Anderson's Frozen Custard

2235 Sheridan Dr, Kenmore
(716) 875-5952

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Roast Beef Sandwich
Frozen Custard
Carl's Choice
Beef on Weck
Cajun Fries
Strawberry
Onion Rings
Hot Fudge
Lemon Ice
BBQ Beef

Menu

Roast Beef & Turkey Sandwiches
All Natural Roast Beef Sandwich
Anderson's famous beef on weck. All natural roast beef traditionally on kimmelweck roll, most commonly dressed with horseradish. Made to your liking.
All Natural BBQ Beef Sandwich
All natural roast beef slow-cooked in Anderson's original tangy barbecue sauce.
All Natural Turkey Sandwich
All natural turkey with no additives. Served hot or cold. Prepared to your liking.

Burgers & Dogs
All Natural Blue Cheese Bacon Burger
All natural angus beef burger topped with blue cheese, bacon strips, lettuce & tomato.
All Natural Angus Beef Hamburger
No preservatives, additives or hormones. Includes your choice of condiments. Cheese not included.
Vegan Veggie Burger
Vegan Veggie Burger. Includes your choice of condiments and toppings.
Sahlen's Hot Dog
Flame grilled locally popular Sahlen's hot dog on a hotdog bun. Includes your choice of condiments and toppings.

Chicken & Fish Sandwiches
All Natural Buffalo Chicken Tender Sandwich
Our crisp, all natural chicken tenders tossed in Buffalo wing sauce, with lettuce and blue cheese
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
4oz chicken breast grilled to perfection, on a toasted roll with your choice of toppings.
Wild Caught Cod Fish Sandwich
Breaded wild caught cod, fried to perfection. Served standard with lettuce, tomato, and a side of tartar sauce.

Chicken Tender Baskets
Small Chicken Tender Basket w/ Fries
Served plain or Buffalo style, with your choice of dipping sauce. Contains wheat.
Large Chicken Tender Basket w/ Fries
Served plain or Buffalo style, with your choice of dipping sauce. Contains wheat.

Wraps
All Natural Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled all natural chicken breast, wrapped up with lettuce, cucumbers, almonds, parmesan cheese, and caesar dressing on a flour tortilla.
Vegan Veggie Wrap
Lettuce, tomatoes, red onion, cucumber, avocado, and balsamic vinaigrette on a flour wrap. Standard preparation is vegan.

Full Salads
Create Your Own Salad
Harvest Salad
Spring Salad
Mandarin Chicken Salad

Fries & Sides
Bacon, Cheese & Sour Cream Fries
Large order of golden curly cue fries topped with melted cheddar sauce, bacon, sour cream, and chives.
Curly Fries
Cajun Fries
Sweet Potato Fries
Onion Rings
Baked Potato
Homestyle Mac n' Cheese
Side Salad
Steamed Broccoli
Side of Root Veggies

Extra Sides
SIDE of Melted Cheddar
SIDE of Beef Gravy

Dippers & Dressing
SIDE of Ranch
SIDE of Blue Cheese
SIDE of Honey Mustard
SIDE of Buffalo Dipping Sauce
SIDE of BBQ Sauce
SIDE of Tartar Sauce
SIDE of Balsamic Vinaigrette
SIDE of Raspberry Vinaigrette
SIDE of Caesar Dressing
SIDE of Greek Dressing

Condiment Packets
Horseradish PC
Ketchup PC
Mustard PC
Mayo PC
Salt PC
Pepper PC
Honey PC
Butter PC

Kid's Meal
Kid's Meal

Fountain & Bottled Beverages
Fountain Drink
Bottled Drink
Bottled Water

Frozen Beverages
Milkshake
Malted Shake
Sensation
Vegan Shake

Classic Dishes
Signature Frozen Custard
Handmade Hard Ice Cream
Plant-Based Frozen Dessert
Flavored Ice

