I've always loved Pat's but they have this girl there now who is outstanding. She knows how to make pizza like call Barstool good. She needs her own place!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Phil Kosick
My mom myself and her friend went to pick her dogs ashes up at the vet and we stopped by here for lunch it was pretty nice the boneless wings were a little dry however I needed another Ranch and the guy said no if you fix that I will definitely come
Enjoyed Pat's Pizzeria recently on a visit to Ithaca for a baseball tourney. Carried out a large thin crust pepperoni and a large regular pepperoni. The pizzas were big and tasty and we all agreed their thin crust is the way to go. We also used the coupon for the free garlic bites - YUMMMMM - they were a hit. We had tons of leftovers and had pizza for breakfast the next day.There seem to be a lot of pizza places around that area with a bunch of different reviews, and some of them look... well... not great. Pat's was good, standard pizza with large slices that you'll enjoy. Wasn't fancy, wasn't exotic, but it was really good. Carry it out and enjoy. They do have some modest inside and outside seating, which was fine, but I think it's more about the pizza there and not really meant to be a destination place.Sidenote, the staff was super friendly even though they were clearly busy. I really appreciated that.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Aurora LaDieu
Food is good but not the best. Ordered a large pizza with onions, banana peppers, and pepperoni. For how much toppings cost, I felt robbed, all pepperoni barley any banana peppers or onions. Found banana pepper tops on my pizza, do better. When going inside to pickup my online order I kept getting looked at instead of receiving any service.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
THOMAS M
I had a turkey sub. It was the worst one I ever had; small - just a few slices of turkey. they forgot lettuce; cost $1 more than the menu price. and had to put mayo on myself from packets. Will never go back or recommend. De bellas real close in location and you get easily twice as much for less.
Lets Go Flying
Possibly the best gluten free pizza in Ithaca.
Zach Stewart
Pizza can't really be bad, but for half the price. Go get a slice from Dandy or Byrne Dairy. It's smaller but tastes about the same. It's alright in a
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Jasper Gneiting
Not really my favorite type of pizza. The crust is thick and it is a little more doughy than I would like.
Jen Reed Castro
Love there pizza and food, definitely my favorite place to get pizza from hands down.....
Vex Intersectional
Man customers can be rude, when the customer ahead of you orders 9 pizzas your door dash will need to wait, it's not the pizzerias fault you left your kid and dog in the car.
How hard can it be to ensure an order contains the main item, a calzone, and a second item, a pasta dish, includes its requested side of meatballs. The other two sides I had added to the pasta were spinach and mushrooms. I'd need a magnifying glass to guarantee they were there.It got here fast via Ithaca to Go, but the food was room-temp cold. The food was generally greasy, the quality of the ingredients mediocre at best for the price.I rarely leave bad reviews, but Pat's Pizzeria, you're not even trying. This was our first and last time trying you.
Tom P.
I just ordered a calzone and garlic bread. With Root beer it came to almost $30. What I received was more like two slices of stuffed pizza and it wasn't that well stuffed and the ingredients were mediocre at best. Their ricotta tasted like cream cheese and they probably only threw a tablespoon or two in. I asked for spinach and ham and I can find about three shreds of spinach in it and the ham looks like the pre-package cube ham they put in 7-Eleven salads. The whole thing was generally disgusting. The dough was like eating a cheap Walmart sheet cake. The size was absolutely ridiculous for the price they made it out of A 12 inch pizza dough and the same for the garlic bread. You couldn't pay me enough to eat at this place again. The kids making the food we're friendly and seemed pretty sharp but that's absolutely the best thing I can say about this place. Definitely a one out of 10. An absolute zero for value. I've owned restaurants and eaten at least hundreds of good New York calzones and this place wasn't even in the same shooting range and never mind missing the mark. this is incredibly disappointing because Ithaca used to be full of great Italian food. And this place has the audacity to call it self the pizza of the finger lakes. Way to discourage tourism pats.....
Melissa Fraley
Pizza was delicious. In our party, there were 3 different types of pizza ordered and everyone liked everything. Kids and adults were pleased. I had the white garlic and it was great. Good crust, very rich flavor. We also had mozzarella sticks and garlic nuggets. Nuggets were very flavorful, but had a lot of butter (which tasted good, just made for messy fingers, lol!) I would definitely check this place out if you're in the area for quick bites!
DR&BB
Don’t really know why the pizza has any more than two or three stars unless they changed how they made the pizzas. We have eaten pizza all over the country and we both said after the first bite of Pat’s that it was the like the Chef Boyardee that we had as kids that came in a box, mainly the taste of their sauce. I am sure more cheese or toppings (very light) might have helped a little but definitely one of the least satisfying we have ever had and pricey.
Darlene Hyde
This was the first pizza I had from Pat's. We would be getting more too but it is a long drive from Syracuse to Ithaca. The staff was great, I called from Dryden and my pizzas were just coming out of the oven when I walked in the door. Members of the staff even offered to carry the pizzas out to my truck.Oh man, those pizzas were sooo good and flavorful. The best pizza I've had in a long time. 5?for the pizza. 5? for the girl and guy working. 5? for cleanliness of the restaurant.
