This is a review just on their pizza, as the other food we've had (salads and pasta) was good. The pizza is terrible. We ordered a pie to eat in the restaurant and it was thin, floppy, and greasy with a layer of oil on top that seemed to seep out more and more as the pie cooled off. There was absolutely no taste to their sauce either, and not much of it either, but considering how super thin the pizza was there was no way to even put more of it on without making it even more of a soggy mess. So disappointing!
La Deana S.
I drove to Fanático knowing I wanted their penne allá vodka - it's so good!! However, the server made sure that we took a look at the specials menu. Well, why did he do that?! They had a Belgian Waffle I couldn't resist ordering. It was really good, but in the interest of full disclosure, I didn't eat the chicken (I don't like chicken breast), but the waffle and bacon were delicious. I like the decor in the restaurant and the location is convenient. The music is not too loud. My only complaint is that, even though it wasn't crowded, we were seated at a booth with a fake wall. It's great for ambiance (for example, at a romantic dinner when speaking in low tones) but the people on the other side of the wall were speaking in louder tones, such that we could hear their entire conversation. Rather than speak over them, we continued our conversation when we left. This happened two times in the same visit (we asked to move the first time, but we almost through our meal when it happened the second time), so took away one star.
Barbara Kahl
Delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amanda L.
My family and I came here for dinner - we've been coming for years since it's a Jericho staple. This time, we ordered the zucchini sticks, garden vegetable pizza on a thin crust, and gnocchi bomb. We loved the zucchini sticks - they were breaded and super crispy! I wasn't super impressed with the garden vegetable pizza because the pizza was kind of soggy, but it was chock full of toppings. The vodka sauce on the gnocchi was good, except the edible bowl didn't really go with the rest of the dish. They served us house focaccia bread, which was delicious (and my mom's favorite part)! We usually get eggplant parm, which is our favorite, but wanted to try something new this time.
Charles H.
We have been coming to Fanatico for over 15 years. The food and service are beyond excellent. Hope to be around for another 15 years to continue to enjoy this place. Special shout out to Gloria-the sweetest server ever!
Sandra C.
Came in for a group weeknight dinner. We did the price fixed menu and what a selection. The food: huge generous portions, and delicious. Drinks were excellent, service was friendly and accurate, would def recommend for dinner.
Christos Z.
They were great when making the reservation and quickly sat us when we arrived. The waitress was pretty good and was genuine which I appreciated and patient. We had kids at the table and everything was not calm or organized but she handled it great and got nothing wrong. Pretty clean and quiet atmosphere . The food was ok at best . I got a chicken parm can't go too wrong. My wife got something off of the special menu and wasn't thrilled with the flavor but the shrimp was fresh and well proportioned.
Justine L.
Came here for an anniversary dinner. We were seated quickly, but our waiter took a while to come. We noticed the restaurant was relatively empty, so I'm not sure why he rarely came around to our table. The food was amazing and came pretty quickly. I only took one star off because our server seems very inattentive despite the restaurant being empty.
I loved my organic Ruby Red Beet, Walnut, and Goat Cheese salad. The pepperoni slice and bread that came with the salad were perfect! (I probably wouldn’t have ordered a slice of pizza if I had known the salad came with the bread but happy I got both anyways)Parking: There’s usually lots of parking
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad, Baked Ziti
Tina K.
Once again ordered pizza on a Friday night and they got our order wrong. We ordered Sicilian with half mushrooms and got half meatballs. And it never fails, the pizza is always raw inside. I don't know why their pizza doesn't cook through....I had to throw a few pieces away because I don't enjoy eating raw dough.
Fronimakis Anastasia
Good food, fresh and delicious. Friendly attentive staff. Excellent wine choices. Make a reservation. The salads are a meal in themselves and oh so delicious. The shrimp scampi over zucchini was good however a bit too much zucchini. The pizzas are delicious too!
Kitty Anderson-Galvez
Omg so VERY crispy and delicious.Nice looking place too. Could enjoy a comfortable evening here with friends too.Got such a warm welcome at the Pizza counter.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Katrina C.
Located inside a small shopping area next to h-mart, an Asian noodle shop, nail salon, and dunkin w ample amount of parking. I always order their chopped veggie salad w no cheese , no mushroom, and add grilled chicken to go. I was finally able to dine-in the other night, and the service was impeccable. Our waiter was super attentative. Never empty cups. Tried their linguine w clam sauce, and it was cooked to perfection. Their classic margarita is delish. Will be back soon. I def recommend!
