The Milleridge Inn

585 N Broadway, Jericho
(516) 931-2201

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Dawn

Horrible meal the meat was hard to chew and I couldn't even cut it. Sent back to the kitchen very disappointed

Lisa

The Millridge is always so beautiful and festive , but the food is just fine. It was a very special place before all the changes. I will continue to go as a tradition, but they really need to adjust it. 

Deborah

Food was awful! Was hoping they finally improved but was disappointed again. Won't be back!

Barbara

The Milleridge Inn is always a lovely place to visit this time of year. I've been going there for almost 25 years. I do remember a more traditional, old fashioned menu. I liked that better honestly. All in all it's still nice.

Eric

The Milleridge Inn is a classic, perhaps a bit stuck between generations. The ambience is "classic New England Inn" that, perhaps needs a bit of an update. The food (and I include the menu choices here) is....mundane. Don't mistake mundane for bad though; the food itself, prep and taste was quite good, just familiar. The service was also very good, but also routine. What was a bit off putting was the prices; a bit high for the overall package. Would I go back? Sure, especially for a holiday (Christmas) family meal. The holiday décor was nice, comfortable, and altogether appropriate for the season. I found the in-house advertisements for the "Holiday Specials" a bit much though. Overall, a nice place for a family to gather and eat, no fuss, no muss, and will bring smiles to most.

Julie

The ambiance it's spectacular. The service and food it's just average. Beautiful restaurant that could upgrade on their food. They have burgers and sandwiches for diner ... food presentation lacks imagination to make it attractive it truly looks like your mother just served you a plate of food at home.

Patty

I was looking forward to dining at the Milleridge Inn. Growing up, I used to go, not only at holidays, but throughout the year. At Christmas time they went all out! Decorations, music, carolers. To say this place has gone downhill is an understatement. Minimal decorations inside, hip hop music playing, no carolers. OK...so the village and outside are decorated over the top. It was beautiful. But this is about the restaurant. We sat down at 5:25. Ordered our drinks right away and they arrived within 5 minutes. Ordered our dinner immediately after. They were out of Pot Roast at 5:30 on a Friday evening. WHAT? So we both order the meatloaf. It wasn't minutes later they plunked down the dinner. Nothing was hot, just medium warm. The corn looked disgusting, the meatloaf was hard and salty but the mashed potatoes were ok. I would never go back again. I was so disappointed! Certainly not the same as when the Murphy's owned it!!

Hollie

Nothing beats the milleridge at Christmas time! Decorated so beautifully. Delicious food and great service.

Patricia

We were very disappointed with our lunch. First I received the wrong lunch. Our waitress then got the lunch I ordered. The flouder was under cooked and greasy. My husband received a hamburger that was just about burnt. On the menu it stated mushrooms and onion and cole slaw, which he didn't receive. And our lunch was way overpriced. Won't be going back to the milleridge Inn again.

Robert

We enjoyed our dinner at this festive time of year. The decorated shopping village adjacent to the restaurant was lots of fun. The food was good but not great, and the service was excellent considering the number of large parties that were being served at the same time. Set your expectations accordingly, and you will have a wonderful time.

Maureen

I love milleridge inn - there is no better place to go to get into the holiday spirit. The food was good, the staff is friendly. One of my favorite restaurants.

Joyce

The butternut squash soup was so delicious! Also enjoyed the short ribs grilled grilled cheese!

Lucy

We go to the Miller Ridge Inn every year for my sister‘s birthday and holiday cheer. It's always such a warm welcome back every year Fransisco our waiter was excellent.

Opentable Diner

Food was poorly prepared. Rubbery chicken with coagulated sauce , probably had been sitting out for a while. Chewy inedible steak and soup was overly sweet. Ambience is nice for holidays but whole family was nauseated for the little food we consumed that still came with a 200 bill.

Catherine

We had a great experience last night eating dinner. We usually go for the ambiance not having high hopes for the food based on past experiences but it was surprisingly amazing! Not sure looks like a bit different menu selections and maybe new chefs because every dish was better than the next. Apps we had Mac and cheese was creamy and the shells were perfectly cooked. Also had the calamari and made perfectly not chewy and very tasty. Both big portions. Two of us had the skirt steak cooked medium rare and other guests had the grilled cheese and lemon chicken. All were satisfied. Lastly the waiter -Luis was exceptionally good.

Loading...