I've always loved Pat's but they have this girl there now who is outstanding. She knows how to make pizza like call Barstool good. She needs her own place!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
My mom myself and her friend went to pick her dogs ashes up at the vet and we stopped by here for lunch it was pretty nice the boneless wings were a little dry however I needed another Ranch and the guy said no if you fix that I will definitely come
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings, Garlic, Garlic Knots, Pizza, Pizza Slice
Enjoyed Pat's Pizzeria recently on a visit to Ithaca for a baseball tourney. Carried out a large thin crust pepperoni and a large regular pepperoni. The pizzas were big and tasty and we all agreed their thin crust is the way to go. We also used the coupon for the free garlic bites - YUMMMMM - they were a hit. We had tons of leftovers and had pizza for breakfast the next day.There seem to be a lot of pizza places around that area with a bunch of different reviews, and some of them look... well... not great. Pat's was good, standard pizza with large slices that you'll enjoy. Wasn't fancy, wasn't exotic, but it was really good. Carry it out and enjoy. They do have some modest inside and outside seating, which was fine, but I think it's more about the pizza there and not really meant to be a destination place.Sidenote, the staff was super friendly even though they were clearly busy. I really appreciated that.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food is good but not the best. Ordered a large pizza with onions, banana peppers, and pepperoni. For how much toppings cost, I felt robbed, all pepperoni barley any banana peppers or onions. Found banana pepper tops on my pizza, do better. When going inside to pickup my online order I kept getting looked at instead of receiving any service.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
I had a turkey sub. It was the worst one I ever had; small - just a few slices of turkey. they forgot lettuce; cost $1 more than the menu price. and had to put mayo on myself from packets. Will never go back or recommend. De bellas real close in location and you get easily twice as much for less.
Possibly the best gluten free pizza in Ithaca.
Pizza can't really be bad, but for half the price. Go get a slice from Dandy or Byrne Dairy. It's smaller but tastes about the same. It's alright in a
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Not really my favorite type of pizza. The crust is thick and it is a little more doughy than I would like.
Love there pizza and food, definitely my favorite place to get pizza from hands down.....
Man customers can be rude, when the customer ahead of you orders 9 pizzas your door dash will need to wait, it's not the pizzerias fault you left your kid and dog in the car.
Restaurantji Recommends
How hard can it be to ensure an order contains the main item, a calzone, and a second item, a pasta dish, includes its requested side of meatballs. The other two sides I had added to the pasta were spinach and mushrooms. I'd need a magnifying glass to guarantee they were there.It got here fast via Ithaca to Go, but the food was room-temp cold. The food was generally greasy, the quality of the ingredients mediocre at best for the price.I rarely leave bad reviews, but Pat's Pizzeria, you're not even trying. This was our first and last time trying you.
I just ordered a calzone and garlic bread. With Root beer it came to almost $30. What I received was more like two slices of stuffed pizza and it wasn't that well stuffed and the ingredients were mediocre at best. Their ricotta tasted like cream cheese and they probably only threw a tablespoon or two in. I asked for spinach and ham and I can find about three shreds of spinach in it and the ham looks like the pre-package cube ham they put in 7-Eleven salads. The whole thing was generally disgusting. The dough was like eating a cheap Walmart sheet cake. The size was absolutely ridiculous for the price they made it out of A 12 inch pizza dough and the same for the garlic bread. You couldn't pay me enough to eat at this place again. The kids making the food we're friendly and seemed pretty sharp but that's absolutely the best thing I can say about this place. Definitely a one out of 10. An absolute zero for value. I've owned restaurants and eaten at least hundreds of good New York calzones and this place wasn't even in the same shooting range and never mind missing the mark. this is incredibly disappointing because Ithaca used to be full of great Italian food. And this place has the audacity to call it self the pizza of the finger lakes. Way to discourage tourism pats.....
Pizza was delicious. In our party, there were 3 different types of pizza ordered and everyone liked everything. Kids and adults were pleased. I had the white garlic and it was great. Good crust, very rich flavor. We also had mozzarella sticks and garlic nuggets. Nuggets were very flavorful, but had a lot of butter (which tasted good, just made for messy fingers, lol!) I would definitely check this place out if you're in the area for quick bites!
Don’t really know why the pizza has any more than two or three stars unless they changed how they made the pizzas. We have eaten pizza all over the country and we both said after the first bite of Pat’s that it was the like the Chef Boyardee that we had as kids that came in a box, mainly the taste of their sauce. I am sure more cheese or toppings (very light) might have helped a little but definitely one of the least satisfying we have ever had and pricey.
This was the first pizza I had from Pat's. We would be getting more too but it is a long drive from Syracuse to Ithaca. The staff was great, I called from Dryden and my pizzas were just coming out of the oven when I walked in the door. Members of the staff even offered to carry the pizzas out to my truck.Oh man, those pizzas were sooo good and flavorful. The best pizza I've had in a long time. 5?for the pizza. 5? for the girl and guy working. 5? for cleanliness of the restaurant.