Signature Sundaes
Hot Caramel Apple Sundae
Sweet Treat of the Month! Our classic vanilla frozen custard smothered with hot caramel and apple toppings.
Reese's Pieces Sundae
Signature Vanilla Frozen Custard topped with hot fudge, peanut butter, and Reese's Pieces®
Turtle Sundae
Signature Vanilla Frozen Custard topped with hot fudge, hot caramel, and pecans.
Mexican Sundae
Signature Vanilla Frozen Custard topped with rich chocolate syrup and Spanish peanuts.
Banana Split
Vanilla & Chocolate Signature Frozen Custard in between two banana halves. Chocolate syrup, strawberry, and pineapple toppings. Topped with handmade whipped cream & chopped nuts
Brownie Overboard
Rich fudge brownie with vanilla & chocolate frozen custard, topped with hot fudge, handmade whipped cream & chopped nuts
Choco-Peanut Butter Passion
Chocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream, Hot Fudge, Peanut Butter, Peanut Butter Cookie, Whipped Cream & Reese's® Peanut Butter Cups
Create Your Own Sundae
Glacier Sundae

Arctic Swirls & Chiffons
Arctic Swirl
Cinnamon Toast Crunch Caramel Arctic Swirl
Our signature vanilla frozen custard blended with Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal, topped with hot caramel and whipped cream!
Chiffon

Whole Ice Cream Cakes
Candy Bar Snickers Cake
Vanilla and milk chocolate ice cream with a center layer of Snickers pieces and caramel, all topped with our chocolate icing, more snickers, caramel, and fudge.
Traditional Cake (Round)
Traditional Cake (Sheet)
Buffalo Football Cake (Round)
Buffalo Football Cake (Sheet)
Rainbow Fudge M&M Cake
Cookies & Cream Dream Cake
Cookie Dough Fudge Cake
Fudgie Turtle Cake
Mint Fudge Ganache Cake
Peanut Butter Fudge Ganache Cake

Whole Ice Cream Pies
Turtle Pie
Peanut Butter Fudge Pie
Mint Fudge Oreo Pie

Pie Slices & Big Wheels
Big Wheel
Ice Cream Pie Slice
Jumbo Chocolate Chip Big Wheel
Big Wheel 6-Pack

Hand-Packed Pints
Signature Frozen Custard (Pint)
Handmade Hard Ice Cream (Pint)
Flavored Ice (Pint)
Plant-Based Frozen Dessert (Pint)

Hand-Packed Pints (Game Day)
Signature Frozen Custard (Pint)
Handmade Hard Ice Cream (Pint)
Flavored Ice (Pint)
Plant-Based Frozen Dessert (Pint)

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+78 photos
Photo credit: google
+77 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

The roast beef and homemade ice cream were good as usual but the fries and onion rings were over cooked in old oil. The employees seemed confused by simple questions and couldn't find a lid for my ice cream to go without me telling them where to look which makes little sense because I'm not the one who works there. The prices are very high, $10.49 for a 3 oz roast beef sandwich, $6 for two scoops of hard ice cream(no toppings). Crazy.
October 2025
Haven’t been here in decades as we live out of state, but we needed a trip down memory lane. My wife loved the single cheeseburger and sweet potato fries. I had a Carl’s roast beef and it was excellent.
August 2025
Took my grandma and mother here for the first time. My mom loved the banana strawberry custard ice cream. My grandmother kept saying how good the chocolate custard was and I enjoyed the homemade cookies and cream. ❤️
August 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Jim's Steakout - 2180 Sheridan Dr
Cheesesteaks, Tacos, Vegetarian
Ted's Hot Dogs - 2312 Sheridan Dr
Hot Dogs, Burgers, Fast Food
Paula's Donuts - 2319 Sheridan Dr
Donuts, Bagels

Anderson's Frozen Custard

2235 Sheridan Dr, Kenmore, NY 14223
(716) 875-5952