Jamestown, NY restaurant—
Our waiter was fantastic and should 100% go work somewhere else, the food was mediocre and the beer was less than impressive. I didn’t think I’d ever say that I wouldn’t like an IPA but it was achieved here! I ordered a burger and it came with nothing on it and my mashed potatoes were cold. Then, as me and my 9 year old daughter were trying to enjoy taking a picture by the skeletons, the bartender told me to not have her walking around the bar area as it wasn’t a public space. Meanwhile everyone at the bar was staring at us like we were doing something wrong. It completely ruined the experience for us to where we just went and sat back down feeling like we both got in trouble. Not to mention we were seated near the stage while the band was bringing their large equipment in as we were trying to have lunch. Personal space was definitely invaded. We won’t be returning!
Tiffany Lang
I would recommend trying Wicked Warren. The pizza is usually very good. However, I just picked up a pickle bacon pizza which I usually love and it raw in the center, the pickles cold, and it had no spices or taste of being baked in a wood fire. I've had their pizza many times and never had one made like this. I almost called to have it corrected but have other plans. the bacon appetizer is just fat and had to be tossed. I'm not sure if this was a new cook, but it was very disappointing.
Tina Pastor
Our server and the hostess were very friendly. The food was delicious! The best part is the skeleton in a blue dress. 😁
Susan Bowen-Gassman
We stopped in while Christmas shopping, on a whim, and turns out it was the first day of their new menu. All of the items that we selected were delicious and we cannot wait to stop back and try more things. The cheese stuffed banana peppers were amazing. 🤩
Stan Shargors
We went there as a family on a Saturday afternoon. The place is very clean and well maintained. Our waitress did a very good job. Every food item we ordered was delicious! Definitely will visit again.
Steven Thorpe
Great place to get food, catch the game and try a few new beers.
Sean Sean
Wicked Warren’s in Jamestown New York is a great place to grab a bite to eat. It’s within walking distance from the Doubletree and LaQuinta. The food is excellent and the staff was extraordinary. Our server, Raina, made sure we were all happy with our food, and she was especially good with my grandfather, who is half deaf. She made sure to speak in his good ear, and knew just when to crack a joke, which made us all laugh. The atmosphere was just amazing, and I hear the beer tastes like heaven. It’s cool to see the brewing machines. We will definitely be eating here again next year when we come to visit!!!
Mark Mansfield
Food was good. I ordered a medium NY Strip and it was definitely on the rare side. My husband ordered Cajun Broiled Haddock but it had no Cajun seasoning on it and no dill tartar sauce. We found it very weird and disappointing that they don’t serve hot beverages like coffee and tea even though they serve dessert.
John Thweatt
Great cocktails. Great food. Great service. Great atmosphere. This place is a must.
Greg Corbi
Love this spot! Excellent food, crispy chick sandwich was delicious and the beer cheese pizza is unforgettable. Beers are on another level. Big flavorful and balanced IPAs and rich porters. Be back soon
Food and drinks were amazing. Sal killed it on the old fashioned. He should be mixing more and more drinks. The beer was top botch. Would Def come again when in the area.
Patricia Schwarz
Awesome - first time here, did not disappoint. Great service, food, atmosphere and great selection at the bar . They have seltzers & you can choose any flavor, combinations, and Sugar Free! Avocado salad was fresh, and the blue rooster pizza was amazing. Boyfriend loved the pretzels & beer cheese. We’ll be back! Prices were very reasonable as well.
kenny williams
I love the BBQ wings and the Beer cheese pizza nice bistro/ pub atmosphere with live entertainment on a Saturday night in Jamestown very KOOL
Wayne LaCross
First time there tonight. The beers were excellent! Highly recommend the vanilla Porter. Food was delicious and our waitress was very attentive. Definitely going back!
