Glad Chris brought this back to Buffalo and I love 2 streets away.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Garlic Fries, Rebel Pizza, Specialty Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Pizza Pie, Cheese Slice, Chicken Wings Quad 40, Guinea Pizza Pie, Naked City Pizza, Chicken Fingers Bucket 24, Side of Hot BBQ Sauce, Coke 20 Oz Bottle, Chicken Wings Single 10, Naked City, Guinea Pie, Naked Salad, Cheese Pizza 1 2 Sheet - 12 Slices, 1 2 Sheet Cheese Pepperoni Green Olives
Mark G
1st time ordering from here. Pizza was below average. Didn’t get all the items I asked for. Suicide French fries were horrid. Slopped “suicide” sauce and hot peppers on fries??? Soggy and medium sauce, at best.
Food: 2
Joseph Pecoraro
Amazing, unique pizza. Can't get enough of them. The guy who helped open this location printed menus in my store and he was super nice as well.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Guinea Pie
Shannon S.
Love this place! We get the food about once a week (oops!). Our personal favorite is when they run their French onion pizza special. They often announce their specials on Instagram so worth following their page. Plus 75¢ wings on Wednesdays which is hard to come by these days. Small, take out only, but in good weather there are some tables outside. The chicken fingers with the homemade blue cheese are inexplicably delicious. Also- gotta give their garlic sesame crust a try- soooo good!
Melissa Gloss
My favorite pizza I can’t eat red sauce and they have so many white sauce options best crust in
Food: 5
Deanna DiGiulio
Driving to friends, Saw the street sign for “Tuesday Special $15” large, one toppingTurned around, ordered, brought to friends houseAND it was the BEST PIZZA I have had in long time.Nice surpriseHighly recommend.. was huge, (for 2) melted hot & so deliciousCheese & mushroom ??
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ahmad Stevenson
Great slices if you love cheese. Crust really holds the slice
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Karen Brautman
My first visit but not my last.I ordered a Guinea pie and a Cheese & half Pepperoni pie.Both were delicious.My family is looking forward to ordering again soon.Really had great service as well as a friendly atmosphere at pick up.Thank you..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Guinea Pie
Steven Leffler
Very, VERY good pizza and fresh cut fries are the best. Only negative is their service can struggle at time (it seems to depend on who is working). Three times in a row now we’ve had to drive back for missing items. After the first time we should have learned our lesson and checked everything before we left, but the last two times our orders were picked up by our kids who didn’t double check. They were fantastic about getting our orders right, however, not one time were we offered any money off the next time or any item taken off the bill. We will order again, but make sure we check order before driving home.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Wings, Full Sheet Cheese Pizza 24 Slices
Meg C.
Great pizza and wings! I recommend the steak and three cheese pie with bbq wings! Not greasy and the wings are worth the price.
We picked up dinner from Naked City Pizza, which is a small takeout spot connected to Fanara's. The owners started with a Buffalo style pizza shop in Las Vegas, where Guy Fieri came for Diners, Drive-ins, and Dives. With success in Vegas, they figured they'd open a spot in Buffalo. We ordered the chicken and 3 cheese pizza, chicken fingers, seasoned fries, and suicide fries (which were featured on DD&D). We ordered online and it was ready for pickup in 40 minutes. It was strictly to-go...no table or counter seating. We ordered a half sheet, but to our surprise, they gave us a full sheet. Makes for an easy lunch on our continued stretch of snow days. My kids were not fans of the onions hidden beneath the cheese. They spent more time dissecting the pizza than eating it. The suicide fries had a delicious hot sauce and variety of hot peppers sliced on top... cherry, jalapeno, and banana peppers. Chicken Fingers were average. It was 75 cent wing night, but we didn't know about that before we arrived.
Michael Moretta
Really good pizza. Order on January 7th, Bills/Miami night game. Was worried quality would be lower because they were so busy, Nope, nailed it. Outside of the crust is crunchy, inside is soft. Sauce seems spicy but not off putting. Will be back for sure. Great pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Full Sheet Cheese Pizza 24 Slices
FRANK MAGGIO
The food is great I ordered it for a large birthday party and the people working there are friendly, they even sang happy birthday to my niece , the food was hot and the place is clean . I will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Full Sheet Cheese Pizza 24 Slices
Joseph Salamone
Was a bit skeptical based on the pricing but this was a tremendous value. Fresh and flavorful ingredients and the dough was thick, but still light and airy. HUGE wings for a great price.We will definitely be trying more!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Charlotte Miller
I ordered a pie last night — they were busy and said about 50 mins. no problem - I gave them an hour. When I showed up I was told that they didn’t have my pizza and they made a mistake. I said absolutely no problem just give me a few slices. When I got my slices they said they’re on the house and even gave me way more slices than I asked for. That is a true business man right there. The SLICES were amazing with their homemade blue cheese — didn’t miss a beat it tasted like i had just ordered this pie This pizza and pizza shop is amazing and they will always have my support and business y’all gotta come check them out they will never disappoint!
