It looks like a cute little ice cream place in a small town, but they were out of most flavors and didn't have milk for milkshakes. The teenager behind the counter was obviously either high or had no idea how to work. I will not be returning.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Rachel M
Friendly staff, delicious ice cream made with milk from local cows. They had a few vegan options too and I got the oat based vanilla ice cream with a couple of maraschino cherries. It was delicious! I really liked they had chairs and tables that were the right size for kids too! Super cute place!!! I would definitely recommend getting ice cream here! It was October so he also had a few really good sounding soups and rolls for sale as well.
Myrna Marcarian
The best place to get ice cream and sit outside to eat it!! Beautiful place and people!
Mickie D.
Great food no matter what season. James is amazing to deal with. I love visiting the shop either to have the wonderful ice cream or the delicious soup and rolls in the colder months.
Deborah C
The owner is a delight! Very pleasant, the ice cream is the best in town and is all natural, and so is the service.
Jo L.
I love this little ice cream shop! There is always a nice variety of ice creams and generous portions. The owner is very nice and friendly. In the Summer they do live music on the weekends, too!
Michele M.
Incredible ice cream, lovely owners and fun music in the summers! Highly recommend!
M Hal
The location of Sticky Fingers is amazing, the ice cream is honestly the tastiest I've ever had, so very satisfactory and the owner "James" is very nice.
Lothar Lothar
Homemade ice cream that can't be beat. Worth the price because of its uniqueness.
Staff/Owner very friendly, kind to everyone. I've only had the ice cream, very creamy and delicious. Family friendly, we really enjoy Sticky Fingers.
Heather
This is the best ice cream I've ever had I had the lavender ice cream sooooo good the customer service is great we will definitely keep coming back here❤️
Daniel Sgroi
The ice cream is delicious. You can tell it is made with much love. Thank you!!
W C.
We stopped here for some much-needed treats after getting positively soaked to the bone at the outdoor concert in Bethel. Our daughter was a real trooper through it all so we wanted to do something special for her.We know about Sticky Fingers because they're the only local [to us] proprietor selling Jane's ice cream, which we all love, and which was a favorite of one of our late mom's. We like that they're open about using Jane's since it's such a high quality product and they don't pretend like it's their own ice cream. The shop is a tight squeeze and be forewarned that while service may be slow, it is extremely friendly, so you won't mind the wait and it will likely strike up a pleasant conversation with your fellow patrons. The vibe in here is chill and homey and we appreciated the welcoming ambience. There's a big patio outside to sit down and enjoy your ice creams.We were all happy with our flavors. One of us got peanut butter fudge and salty caramel pretzel. Both were excellent. The other got Almond Joy and cherry chocolate, and while we appreciated the inverse of the latter (chocolate ice cream with cherries instead of the typical other way around), the coconut on the Almond Joy was incredible...so rich! Our kiddo was equally happy with her killer chocolate.Overall, we had a really nice time here and were happy to support such a do-good/feel-good establishment. It's definitely worth a visit if you're in the area.
Delicious ice cream ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Coconut Almond Joy, Salted Caramel Pretzela, Cookies & Cream
It looks like a cute little ice cream place in a small town, but they were out of most flavors and didn't have milk for milkshakes. The teenager behind the counter was obviously either high or had no idea how to work. I will not be returning.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Friendly staff, delicious ice cream made with milk from local cows. They had a few vegan options too and I got the oat based vanilla ice cream with a couple of maraschino cherries. It was delicious! I really liked they had chairs and tables that were the right size for kids too! Super cute place!!! I would definitely recommend getting ice cream here! It was October so he also had a few really good sounding soups and rolls for sale as well.
The best place to get ice cream and sit outside to eat it!! Beautiful place and people!
Great food no matter what season. James is amazing to deal with. I love visiting the shop either to have the wonderful ice cream or the delicious soup and rolls in the colder months.
The owner is a delight! Very pleasant, the ice cream is the best in town and is all natural, and so is the service.
I love this little ice cream shop! There is always a nice variety of ice creams and generous portions. The owner is very nice and friendly. In the Summer they do live music on the weekends, too!
Incredible ice cream, lovely owners and fun music in the summers! Highly recommend!
The location of Sticky Fingers is amazing, the ice cream is honestly the tastiest I've ever had, so very satisfactory and the owner "James" is very nice.
Homemade ice cream that can't be beat. Worth the price because of its uniqueness.
Restaurantji Recommends
Delicious Ice cream; locally -sourced ingredients !
Staff/Owner very friendly, kind to everyone. I've only had the ice cream, very creamy and delicious. Family friendly, we really enjoy Sticky Fingers.
This is the best ice cream I've ever had I had the lavender ice cream sooooo good the customer service is great we will definitely keep coming back here❤️
The ice cream is delicious. You can tell it is made with much love. Thank you!!
We stopped here for some much-needed treats after getting positively soaked to the bone at the outdoor concert in Bethel. Our daughter was a real trooper through it all so we wanted to do something special for her.We know about Sticky Fingers because they're the only local [to us] proprietor selling Jane's ice cream, which we all love, and which was a favorite of one of our late mom's. We like that they're open about using Jane's since it's such a high quality product and they don't pretend like it's their own ice cream. The shop is a tight squeeze and be forewarned that while service may be slow, it is extremely friendly, so you won't mind the wait and it will likely strike up a pleasant conversation with your fellow patrons. The vibe in here is chill and homey and we appreciated the welcoming ambience. There's a big patio outside to sit down and enjoy your ice creams.We were all happy with our flavors. One of us got peanut butter fudge and salty caramel pretzel. Both were excellent. The other got Almond Joy and cherry chocolate, and while we appreciated the inverse of the latter (chocolate ice cream with cherries instead of the typical other way around), the coconut on the Almond Joy was incredible...so rich! Our kiddo was equally happy with her killer chocolate.Overall, we had a really nice time here and were happy to support such a do-good/feel-good establishment. It's definitely worth a visit if you're in the area.