Killa Kookies & Kream

3423 Fluvanna Ave, Jamestown
(716) 499-6291

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jennifer Hazelton

I’ve ordered cookies twice for class treats as Killa Kookies was highly recommended! The kiddos LOVED the cookies both times! And so do the adults!!! The owner is so sweet and kind, we can’t wait to order more in the future for special events!

Colleen Anthony

Ordered my daughters first birthday cake from here and it was AMAZING! The icing was some of the best icing I have ever had. put the left over cake (i know a tragedy) in the freezer and 4 days later it still tastes just as fresh as the day we picked it up!! will definitely come to them for all the birthday/party cakes!!

Erin Saxton-Filkins

Killa Kookies always does a great job! We got our wedding cake, cupcake and cookies from there a couple of years ago and they were fantastic!

They were experimenting with different cinnamon rolls a while ago and the cookies and cream frosted one was delicious.

The peanut butter pie is fantastic.
As well as all their cupcakes!

My husband loves the cookies too!

Dietary restrictions: Possible to order GF cupcakes made with almond flour.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Gourmet Cupcakes, Cookie Sandwich, Drop Cookies, Gelato, Bakery

Haley Storer

The cookies for my daughter’s party were AMAZING. everyone loved them! They were so soft and done so well! Exactly what I wanted! I can’t recommend them enough

Katie

I absolutely love this bakery and the way they went above the standards on the custom cheesecake I ordered. It was so delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Monica Morales

I have had cake from here on 3 different occasions and each occasion I was highly disappointed. My mother ordered from here for her wedding and it looked nothing like my mom wanted. Not only did it not look the greatest the taste was dry and awful. I had cake from here again for my cousins birthday. It was the cutest grinch cake I would give it a 10/10 for presentation but the cake was dry and the fondant used was so thick and gross. My other cousin ordered from here for her daughter’s birthday in November. Again presentation was so cute but the taste was awful. The fondant on it had to be a half an inch thick no lie. It had a hazelnut inside that was the only good tasting part about this cake the rest was dry. Kind of old tasting. It’s too bad because I was really hoping to redeem their name but 3 times on different occasions with different people ordering. It just is a no for me.

Food: 1

Aidan Remington

They did a cake for my surprise birthday and it was all messed up not what I wanted at all , the fondant was all bunched up in the back of one of the cakes when it’s suppose to be smooth and there was way too much frosting underneath, and not the type of frosting I asked for. 10 out of 10 do not recommend.

deborah talarico

Best baked goods I ever had. My favorite is the peanut butter blossom cookies. OMG! Amazing. Will be ordering from them again.

Ashley Hargis

The homemade cookies are their best item in my opinion, we’re big fans of the snickerdoodles.

Holly Webber

The cookies tasted like powdered sugar and baking powder. the buttercream frosting was so thick it was like eating butter. I spent over $45 between my friend and I and we both ended up throwing most of it away. It looks beautiful but the taste is not very great Especially for the price

Dan Ball

Cake isn’t fresh must come in made already. Frosting is like eating a scoop of butter. Maybe someone should tell them not to put buttercream in a cold case and very over priced.

Rhonda Lamancuso

I got custom cookies for my husband’s birthday. I sent pictures of the designs I wanted & not only did they look amazing, but they were delicious cookies!!

Julie Dempski

Ice cold food, missing food and no silverware when ordered online. Unreliable.

maggie river

This is my favorite bakery

John Lyon

Very yummy but they need to advertise to bring customers in so the prices come down.

Loading...