Best restaurant in Lake George. Food is amazing!! Fresh ingredients.10 out of 10! You not only get a phenomenal meal at Mario's, but you get an experience...very romantic atmosphere. We love it here and will be coming back for years to come. Very special place.
Jason Sawn
The food was amazing however we waited entirely too long to get it. We watched tables come after us and finish eating while we waited. It wasn’t until we spoke to a manager to pay for the drinks so we could leave that our food appeared. They apologized several times and bought us desserts, this was a nice gesture however too little too late
Steve L
Very nice and friendly atmosphere with great and delicious food. Excellent service.
Angela Reade
We were a party of 4 for my husbands 70 birthday May 4. I ordered chicken Marsala it was so sweet it tasted like a sherry sauce. The waitress came over the rest of the group had finished and seen I only had one bite asked me if I would like something else as my group had all finished so I said no. She said she would show the kitchen as they needed to know when they messed up. No manager came over they charged for my meal. As it was my husbands 70th I did not want to fuss but believe that they should have voluntarily taken my meal off the check. We have 2 timeshares and have been going to Lake George for over 30 years. I was told that Mario’s have new owners so that’s it for us we normally go 1 time every time we are up there which is 6 times a year. Not anymore.
James Rafalik
Food = Yummy Paige was nice and its an underrated spot
pat kelly
Great place and food
DH f
Will will not be disappointed. Food has unbelievable flavor. Paige was our server she was amazing I recommend asking for her . My wife is gluten free and they went above and beyond . Her chicken parmesan was incredible.
Casandra Venditti
Food was excellent. Just know that if you have OCD you may struggle. The glasses on the tables aren’t the same size and it make drive you crazy.
shannon leckie
Took our two sons and 8 of their college buddies to Mario’s for dinner. Food was awesome and service was even better! Paige was our waitress; she was great and absolutely hysterical with the kids! We all had a blast and everyone loved their meals!
Marta Soto-Johnson
We had a delicious dinner with great service. Our server recommended the lasagna with the homemade sausage sauce. The serving size was perfect for one adult and the sauce was perfect if you like a little heat with your food. The salads and bread were fresh. The beef braciole, chicken piccata, and the rib eye satisfied the rest of the dinner party. We saved no room for dessert as the food was so delicious.
What an absolute gem! This quaint Italian restaurant in Lake George delivered an unforgettable dining experience. From the moment we walked in, we were enveloped in a cozy, welcoming atmosphere that felt like stepping into a little corner of Italy.
The menu was a perfect balance of classic Italian dishes and unique chef specialties. Every dish we tried was incredible—the pasta was cooked to perfection, the sauces were rich and flavorful, even the bread was great!
The staff were warm, attentive, and genuinely passionate about making our meal special. Their recommendations were spot-on, and they made us feel right at home.
Whether you’re looking for a romantic dinner, a family meal, or just a fantastic dining experience, this place is a must-visit. We’ll definitely make it a regular stop whenever we’re in Lake George. Bravo to the chef and the whole team! 🍝🍷✨
Johnny Kincanon
What a pleasure to eat here, met the owner and you could hear how determined she is to prepare healthy, fresh and delicious food. She succeeded!
Hadden Blair
So this isn't an authentic, fine dining Italian restaurant. It is a classic American Italian restaurant that has it all. The vibe, the food, and the service are old school classic. If that's what you're looking for, you won't be disappointed
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Clams Casino, Chicken Marsala
Al Mit
Because we had 5 in our party, we were placed a large table in the back of the restaurant close to restrooms, the kitchen and bar. Tight and busy area. A little bothersome because of frequent acknowledgements from staff that they were close to brushing me or each other as they were hurriedly shuttling about. Kinda made me pay more attention to the staff than I wanted.
Food was excellent and well presented.
Staff was working very hard as it was peak time and it felt like maybe too hard or something. Utterances overheard while passing through indicated some frustration. A little more information that I needed to have a good night out. I expected a low key, easy night out with my family. Maybe that's my fault. Didn't know the place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Veal Parmigiana, Chicken Parmigiana, Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken, Shrimp Scampi Ala Mario, Minestrone Soup
John S
Excellent Italian food. Came here as a child with my parents, 28 years later, restaurant still doing a great job. They were short staffed being off season, but our waitress Janet did a great job despite all the tables she needed to service. Thanks Janet!