Glad Chris brought this back to Buffalo and I love 2 streets away.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Garlic Fries, Rebel Pizza, Specialty Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Pizza Pie, Cheese Slice, Chicken Wings Quad 40, Guinea Pizza Pie, Naked City Pizza, Chicken Fingers Bucket 24, Side of Hot BBQ Sauce, Coke 20 Oz Bottle, Chicken Wings Single 10, Naked City, Guinea Pie, Naked Salad, Cheese Pizza 1 2 Sheet - 12 Slices, 1 2 Sheet Cheese Pepperoni Green Olives
1st time ordering from here. Pizza was below average. Didn’t get all the items I asked for. Suicide French fries were horrid. Slopped “suicide” sauce and hot peppers on fries??? Soggy and medium sauce, at best.
Food: 2
Amazing, unique pizza. Can't get enough of them. The guy who helped open this location printed menus in my store and he was super nice as well.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Guinea Pie
Love this place! We get the food about once a week (oops!). Our personal favorite is when they run their French onion pizza special. They often announce their specials on Instagram so worth following their page. Plus 75¢ wings on Wednesdays which is hard to come by these days. Small, take out only, but in good weather there are some tables outside. The chicken fingers with the homemade blue cheese are inexplicably delicious. Also- gotta give their garlic sesame crust a try- soooo good!
My favorite pizza I can’t eat red sauce and they have so many white sauce options best crust in
Food: 5
Driving to friends, Saw the street sign for “Tuesday Special $15” large, one toppingTurned around, ordered, brought to friends houseAND it was the BEST PIZZA I have had in long time.Nice surpriseHighly recommend.. was huge, (for 2) melted hot & so deliciousCheese & mushroom ??
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great slices if you love cheese. Crust really holds the slice
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
My first visit but not my last.I ordered a Guinea pie and a Cheese & half Pepperoni pie.Both were delicious.My family is looking forward to ordering again soon.Really had great service as well as a friendly atmosphere at pick up.Thank you..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Guinea Pie
Very, VERY good pizza and fresh cut fries are the best. Only negative is their service can struggle at time (it seems to depend on who is working). Three times in a row now we’ve had to drive back for missing items. After the first time we should have learned our lesson and checked everything before we left, but the last two times our orders were picked up by our kids who didn’t double check. They were fantastic about getting our orders right, however, not one time were we offered any money off the next time or any item taken off the bill. We will order again, but make sure we check order before driving home.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Wings, Full Sheet Cheese Pizza 24 Slices
Great pizza and wings! I recommend the steak and three cheese pie with bbq wings! Not greasy and the wings are worth the price.
Restaurantji Recommends
We picked up dinner from Naked City Pizza, which is a small takeout spot connected to Fanara's. The owners started with a Buffalo style pizza shop in Las Vegas, where Guy Fieri came for Diners, Drive-ins, and Dives. With success in Vegas, they figured they'd open a spot in Buffalo. We ordered the chicken and 3 cheese pizza, chicken fingers, seasoned fries, and suicide fries (which were featured on DD&D). We ordered online and it was ready for pickup in 40 minutes. It was strictly to-go...no table or counter seating. We ordered a half sheet, but to our surprise, they gave us a full sheet. Makes for an easy lunch on our continued stretch of snow days. My kids were not fans of the onions hidden beneath the cheese. They spent more time dissecting the pizza than eating it. The suicide fries had a delicious hot sauce and variety of hot peppers sliced on top... cherry, jalapeno, and banana peppers. Chicken Fingers were average. It was 75 cent wing night, but we didn't know about that before we arrived.
Really good pizza. Order on January 7th, Bills/Miami night game. Was worried quality would be lower because they were so busy, Nope, nailed it. Outside of the crust is crunchy, inside is soft. Sauce seems spicy but not off putting. Will be back for sure. Great pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Full Sheet Cheese Pizza 24 Slices
The food is great I ordered it for a large birthday party and the people working there are friendly, they even sang happy birthday to my niece , the food was hot and the place is clean . I will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Full Sheet Cheese Pizza 24 Slices
Was a bit skeptical based on the pricing but this was a tremendous value. Fresh and flavorful ingredients and the dough was thick, but still light and airy. HUGE wings for a great price.We will definitely be trying more!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
I ordered a pie last night — they were busy and said about 50 mins. no problem - I gave them an hour. When I showed up I was told that they didn’t have my pizza and they made a mistake. I said absolutely no problem just give me a few slices. When I got my slices they said they’re on the house and even gave me way more slices than I asked for. That is a true business man right there. The SLICES were amazing with their homemade blue cheese — didn’t miss a beat it tasted like i had just ordered this pie This pizza and pizza shop is amazing and they will always have my support and business y’all gotta come check them out they will never disappoint!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5