Settler's Select

37 Main St, Le Roy
(585) 502-5282

Recent Reviews Reserve

Customers' Favorites

Fried Green Tomatoes

French Onion Burger

Mozzarella Sticks

Home Fries

Pancakes

Steak

Photos

+20 photos

+19 photos

Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I went to Settler's with two couples. There was only one waitress at lunch time that I saw. This woman was working like crazy. We waited 20+ minutes to order, which we understood. When the food came I was disappointed with my Greek salad. The salad had kalamata olives with pits and I wasn't warned about that. Most restaurants I have dined at have pitless olives. The Greek dressing was awful, no flavor, taste or spices. Another woman ordered a grilled tuna and...

July 2025

I fully enjoyed the Apollo salad special. The steak was perfect. Scott's service was great and he went above and beyond to meet my dietary restriction. I should also clarify that the $20 - $30 price was with dessert and/or alcoholic beverage.

July 2025

Had a GREAT dinner here. I am a sucker for an old fashioned turkey sammie with gravy over everything. This gravy did not disappoint!
The lemony marscapone cake was delicious!
Service was excellent, our guy stopped often to see if we needed anything.

July 2025

More Reviews

Restaurants in Le Roy, NY

Settler's Select

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Settler's Select