Frosty's Ice Cream
5500 Broadway, Lancaster
(716) 697-1812
Customers' Favorites
Chocolate Dipped Waffle Cone
Peanut Butter Sundae
Chocolate Ice Cream
With Hard Ice Cream
Ice Cream Cone
Cotton Candy
Hot Fudge
Sundaes
Soft
Cake
Menu
Photos
+25 photos
+24 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I've been going here since I was a kid and it's just a regular staple every single summer. They have a lot of Perry's ice cream flavors along with many other options. They even have a decent vegan menu. I love when they have weekly flavors or alcoholic ice cream flavors. Service is great and I'll continue to go until the fall! As a tidbit make sure you have cash, but they do have an ATM available
Step into a Lancaster tradition at Frosty's, a long-time local favorite that consistently earns high praise. You can't miss their distinctive building right on Broadway, complete with a convenient play area in front for children.
Ordering is a seamless experience: just approach the window to select from a vast array of ice creams, shakes, and other unique specialties, then collect your delicious treat at the opposing window. One of the best surprises?...
Ordering is a seamless experience: just approach the window to select from a vast array of ice creams, shakes, and other unique specialties, then collect your delicious treat at the opposing window. One of the best surprises?...
The huge selection offers something for everybody and they're constantly keeping things fresh with new flavors! I am constantly impressed by all the different dessert creations and you can tell that they truly love what they do and put a lot of care into the menu. Very generous scoop sizes and always tasty!
You May Also Like
Lancaster's Broadway Deli - 5430 Broadway
![]()
Sandwich Shop, Cafe, Gluten-Free, American, Pet Friendly
Lancaster Coffee Co. & Cafe - 24 Central Ave
![]()
Cafe, American, Coffee & Tea, Juice Bar & Smoothies, Pet Friendly