Jericho Cider Mill

Almost missed this place, thanks to the flags which called my attention. Off the road, no parking so just parked on the side of the road. No sidewalk, just raised uneven grassy area - not wheelchair accessible.
Store is small, filled with a variety of jarred products (don’t know if it was just that day but they weren’t organized by label), pies, donuts, bottled cider, etc.
Got a gallon of cider, a bag of donuts and a frozen cider (a slushy version). Hot cider was also available. I liked their donut- cakey but not as dense as others I’ve had, just the right sweetness.
Apples and pumpkins on sale, some photo ops outside.

I visited Jericho cider mill today and was disappointed by the poor customer service. The employee I encountered seemed uninterested in assisting me. There was no greeting or friendly interaction, which made me feel unwelcome. She didn’t even look up when I walked up to the register.

From the moment we stopped by the energy was off the charts. Ended up getting two pies, banana cream and pumpkin which were outstanding. The apple slushie with a doughnut was my favorite, my wife is obsessed with all the diffrent doughnuts. The cashiers were super helpful and nice. Will be returning again soon.

Really good pies and delicious apple cider!

Made the drive from Farmingdale. Had a great time visiting Cider Mill in Jericho. Very lowkey place in Long Island but also very popular. Once you arrive, you will see lines forming in the front side. We bought donuts and cold juice, both were good. They have cornhole game available and tables to sit at while you eat & drink. Parking is on the side of the road, gets very full (keep that in mind)

I used to live on Long Island and this was one of my favorite spots. When I make the trip back to Long Island, I always stop here. The pies and warm apple cider are delicious!

We go here every year for the cider donuts , really authentic apple cider and every variety of apple imaginable . Plus they have jarred items , bought the strawberry rhubarb preserves a favorite . Also known for their pies but since I love baking pies we leave them for others. Nice stop on an autumn day .

Best cider ever! The gold standard, nothing compares!

Apple pie was a bit raw in the middle and overall it was not flavored enough with spices, very bland.
The pumpkin donuts didn’t taste much like pumpkin. The apple cider donuts were good. The apple cider was very tasty.

Ir was better in the old days now its pretty dirty

I no longer live on Long Island but am happy to see this iconic place is still in business. My late husband and I lived nearly an hour away from the Jericho Cider Mill. We had easy access to a number of nearby farmstands. But every year, instead of a birthday cake, he requested an apple crisp, specifically from here. When I visit the area again, I plan on making a trip here and stocking up.

A fun place to get apples,cider,pies

Great stop for cider and donuts! It's like being out east or in Connecticut! I'm glad this place has been here for way over 200 years and hasn't become condos!

Jericho Cider Mill Chocolate Glazed Doughnuts are delicious!!! Rich, moist, perfectly glazed, wonderfully made every time. Find a way to eat some as soon as possible! I've searched high and low for the decadent doughnuts I remember from my youth. But every other brand I've purchased at supermarkets or doughnut shops has been a sad, faint echo of the perfect scrumptious delight we all think of when our heart calls for a doughnut treat. Be sure to buy enough for everybody - no one will want to go halfsies. Thank you Jericho Cider Mill for crafting these sublime doughnuts!!!!

Went last Sunday and both my debit card and my sister's were then used for fraudulent charges. WILL NEVER SHOP HERE AGAIN!