Sweet Surrender Bake House
297 Wantagh Ave, Levittown
(516) 731-2424
Customers' Favorites
Cinnamon Sugar Jelly Donut
Croissant - Cannoli Donut
Rainbow Cookie Cake
Bread Pudding Cake
Chocolate Cupcake
Cheesecake Slice
Seasonal Pastries
Butter Cookies
Birthday Cake
Rainbow Cake
Seasonal Specialty
Apple Cider Cake
Bread
Italian Seeded Bread
Italian Plain Bread
French Bread
Rye Plain - Small Bread
Rye Seeded - Small Bread
Rye Seeded - Large Bread
Six Grain Bread
Cinnamon Raisin Bread
Rolls
Kaiser Roll - Everything
Onion Roll
12 Assorted Rolls
1/2 Dozen Assorted Rolls
Kaiser Roll - Plain
Kaiser Roll - Sesame seed
Kaiser Roll - Poppy Seed
Baked Specialty
Crumb Bun
Rainbow Bar
Raspberry Crumb Bar
Brownie - Choc Chip
Cheese Horn
Brownie - Walnut
Salt Stick
Brownie - Gluten Free
Almond Horn Cookie
Apple Turnover - Small
Cinnamon Raisin Bun
Cheese Bun
Croissants
Baked Croissant
Scones
Choc Chip Scone
Maple Pecan Scone
Blue Berry Scone
Cranberry Orange Scone
Pies
Brownie Pie Choc Chip
Apple Pie
Cherry Pie
Blueberry Pie
Apple Crumb Pie
Blueberry Crumb Pie
Banana Cream Pie
Choc Cream Pie
Pound Cakes
Crumb Square Plain
Chocolate Drizzle
Raspberry Swirl
Philly Fluff Plain
Philly Fluff Choc Chip
Raspberry Crumb Cake
Crumb Square Apple
Sugar Free Pound Cake Marble
Sugar Free Pound Cake Blueberry
Cheesecakes
Marble Cheesecake w/Ganache - Small 6inch
Rainbow Cheesecake - Large 8inch
Rainbow Cheesecake - Small 6inch
Plain Cheesecake - Small 6inch
Fruit Filling Topped Cheesecake - Small 6inch
S/F Cheesecake - Small 6inch
Plain Cheesecake - Large 8inch
Marble Cheesecake w/Ganache - Large 8inch
Butter Cream Cakes
Shadow Cake
All Vanilla
Reeses Peanut Butter Cake
Whipped Cream Cakes
Black Forest Cake
Cannoli Cake
Congo Cake
Strawberry Shortcake
Berry Delight Cake
Fudge Cakes
All Chocolate Cake
7 Layer Cake
Vanilla Swirl Cake
Pudding Cakes
Jelly Donut Bread Pudding Cake
Bread Pudding Cake
Semi Sweet Chocolate Cakes
Chocolate Mousse Cake
Rainbow Cake
Cream Cheese Cakes
Carrot Cake
Red Velvet Cake
Muffins
Marble Muffin
Chocolate Chip Muffin
Sugar Free Blueberry Muffin
Sugar Free Marble Muffin
Corn Muffins
Oat Bran Muffin
Apple Muffin
Blueberry Muffin
Donuts
Double Filled Strawberry Donut
1/2 Dozen Assorted Donuts
French Cruller - Vanilla
Power Sugar - Cream Donut
Cinnamon Sugar Donut
Twists/Round Donut
French Cruller - Choc
12 Assorted Donuts
Cookies
Linzer Tart Cookie
1/2 LB Box of Assorted Butter Cookies
1LB Box of Assorted Butter Cookies
1/2 LB Box of Rainbow Cookies
1/2 LB Box of Assorted Butter Cookies **Nut-Free*
Fudge Mountain Cookie
Rainbow Sprinkled Cookie
Character Cookie
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
Triple Chunk Cookie
Coconut Macaroon Large
1LB Box of Assorted Butter Cookies **Nut-Free**
Reese s Cookie
Black & White Cookie
1LB Box of Rainbow Cookies
Small Cookie Tray (Little under 1lb )
Medium Cookie Tray (Over 1.5 lb )
Rugelach (27.45/Lb)
Coconut Macaroon Small (23.75/Lb)
Pastries
Cupcake - Vanilla
Cupcake - Chocolate
Cream Puff
Cannoli Large
Cake Pops (choc, RV, cookie dough, funfetti, oreo)
Key Lime Tart
Black Out Pastry
Cannoli Cookie Sandwich
Cannoli Small
Eclair Small
Weekend Speciality
Onion Pockets
Meltaway
Apple Strudel
Blueberry Turnover
Crumb Custard Cake
Photos
+85 photos
+84 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I loved the variety of cakes, small desserts and pastries offered. The staff was very attentive and helpful. I bought a chocolate mousse cake, a few breakfast pastries and Italian bread. The place is clean and even with a short line of customers, I didn't feel rushed or had to wait long to receive assistance. I would definitely come back for future purchases.
September 2025
Absolutely incredible always a pleasure shopping at Sweet surrender The peanut butter devil's food combination that I got for my friend's birthday was out of this world definitely will be back for that on top of all of the other items I love from this location seven layer cake to die for it's out of stock usually because people love it so much
August 2025
I recently placed an order from this bakery for my office, and it was my very first experience with them absolutely amazing! The French strawberry vanilla cake stole the show and has officially become my new favorite. The flavor was perfectly balanced, fresh, and indulgent. I’ll definitely be coming back for more!
August 2025
You May Also Like
Italian ice - 299 Wantagh Ave
![]()
Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Juice Bar & Smoothies, Dessert
Ralph's Italian Ices - 301 Wantagh Ave
![]()
Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Juice Bar & Smoothies, Ice Cream
THAT PIZZA PLACE IN LEVITTOWN - 303 Wantagh Ave
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Vegan, Vegetarian