Frosty's Ice Cream

5500 Broadway, Lancaster
(716) 697-1812

Recent Reviews

Sort by
KCF

The ice cream is very good, the price is more then fair & the amount of ice cream they pile into a cone is obscene! But...the place is really run down. There are several wooden playground vehicles made for kids to play on that have rot & broken pieces, exposed nails & screws sticking from loose boards. Standing water & algae in buckets on the property. I know this is a historic building & not much can be done to it but the property is in need of a good power wash & overhaul.

Jakaka

Ice cream was delicious. Buffalo dough and canolie on a waffle cone. Two scoops was more than enough. Great prices highly recommend

Charmaine W

Awesome

Amy K

Never have a complaint about this ice cream stand. Always quick, Ice cream delicious and definitely a good amount and not expensive.
This is my go-to place for ice cream in Lancaster

Jamillah Burchett

Got the ice cream nachos 1000/10 i highly recommend this location! It was such a cute ice cream stand aswell with a cool waiting area especially if you have children ! Service was immaculate and the employees were all so sweet and accommodating! Also this location is cash only but they have an ATM!

Kaila Brown

Awesome Ice Cream!!! Best I ever had!

Donna Wlosinski

A cute little ice cream spot that was a gas station way back when on Broadway in Lancaster! Been going since it opened in the early 2000's because I lived down the street I took my grandson then now we went with his girlfriend and he is almost 25 years old! I had a baby coneof blueberry cheesecake ice cream was delicious plenty of cheesecake and blueberry! My grandson had warm brownie Sunday with whipped cream and chocolate sauce was plenty and every part of it was delicious! His girlfriend had a baby strawberry daiquiri was very good and just enough . The staff was friendly and helpful to our questions! Even a couple of wooden trains for the kids to play in. Great for all ages

Annamae Scheuerman

Great spot with creative ice cream. Try the nachos

Jennifer Brown

Ice cream portions are big- worth the money.
Staff was not friendly or welcoming

Brian Marafino

Great little ice cream spot with many varieties

Paul Smith

Best place to have ice-cream

Brian Evers

Great selection.

Audrey Concialdi

Love this ice cream spot! Amazing ice cream and even better pricing!! Love the outdoor area for my kids to play too.

Daniel Benitez

The best ice cream ever in Buffalo area and the world 🤩🥰❤️excelent staff and very good prices

Lexi O'Keefe

I've been going here since I was a kid and it's just a regular staple every single summer. They have a lot of Perry's ice cream flavors along with many other options. They even have a decent vegan menu. I love when they have weekly flavors or alcoholic ice cream flavors. Service is great and I'll continue to go until the fall! As a tidbit make sure you have cash, but they do have an ATM available

Loading...