AMAZING!! We got 2 pizzas both speciality & 2 orders of wings which were all delicious. Extremely crispy wings & crust on the pizza which makes it overall a 10/10 & everything was portioned really well together. It is honestly the best pizza i’ve tried & we will be returning.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Myrhia Zajaczkowski
Best food around. The pizza sauce and wing sauce are amazing!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Chicken Tenders, Wings, Mozzarella Sticks, New York Style Pizza
p turnbull
Ordered a pizza. Went to pick it up. Door is locked. So I gave a call and told them the door was locked. They told me 10 more minutes. Then they would unlock the door and give me the pizza. I wasn't have it. Wait outside. BYE. I didn't want pizza that bad.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Bradley Clark
Stopped in to grab a pizza on our way home. Great tasting pizza. Sauce was sweet but it worked well with the crust. No seating inside, so my wife and I sat on a park bench up the street and enjoyed the day.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brieanne Dorman
Amazing pizza and wings!!! Re-peat visitor ?
Food: 5
Eric Sleezer
Best pizza ever seen, and I travel plenty
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Vanwormer Sarah
Love their pizza. The sauce is the best
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Tenders
ILLxMaya
This place is like titanium, while other pizza places change with time and employee turnover, this place remains solid. Their pizza is crisp and lighter on grease than most New York-Style pizza(but still sufficient) with thin-crust, a moderate amount of cheese, and an Italian-style sauce that tastes greener than what I normally encounter(which I thoroughly enjoy). When I stop by, it's generally for their modestly priced lunch deals or the calzones they make on Wednesday. That's right, this majestic establishment also makes crispy, lightly-greased calzones on Wednesday. This was news to me that has only made my amorous bond with Market St. Pizza even stronger. "Entice me, almighty enticer" - Some Guy(2023).
Pat Del Transit Walls
No pizza anywhere in Johnstown. What's with these part time pizzerias? All pizzerias are closed from Sunday-Tuesday/Wednesday! Ridiculous!!!! Give other businesses opportunities if you're going to have your shop closed half the time. Smh
AP
As someone who lives near NYC I wasn’t expecting much from an upstate pizza place but wow! Pleasantly surprised. This pizza was great. Highly recommend if you’re in the area.
Gourmet pies. Will help you CUSTOMIZE your own. Out of this world Homespun dressings. Service, quality, top knotch PIZZA.
Laci Nellis
Terrible experience! I have never had any problems. I ordered two dozen wings and the box was broke so the wings fell into the bag. The night manager, Don, asked my boyfriend why we can’t eat them out of the bag. I originally called and explained the issue and then called my boyfriend to ask what really happened. He began screaming at me on the phone trying to tell me he knows a scam when he sees one. I offered to come to the store to show him and he told me that there was nothing wrong with the wings. Businesses like that can’t afford to lose loyal customers.
Valerie Cara
Decided to try some place new and loved their pizza. For several weeks I have ordered. Lastnight however, the pizza was completely different than every other week. Would you like some sauce w that sugar???
Meme Standon
The best options for goumet pizzas in this area that taste SUPERB. High quality ingredients, homeade dressings are amazing, huge portions and wonderful kind helpfully staff and owners. 10*******
AMAZING!! We got 2 pizzas both speciality & 2 orders of wings which were all delicious. Extremely crispy wings & crust on the pizza which makes it overall a 10/10 & everything was portioned really well together. It is honestly the best pizza i’ve tried & we will be returning.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Best food around. The pizza sauce and wing sauce are amazing!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Chicken Tenders, Wings, Mozzarella Sticks, New York Style Pizza
Ordered a pizza. Went to pick it up. Door is locked. So I gave a call and told them the door was locked. They told me 10 more minutes. Then they would unlock the door and give me the pizza. I wasn't have it. Wait outside. BYE. I didn't want pizza that bad.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Stopped in to grab a pizza on our way home. Great tasting pizza. Sauce was sweet but it worked well with the crust. No seating inside, so my wife and I sat on a park bench up the street and enjoyed the day.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing pizza and wings!!! Re-peat visitor ?
Food: 5
Best pizza ever seen, and I travel plenty
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Love their pizza. The sauce is the best
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Tenders
This place is like titanium, while other pizza places change with time and employee turnover, this place remains solid. Their pizza is crisp and lighter on grease than most New York-Style pizza(but still sufficient) with thin-crust, a moderate amount of cheese, and an Italian-style sauce that tastes greener than what I normally encounter(which I thoroughly enjoy). When I stop by, it's generally for their modestly priced lunch deals or the calzones they make on Wednesday. That's right, this majestic establishment also makes crispy, lightly-greased calzones on Wednesday. This was news to me that has only made my amorous bond with Market St. Pizza even stronger. "Entice me, almighty enticer" - Some Guy(2023).
No pizza anywhere in Johnstown. What's with these part time pizzerias? All pizzerias are closed from Sunday-Tuesday/Wednesday! Ridiculous!!!! Give other businesses opportunities if you're going to have your shop closed half the time. Smh
As someone who lives near NYC I wasn’t expecting much from an upstate pizza place but wow! Pleasantly surprised. This pizza was great. Highly recommend if you’re in the area.
Restaurantji Recommends
The best pizza ever!!! Try a monster ?
Gourmet pies. Will help you CUSTOMIZE your own. Out of this world Homespun dressings. Service, quality, top knotch PIZZA.
Terrible experience! I have never had any problems. I ordered two dozen wings and the box was broke so the wings fell into the bag. The night manager, Don, asked my boyfriend why we can’t eat them out of the bag. I originally called and explained the issue and then called my boyfriend to ask what really happened. He began screaming at me on the phone trying to tell me he knows a scam when he sees one. I offered to come to the store to show him and he told me that there was nothing wrong with the wings. Businesses like that can’t afford to lose loyal customers.
Decided to try some place new and loved their pizza. For several weeks I have ordered. Lastnight however, the pizza was completely different than every other week. Would you like some sauce w that sugar???
The best options for goumet pizzas in this area that taste SUPERB. High quality ingredients, homeade dressings are amazing, huge portions and wonderful kind helpfully staff and owners. 10*******