K G (Khandio)
Fast Friendly Service , Nicole P checked on us frequently and smiled every time! We definitely had an amazing experience. 3 different Pizza’s , Avacado Salad , and the Fish Fry - everything was cooked properly and presented nicely!
Jamestown, NY restaurant— Our waiter was fantastic and should 100% go work somewhere else, the food was mediocre and the beer was less than impressive. I didn’t think I’d ever say that I wouldn’t like an IPA but it was achieved here! I ordered a burger and it came with nothing on it and my mashed potatoes were cold. Then, as me and my 9 year old daughter were trying to enjoy taking a picture by the skeletons, the bartender told me to not have her walking around the bar area as it wasn’t a public space. Meanwhile everyone at the bar was staring at us like we were doing something wrong. It completely ruined the experience for us to where we just went and sat back down feeling like we both got in trouble. Not to mention we were seated near the stage while the band was bringing their large equipment in as we were trying to have lunch. Personal space was definitely invaded. We won’t be returning!
I would recommend trying Wicked Warren. The pizza is usually very good. However, I just picked up a pickle bacon pizza which I usually love and it raw in the center, the pickles cold, and it had no spices or taste of being baked in a wood fire. I've had their pizza many times and never had one made like this. I almost called to have it corrected but have other plans. the bacon appetizer is just fat and had to be tossed. I'm not sure if this was a new cook, but it was very disappointing.
Our server and the hostess were very friendly. The food was delicious! The best part is the skeleton in a blue dress. 😁
We stopped in while Christmas shopping, on a whim, and turns out it was the first day of their new menu. All of the items that we selected were delicious and we cannot wait to stop back and try more things. The cheese stuffed banana peppers were amazing. 🤩
We went there as a family on a Saturday afternoon. The place is very clean and well maintained. Our waitress did a very good job. Every food item we ordered was delicious! Definitely will visit again.
Great place to get food, catch the game and try a few new beers.
Wicked Warren’s in Jamestown New York is a great place to grab a bite to eat. It’s within walking distance from the Doubletree and LaQuinta. The food is excellent and the staff was extraordinary. Our server, Raina, made sure we were all happy with our food, and she was especially good with my grandfather, who is half deaf. She made sure to speak in his good ear, and knew just when to crack a joke, which made us all laugh. The atmosphere was just amazing, and I hear the beer tastes like heaven. It’s cool to see the brewing machines. We will definitely be eating here again next year when we come to visit!!!
Food was good. I ordered a medium NY Strip and it was definitely on the rare side. My husband ordered Cajun Broiled Haddock but it had no Cajun seasoning on it and no dill tartar sauce. We found it very weird and disappointing that they don’t serve hot beverages like coffee and tea even though they serve dessert.
Great cocktails. Great food. Great service. Great atmosphere. This place is a must.
Love this spot! Excellent food, crispy chick sandwich was delicious and the beer cheese pizza is unforgettable. Beers are on another level. Big flavorful and balanced IPAs and rich porters. Be back soon
Restaurantji Recommends
Food and drinks were amazing. Sal killed it on the old fashioned. He should be mixing more and more drinks. The beer was top botch. Would Def come again when in the area.
Awesome - first time here, did not disappoint. Great service, food, atmosphere and great selection at the bar . They have seltzers & you can choose any flavor, combinations, and Sugar Free! Avocado salad was fresh, and the blue rooster pizza was amazing. Boyfriend loved the pretzels & beer cheese. We’ll be back! Prices were very reasonable as well.
I love the BBQ wings and the Beer cheese pizza nice bistro/ pub atmosphere with live entertainment on a Saturday night in Jamestown very KOOL
First time there tonight. The beers were excellent! Highly recommend the vanilla Porter. Food was delicious and our waitress was very attentive. Definitely going back!
Fast Friendly Service , Nicole P checked on us frequently and smiled every time! We definitely had an amazing experience. 3 different Pizza’s , Avacado Salad , and the Fish Fry - everything was cooked properly and presented nicely!
Loading...