Best restaurant in Lake George. Food is amazing!! Fresh ingredients.10 out of 10! You not only get a phenomenal meal at Mario's, but you get an experience...very romantic atmosphere. We love it here and will be coming back for years to come. Very special place.
The food was amazing however we waited entirely too long to get it. We watched tables come after us and finish eating while we waited. It wasn’t until we spoke to a manager to pay for the drinks so we could leave that our food appeared. They apologized several times and bought us desserts, this was a nice gesture however too little too late
Very nice and friendly atmosphere with great and delicious food. Excellent service.
We were a party of 4 for my husbands 70 birthday May 4. I ordered chicken Marsala it was so sweet it tasted like a sherry sauce. The waitress came over the rest of the group had finished and seen I only had one bite asked me if I would like something else as my group had all
finished so I said no. She said she would show the kitchen as they needed to know when they messed up. No manager came over they charged for my meal. As it was my husbands 70th I did not want to fuss but believe that they should have voluntarily taken my meal off the check. We have 2 timeshares and have been going to Lake George for over 30 years. I was told that Mario’s have new owners so that’s it for us we normally go 1 time every time we are up there which is 6 times a year. Not anymore.
Food = Yummy Paige was nice and its an underrated spot
Great place and food
Will will not be disappointed. Food has unbelievable flavor. Paige was our server she was amazing I recommend asking for her . My wife is gluten free and they went above and beyond . Her chicken parmesan was incredible.
Food was excellent. Just know that if you have OCD you may struggle. The glasses on the tables aren’t the same size and it make drive you crazy.
Took our two sons and 8 of their college buddies to Mario’s for dinner. Food was awesome and service was even better! Paige was our waitress; she was great and absolutely hysterical with the kids! We all had a blast and everyone loved their meals!
We had a delicious dinner with great service. Our server recommended the lasagna with the homemade sausage sauce. The serving size was perfect for one adult and the sauce was perfect if you like a little heat with your food. The salads and bread were fresh. The beef braciole, chicken piccata, and the rib eye satisfied the rest of the dinner party. We saved no room for dessert as the food was so delicious.
Restaurantji Recommends
What an absolute gem! This quaint Italian restaurant in Lake George delivered an unforgettable dining experience. From the moment we walked in, we were enveloped in a cozy, welcoming atmosphere that felt like stepping into a little corner of Italy.
The menu was a perfect balance of classic Italian dishes and unique chef specialties. Every dish we tried was incredible—the pasta was cooked to perfection, the sauces were rich and flavorful, even the bread was great!
The staff were warm, attentive, and genuinely passionate about making our meal special. Their recommendations were spot-on, and they made us feel right at home.
Whether you’re looking for a romantic dinner, a family meal, or just a fantastic dining experience, this place is a must-visit. We’ll definitely make it a regular stop whenever we’re in Lake George. Bravo to the chef and the whole team! 🍝🍷✨
What a pleasure to eat here, met the owner and you could hear how determined she is to prepare healthy, fresh and delicious food. She succeeded!
So this isn't an authentic, fine dining Italian restaurant. It is a classic American Italian restaurant that has it all. The vibe, the food, and the service are old school classic. If that's what you're looking for, you won't be disappointed
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Clams Casino, Chicken Marsala
Because we had 5 in our party, we were placed a large table in the back of the restaurant close to restrooms, the kitchen and bar. Tight and busy area. A little bothersome because of frequent acknowledgements from staff that they were close to brushing me or each other as they were hurriedly shuttling about. Kinda made me pay more attention to the staff than I wanted.
Food was excellent and well presented.
Staff was working very hard as it was peak time and it felt like maybe too hard or something. Utterances overheard while passing through indicated some frustration. A little more information that I needed to have a good night out. I expected a low key, easy night out with my family. Maybe that's my fault. Didn't know the place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Veal Parmigiana, Chicken Parmigiana, Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken, Shrimp Scampi Ala Mario, Minestrone Soup
Excellent Italian food. Came here as a child with my parents, 28 years later, restaurant still doing a great job. They were short staffed being off season, but our waitress Janet did a great job despite all the tables she needed to service. Thanks Janet!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...