Pancho's Pizza & Wings

25 Sullivan Ave, Liberty
(845) 747-9686

Recent Reviews

Sharon gifford-peduto

They're regular Pizza is a bit greasy. It's a family owned restaurant who have been around for years.Unfortunately they moved to a much larger location, which lacks atmosphere.This move made their prices go up. 1 large plain pizza is $16.00. Buffalo wing pizza $20.00 plus. Too expensive for the quality of food.Plenty of parking.Kid-friendliness: It's a family restaurant.Wheelchair accessibility: Huge doors and plenty of empty space. Tables all around the walls nothing in the middle of restaurant.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Aimeé Danielle

I love their pizza!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Pizza to Go

Michael Marmur

Fabulous pizza!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Patriotic American

I once left a bad review of this place due to a single worker there being miserable.This place shouldn't suffer because of someone they were probably desperate to hire in the first place.So I'm updating now after finding out that they hired new staff.The food here is fantastic.The owner is a great guy.The new staff is very friendly.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ashley Weintraub

Unfortunately Paesanos was closed, leaving this as my only option. I called and placed my order, verified my toppings twice over the phone, verified my topping a third time while paying an arm and a leg to come home and find out half my toppings were wrong. Sauce had way too much garlic and the middle of the pie was soggy. Will not return.

Richard Vosburgh

Nice cashier,Pizza crust was like cardboard and a little burned, greasy, sauce had large amount of full stems of basil and something else like the size of spinach leaves. Was not happy with just plain cheese and

Food: 1

Service: 4

Christopher Armstrong

Talk about sauce, it's tasty, talk about crust, delicious !Place is a dump, but pizza is fantastic

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza to Go

Scott Huggler

Either They don't answer the phone or answer and don't

Stephen A.

Amazing food, super friendly service and a beautiful dining room, and oh, did I mention the prices are more than reasonable? It seems everywhere I go, the prices go up, but here the quality of the food is outrageous and the price cannot be beat! Highly recommended.

Patricia Grant

We stopped in for slices , they served them to us cold and the cook who took our order had an attitude and call the waitress over, and was rude to her, we were there at 4:00 on August 20, will not be back

Milon B

Pizza and service was good but inside need a interior upgrade. Inside have a lot of potential if you do it right.

ALEX

Basic pizza it is good though.....there white cheese slices are the best ... wings are too expensive..

david gillmer

I've eaten pizza all around the area. Pancho's is the best. Best crust. Best flavor. Chicken wings are big and juicy. Good variety of sauces, medium wings are tangy and vinegar forward with good spice level. Get here.

MELISSA TSCHERSCH

A great value, two slices with pepperoni for $6.50, however, this is the type of place reminds me of diners who would literally eat anything. The crust on my Neapolitan pizza was overcooked, completely burnt, and stone cold. The dining room is a huge waste of space. Perhaps Gordan Ramsey could teach the owner a few things about running a kitchen. A huge menu, 5 tables and pizza that was sitting on the counter for hours. I say "DON'T BOTHER."

Jeremy Male

The place has nasty food and as of today they have a stop working order on the door ? I guess we don't have to wonder why that is

Load More