Great food. Clean place. Awesome. Will be
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is a review just on their pizza, as the other food we've had (salads and pasta) was good. The pizza is terrible. We ordered a pie to eat in the restaurant and it was thin, floppy, and greasy with a layer of oil on top that seemed to seep out more and more as the pie cooled off. There was absolutely no taste to their sauce either, and not much of it either, but considering how super thin the pizza was there was no way to even put more of it on without making it even more of a soggy mess. So disappointing!
I drove to Fanático knowing I wanted their penne allá vodka - it's so good!! However, the server made sure that we took a look at the specials menu. Well, why did he do that?! They had a Belgian Waffle I couldn't resist ordering. It was really good, but in the interest of full disclosure, I didn't eat the chicken (I don't like chicken breast), but the waffle and bacon were delicious. I like the decor in the restaurant and the location is convenient. The music is not too loud. My only complaint is that, even though it wasn't crowded, we were seated at a booth with a fake wall. It's great for ambiance (for example, at a romantic dinner when speaking in low tones) but the people on the other side of the wall were speaking in louder tones, such that we could hear their entire conversation. Rather than speak over them, we continued our conversation when we left. This happened two times in the same visit (we asked to move the first time, but we almost through our meal when it happened the second time), so took away one star.
Delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My family and I came here for dinner - we've been coming for years since it's a Jericho staple. This time, we ordered the zucchini sticks, garden vegetable pizza on a thin crust, and gnocchi bomb. We loved the zucchini sticks - they were breaded and super crispy! I wasn't super impressed with the garden vegetable pizza because the pizza was kind of soggy, but it was chock full of toppings. The vodka sauce on the gnocchi was good, except the edible bowl didn't really go with the rest of the dish. They served us house focaccia bread, which was delicious (and my mom's favorite part)! We usually get eggplant parm, which is our favorite, but wanted to try something new this time.
We have been coming to Fanatico for over 15 years. The food and service are beyond excellent. Hope to be around for another 15 years to continue to enjoy this place. Special shout out to Gloria-the sweetest server ever!
Came in for a group weeknight dinner. We did the price fixed menu and what a selection. The food: huge generous portions, and delicious. Drinks were excellent, service was friendly and accurate, would def recommend for dinner.
They were great when making the reservation and quickly sat us when we arrived. The waitress was pretty good and was genuine which I appreciated and patient. We had kids at the table and everything was not calm or organized but she handled it great and got nothing wrong. Pretty clean and quiet atmosphere . The food was ok at best . I got a chicken parm can't go too wrong. My wife got something off of the special menu and wasn't thrilled with the flavor but the shrimp was fresh and well proportioned.
Came here for an anniversary dinner. We were seated quickly, but our waiter took a while to come. We noticed the restaurant was relatively empty, so I'm not sure why he rarely came around to our table. The food was amazing and came pretty quickly. I only took one star off because our server seems very inattentive despite the restaurant being empty.
Food is delicious and it's so pretty !!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Rainbow Cookie Cheesecake, Chopped Salad, Salad
Restaurantji Recommends
I loved my organic Ruby Red Beet, Walnut, and Goat Cheese salad. The pepperoni slice and bread that came with the salad were perfect! (I probably wouldn’t have ordered a slice of pizza if I had known the salad came with the bread but happy I got both anyways)Parking: There’s usually lots of parking
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad, Baked Ziti
Once again ordered pizza on a Friday night and they got our order wrong. We ordered Sicilian with half mushrooms and got half meatballs. And it never fails, the pizza is always raw inside. I don't know why their pizza doesn't cook through....I had to throw a few pieces away because I don't enjoy eating raw dough.
Good food, fresh and delicious. Friendly attentive staff. Excellent wine choices. Make a reservation. The salads are a meal in themselves and oh so delicious. The shrimp scampi over zucchini was good however a bit too much zucchini. The pizzas are delicious too!
Omg so VERY crispy and delicious.Nice looking place too. Could enjoy a comfortable evening here with friends too.Got such a warm welcome at the Pizza counter.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Located inside a small shopping area next to h-mart, an Asian noodle shop, nail salon, and dunkin w ample amount of parking. I always order their chopped veggie salad w no cheese , no mushroom, and add grilled chicken to go. I was finally able to dine-in the other night, and the service was impeccable. Our waiter was super attentative. Never empty cups. Tried their linguine w clam sauce, and it was cooked to perfection. Their classic margarita is delish. Will be back soon. I def recommend!