Number 1 Pizza

509 Canada St, Lake George
(518) 685-3424

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Joelene Godfrey-Lawson

I paid $40 for a large pizza with broccoli and mushrooms and a large fry. I was shocked when she said $40, no wonder they don’t print the prices on their menu. The fries weren’t cooked they were raw. The pizza barely had toppings and was very greasy and inedible. There were 2 what I thought would be garlic knots in the pizza box, not sure why but they were a slice of pepperoni in dough and hard as a rock. The complementary 4 garlic knots were hard and very salty, again not edible. I hadn’t been up there in years so I thought why not. Never again. $40 elsewhere would get me a heck of a lot more food that is actually edible.

Kari Col

Hidden Gem Just Outside the Village – A Must-Visit! We thought we were just stopping in for a quick slice… and ended up with a full, unforgettable Italian meal! Just minutes from the hustle of downtown Lake George, Number 1 Pizza feels like stepping into someone’s home—if that someone happens to be an incredible Italian cook. The specials drew us in, and we’re so glad they did. Everything is homemade—from the rich, savory sauce to the perfectly seasoned meatballs. The lasagna was layered with love, and the manicotti, made with delicate crepes, was hands-down the best we’ve ever had. You can taste the care and tradition in every bite. The owners are genuinely welcoming, the atmosphere is cozy and unpretentious, and the food is the real star. This place isn’t just about pizza (though we hear that’s great too)—it’s a full-on Italian comfort food experience you won’t want to miss. If you’re in Lake George, make the short drive. We will be back!

George Gregory Jr.

The owners are old school. Done right. It may take a little longer than normal, Rome wasn’t built in a day. Clean and tasty. Worth the wait.

JOSEPH DINAPOLI

Best pizza in the region made by a real Italian chef making pizza the way it should be made

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mac MacDonald

They make the best pizza ever, thin with a great crust and their toppings are the best no cheap cheese or oil dripping from the pepperoni, by far the best pizza in the area you must try it for yourself. Mac Mac Donald

Andrew Short

Food was just alright.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Penne Alla Vodka with Chicken Cutlet

Bonnie Murray

Best place for home made Italian food 😋 We have tried many dishes and love them all. The owner is the sweetest person .

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Homemade Cannoli, Cannoli, Penne Alla Vodka with Chicken Cutlet

Samantha Grasso

THE BEST OLD SCHOOL ITALIAN YOU COULD ASK FOR!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Ravioli, Chicken Fingers, Cajun Fries, Chicken Caesar Salad, Combination Pizza, Personal Pepperoni Pie, Mini Pepperoni Rolls, White Pizza, Chicken Wings, Homemade Cannoli, Chicken Parmesan Panini, Chicken Parmigiana, Penne Alla Vodka with Chicken Cutlet, Chicken Caesar, 12 Inch Pizza

Michael Hoffarth

Food was absolutely the worst I've had in a very long time, as I barely write reviews but felt the need to write this one. I spent almost 70 dollars on a Large pizza and 2 orders of wings. The pizza was below average at best. And the wings were absolutely terrible, and for 20 dollars a order please save your money and do not ever order here. We are staying at the campground up the road and I will forever remember never to go here.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Lauren R

$70 for a pizza and 2 orders of wings the pizza was mediocre but the wings...I HATE wasting food, but I literally could not stomach them! They weren't real chicken wings, they filled with hard chunks you couldn't chew through. I have never had chicken wings like this in my life, I am really unsure how they have been able to continue to serve them. They are doughy and filled with rubber chunks, super disappointed ? maybe the other food is great, I can't speak to that. But steer clear of the wings ?

Quinn Davis

Delicious! Great pizza!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: 12 Inch Pizza

Michael Hoffarth

below average pizza and wings were the worst I've ever had. whoever writes these reviews are full of it. I just spend 70 dollars of my hard earned money for the worst meal I've had all year . 1 quote on quote large pepperoni pizza and 2 orders of wings for my family that no one could eat besides me because I forced myself because I payed the money.

Sam Ima

It number one??

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Pat Richards

We came with the recommendation of a friend who visits Lake George often. The food is spectacular, freshly made with true Italian ingredients. Came back two nights in a row. Service is impeccable. Certainly more than pizza. Lasagna is terrific. Ravioli with bolognese was superb. Can’t do better.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Ravioli

Arthur Parent

This was our second time eating there and we enjoyed the food. Very good.

Parking: Plenty of parking

Kid-friendliness: Very friendly

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana, Large Pizza

Loading...