Old Mexico Express
111 Dryden Rd, Ithaca
(607) 319-5633
Customers' Favorites
Burrito
Menu
Photos
+15 photos
+14 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Build-your-own-plate restaurant. Ordered steak nachos with pico and salsa. Overall good, I will order a different meat next time though, the steak was cooked well and tender but flavor was lacking and was served only sort-of warm. Pico and salsa were fresh and tasty, cheese blend good, chips fresh. A minor gripe is that it's served with the only warm component being the meat, so it's a very room-temperature-to-cold food experience, but not everything needs to be piping...
Not sure why this place was closed for a long time, but it’s open again and I’m glad I tried it. With food prices increasing all over collegetown, the quality and portion size you get here for the price is definitely worth it. Service may be a little slow at times but it usually doesn’t ever take more than a couple minutes. The selection of meats and other ingredients is also great! Definitely give it a shot if you haven’t!
Great food but really inconsistent hours. They say they close from 3PM to 5PM everyday, but multiple times I've been by the store or called before and after those times (2pm and 6pm, typically) to check and they were closed or didn't answer the phone. Really frustrating.
You May Also Like
Plum Tree Restaurant - 113 Dryden Rd
![]()
Japanese, Sushi Bar, Vegetarian
Gangnam Station - 104 Dryden Rd
![]()
Korean, Chinese, Vegetarian
Wings Over Ithaca - 121 Dryden Rd
![]()
Chicken Wings, Fast Food