered salmon with sensational crispy polenta cake and asparagus that combined was just perfect on a gentle snowing evening
TeriPugh
We both had the signature hamburger. I asked for medium and it was very dry. My husband’s hamburger was a little better. First time there. Nice atmosphere. Good service but I was disappointed with my meal.
gail k
Food is well prepared - nothing out of the ordinary - The spaghetti and huge meatball was filling. The pasta with pesto was tasty - but a bit too much oil. The wait staff was attentive - Even though we had a reservation , the hostesses were very overwhelmed with a large party that arrived without a reservation. Were happy to find this restaurant as many restaurants in Ithaca are not open on Mondays.
nobus oghenekaro
Great food and awesome staff. They were willing to seat I and my cousin after we were turned away by another place for showing up 10mins before closing on a Sunday.
Ajay Pillai
I'm a huge fan of their braised beef short ribs and Faroe island salmon. The beef was tender and buttery. The salmon was properly seared, the asparagus was cooked well, the mash was a bit grainy although the seasoning was good.The service was super awesome too. The place is usually crowded, make sure to take a reservation before you go.
Hannah Lise
Fantastic gnocchi made in house. Fries were crispy, salty, and hot.. just perfect! Outdoor seating is nice on a day with good weather. Staff were friendly and helpful and food was ready quickly.
Sonia & Dru Bellajo
Nice restaurant, good atmosphere. Burger was good but skip the filet mignon. Beer was good too. Street parking is limited however 1 block away is a parking structure available for a fee.
619janev
We had 12 people and we were able to get in for dinner. Service was very good and the food was excellent. A little loud when we were there but it was packed
Chris Christofilakes
Best meal we had all week. Steak was juicy and doneness was as I asked. Scallops were done well and tasted fresh. Potatoes were tasty. And the dessert was good too.
Food was just delicious. for starters we had crab cakes, tomato soup, cheesy bread (amazing) and buratta. Our main dishes were Gnocchi with salmon and Penne vodka with shrimp. both are a must. We had sides of salad and Truffle fries. we finished with NY cheese cake and chocolate cake. Just an excellent meal. Service was great too.
Arun Gayam
We were in town for the weekend and heard good things about this place. The cocktails were just meh. The Garlic Cheesy Bread was a really good appetizer to start with. The beef short rib was really good but the shrimp scampi didn’t live up to the hype. The Bolognese was a good choice that our waiter Sophia recommended. Service here was very good and quick.
QB1212
Great service. Best hostess I’ve had and seen!! Great food as well. Ithaca is beautiful!! Can’t wait to come eat again!!
601hillaryb
Everything tasted great! The flavors were excellent, the service was quick and the wait staff were super friendly. I would definitely recommend.
NBandLB
Several restaurant choices on the Commons so we walked around to check them out. Mahogany Grill had a good crowd eating outside and the menu worked for us. We were seated right away inside and had our bar drinks quickly served. The small Mediterranean salad was fresh and a hefty portion. The chop house burger was delicious. Our server, Jenn, was efficient and kind and made the evening pleasant. We would like to return but just passing through on a road trip.
Upscale. White linen tablecloths. Great menu variation, little bit of everything. Steaks to seafood to burgers. Classy place with a great bar
Lovely atmosphere and locals. Friendly staff. Prompt service. Great Mediterranean salad. Ordered salmon with sensational crispy polenta cake and asparagus that combined was just perfect on a gentle snowing evening
We both had the signature hamburger. I asked for medium and it was very dry. My husband’s hamburger was a little better. First time there. Nice atmosphere. Good service but I was disappointed with my meal.
Food is well prepared - nothing out of the ordinary - The spaghetti and huge meatball was filling. The pasta with pesto was tasty - but a bit too much oil. The wait staff was attentive - Even though we had a reservation , the hostesses were very overwhelmed with a large party that arrived without a reservation. Were happy to find this restaurant as many restaurants in Ithaca are not open on Mondays.
Great food and awesome staff. They were willing to seat I and my cousin after we were turned away by another place for showing up 10mins before closing on a Sunday.
I'm a huge fan of their braised beef short ribs and Faroe island salmon. The beef was tender and buttery. The salmon was properly seared, the asparagus was cooked well, the mash was a bit grainy although the seasoning was good.The service was super awesome too. The place is usually crowded, make sure to take a reservation before you go.
Fantastic gnocchi made in house. Fries were crispy, salty, and hot.. just perfect! Outdoor seating is nice on a day with good weather. Staff were friendly and helpful and food was ready quickly.
Nice restaurant, good atmosphere. Burger was good but skip the filet mignon. Beer was good too. Street parking is limited however 1 block away is a parking structure available for a fee.
We had 12 people and we were able to get in for dinner. Service was very good and the food was excellent. A little loud when we were there but it was packed
Best meal we had all week. Steak was juicy and doneness was as I asked. Scallops were done well and tasted fresh. Potatoes were tasty. And the dessert was good too.
Restaurantji Recommends
Food was just delicious. for starters we had crab cakes, tomato soup, cheesy bread (amazing) and buratta. Our main dishes were Gnocchi with salmon and Penne vodka with shrimp. both are a must. We had sides of salad and Truffle fries. we finished with NY cheese cake and chocolate cake. Just an excellent meal. Service was great too.
We were in town for the weekend and heard good things about this place. The cocktails were just meh. The Garlic Cheesy Bread was a really good appetizer to start with. The beef short rib was really good but the shrimp scampi didn’t live up to the hype. The Bolognese was a good choice that our waiter Sophia recommended. Service here was very good and quick.
Great service. Best hostess I’ve had and seen!! Great food as well. Ithaca is beautiful!! Can’t wait to come eat again!!
Everything tasted great! The flavors were excellent, the service was quick and the wait staff were super friendly. I would definitely recommend.
Several restaurant choices on the Commons so we walked around to check them out. Mahogany Grill had a good crowd eating outside and the menu worked for us. We were seated right away inside and had our bar drinks quickly served. The small Mediterranean salad was fresh and a hefty portion. The chop house burger was delicious. Our server, Jenn, was efficient and kind and made the evening pleasant. We would like to return but just passing through on a road trip.
Loading...