Anderson's is a must stop if you're going out to dinner. My rule is if you're going to Ted's Hot Dogs which is across the street, you must stop at Anderson's for ice cream. The variety of ice cream and soda floats are unbeatable. For those who are not from Western New York, Anderson's is a local staple that you have to stop at.
The prices are reasonable and the experience is one to remember
Sharon Bauer
Took my granddaughter for a flu shot and told her if she was brave a treat would follow. She picked Anderson for ice cream. We ordered and when I went to pay the girl said whenever it snows ice cream is half price. I thanked her and felt great that I saved money for a great ice cream treat. Thanks Andersons will have to remember when it snows to go for half price ice cream.
connor krumpek
I stopped into today at around 4pm and Logan was very helpful to me and my family. It is nice to know that our future is in good hands
Katie Casey
The food is so overpriced. You pay $10.49 for 3 oz of meat.. and no fries. I can go to a local restaurant for 6oz of meat, and fries for $16 that is of higher quality. I know prices have gone up but this is ridiculous. They have a bunch of kids making your order. I do not recommend.
Courtney Sorrento
$10 for a sundae. Note to self: just go to the supermarket. 😐
Viv G
Now we are making frozen custard that don’t melt anymore? They taste different than when the owner is still alive. Won’t be going back
Maryann Knighton
11/16/25 I purchased 2 beef sandwiches at approximately $15 each that didn't have enough meat on them to qualify as a $8 sandwich. We have always liked Anderson beef but at their current prices and quality we will no longer be patronizing their establishment.
Suneel Ram
I got a cheeseburger and a custard twist and it was delicious! Gina was really helpful and provided great customer service!
Bill Songin
Great ice cream and good roast beef sandwiches!
Joe Damato
Great beef, good ice cream, very clean with good employees
Literally the worst drive-thru. Ive literally been sitting here for 20 mins waiting for a chicken finger basket while the kids that run the place socialize.
Angelique Hamilton
Had a beef on weck, which was excellent, but it did not look like photo. I expected a slightly larger sandwich meatwise for cost.
Lex Z
Solid place to go for ice cream. The custard is great here. The service is okay, not great. But most of them are youngsters so maybe they're just learning. We love their ice cream sandwiches to go. The season peach sundae wasn't all that great, not worth the extra money. I wish I ordered just their classic custard or something. Overall, I would recommend this ice cream spot.
Jessica Campbell
There food is very good, but the drive-thru is so slow. Only compliant I have.
Marvin Shantler
Extra horse radish wasn't fresh that Cheektowaga one sucks
Anderson's is a must stop if you're going out to dinner. My rule is if you're going to Ted's Hot Dogs which is across the street, you must stop at Anderson's for ice cream. The variety of ice cream and soda floats are unbeatable. For those who are not from Western New York, Anderson's is a local staple that you have to stop at.
The prices are reasonable and the experience is one to remember
Took my granddaughter for a flu shot and told her if she was brave a treat would follow. She picked Anderson for ice cream. We ordered and when I went to pay the girl said whenever it snows ice cream is half price. I thanked her and felt great that I saved money for a great ice cream treat. Thanks Andersons will have to remember when it snows to go for half price ice cream.
I stopped into today at around 4pm and Logan was very helpful to me and my family. It is nice to know that our future is in good hands
The food is so overpriced. You pay $10.49 for 3 oz of meat.. and no fries. I can go to a local restaurant for 6oz of meat, and fries for $16 that is of higher quality. I know prices have gone up but this is ridiculous. They have a bunch of kids making your order. I do not recommend.
$10 for a sundae. Note to self: just go to the supermarket. 😐
Now we are making frozen custard that don’t melt anymore? They taste different than when the owner is still alive. Won’t be going back
11/16/25 I purchased 2 beef sandwiches at approximately $15 each that didn't have enough meat on them to qualify as a $8 sandwich. We have always liked Anderson beef but at their current prices and quality we will no longer be patronizing their establishment.
I got a cheeseburger and a custard twist and it was delicious! Gina was really helpful and provided great customer service!
Great ice cream and good roast beef sandwiches!
Great beef, good ice cream, very clean with good employees
Restaurantji Recommends
Literally the worst drive-thru. Ive literally been sitting here for 20 mins waiting for a chicken finger basket while the kids that run the place socialize.
Had a beef on weck, which was excellent, but it did not look like photo. I expected a slightly larger sandwich meatwise for cost.
Solid place to go for ice cream. The custard is great here. The service is okay, not great. But most of them are youngsters so maybe they're just learning. We love their ice cream sandwiches to go. The season peach sundae wasn't all that great, not worth the extra money. I wish I ordered just their classic custard or something. Overall, I would recommend this ice cream spot.
There food is very good, but the drive-thru is so slow. Only compliant I have.
Extra horse radish wasn't fresh that Cheektowaga one sucks
Loading...