Star Gelt Cafe

1158 NY-52, Loch Sheldrake
(845) 436-6774

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Duvid G

Don’t even give it a try!Stay as far away as possible!The food may not be as terrible, but the WAITERS are just TERRIBLE THUGS with BELOW ZERO UNDERSTANDING;A elderly couple next to me was waiting starved for over 1:25 just to realize that their order IS NOT EVEN IN, they just stood up and left the place, to my left there was a angry family experiencing the same and started demanding a response from the waiter, there was no one to communicate with, it felt like a war zone, I ended up leaving the premises after waiting over an hour without even getting served!

A Goldminer

We came here for brunch. The place is a deck over a lake, old but with a charm and is very relaxing with nice scenic views. The restaurant is ran in a very traditional way and the waiters still take your orders only by table service and still use a calculator for your bill. It reminded me of the ol nostalgic catskills region and is really a good place for unwinding yourself.The service though was terrible, they were way to understafed and the waiters and the kitchen couldn't get their act together. It took them a half hour till they were able to just take my order. And almost equal to have my food ready.The food was simple but homey tasting but very overpriced plus gradatute of 20% for a waiter that I had no gradatute at all.I loved the vibe and the feel of this restaurant but the service needs some real improvement so I can come back and really enjoy this place.

rachel mayer

Beautiful scenic place. Delicious hearty food!

Dovber Friedman

It's ok

Carlos Chimbote

Best view and best dairy Kosher restaurant in the Catskills!

Zach Schwartz

Food is ok. Service is awful

Alexander Yakovis

Food is not fancy but ok.

isaac klein

It's a very relaxing place!!It's my first time in this restaurant,,,but I'm sure that I come back next time !!!Thanks...If you saw this text ,please give a LIKE ?.THNKS,,,,

Motty Kleinman

Nice calm place and beautiful views of the lake and mountains

Yoel Honig

Food and service was great!

Gedalia Mendelson

We think it’s great, the food is good and prices are reasonable considering we’re in mountains. We’re regulars yearly and the view makes this place. Diverse crowd always chatting and enjoying the time out of town. What else do u want? U can walk down and rent a boat. Really just a relaxing place to sit and lower your blood pressure.

מענדי גרליק

A old place with smelly food, the service was pretty bad. The food im pretty sure was made 17 years before we came.

Shaul Singer

Great tasting restaurant

Avi Klein

I always like coming here for the best breakfast

MarkGoldberg Brooklyn

Limited food menu selection, but it's a cafe only open during the summer months. Our waiter was very nice and accommodating..The lake view was pretty... Good spot for lunch...

Loading...