Terrible pizza and absolute worst experience with a business in years . Read the messages for yourself and you decide . As for these reviews she says the negative ones help so I sincerely hope you save your $77 and grab a Stewart’s pizza instead where its service with a smile.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Crystal Schneider
Hi! Fellow Italian here! Camping with family at whetstone and was told by the owners daughter for $77 for a large pizza and 20 wings it would be the best I've ever had. I'm sooo disappointed both by the food and also the fact us Italians don't do this to others. I have taken pictures of my burnt onion and half cheese pizza and will take it to the appropriate party since we cannot coincidentally post a picture here. Wonder why.
Update: since the owners 2 daughters read my review they proceeded to blow up my phone all night until 10pm arguing with me over the food I received. I was offered a remade pizza (a different day like we weren't hungry now) but the soggy wings I was to be stuck with. $77 for a large 2 topping and 20 wings. The daughters are rude and crude and I could not believe a business owner would text their customers for hours arguing with them. I think this review will need to be escalated to the better business bureau. Too small of a town to treat people like that and feed them crappy pizza. Our convenience stores in town do a better job.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Wesley Ralston
The pizza was excellent, especially the crust. The owners were very kind and worked very hard to make sure that we got our pizza quickly, and when we did, it was fresh and hot. This was very authentic New York pizza. We will definitely be going back again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeannie Groft
We visited the town lowelville and stoped at new york pizzeria their pizza was awesome!!! Best puzza ive had in years. The staff was very friendly and attentive thank you for a awesome pizza
Charlie Bravo
I really appreciated the service i received today. The owner was very nice and willing to remake my pizza after my son mishandled the first. When going to pick up the 2nd pizza everyone welcomed me with a smile, i didn't feel like a burden or annoyance. Thank you so much NY PIZZERIA, will be ordering from there again soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lee Hinkleman
My favorite pizza place. FB Food Blog Eating in Upstate New York and Beyond
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Abby Priolo
The way pizza tasted when you were a kid. I can't wait to come back to this town and get it again.
hellixion marshall
Crispy crust, vibrant veggies, gooey cheese — every bite bursts with fresh flavor. A perfect, satisfying pizza for plant-based cravings!
Ethan Fountaine
$80.00 worth of food 20 wings and a large pizza with pepperoni sausage and onions soupy like bad and I bought calazones last time over 100 dollars and they weren't even done all the way through it food sucks it was good first couple times but not anymore the only good thing on this order was the 2 liter of soda and also
Taylor wheatley
The quality of the cheese on this pizza is beyond what one might expect in a small town—I don’t think people fully appreciate the exceptional ingredients used here. From the dough to the sauce, the cheese, and the meats, every component is top-notch. Naturally, the price reflects this level of quality—you’re paying for excellence. If you’re not looking for authenticity, you might as well stick with a frozen pizza and miss out on something truly special.
We live in Pa., but travel to Lowville frequently to visit family. We usually pick up a pizza on our way. Best I’ve ever had. Consistently. The food is great, and so is the service.
Cody Hodge (Fundeath4U89)
Great food and price me and my wife enjoyed the food
Michi Tomoe
So I thought I had ordered the large calzone, but when I arrived it was the calzone pizza. Um.. it was even better than the traditional calzones and was perfect for feeding a small group for lunch. I definitely recommend this if you haven’t tried it.
Dorothy Keyes
So impressed. The service was wonderful ,as soon as we walked in the door we were acknowledged and seated. Our waiter couldn’t have been any better., he gave his all for being a stand out waiter( attentive, smiling, friendly, and courteous). The food was so delicious, and portion plentiful. The atmosphere quaint, warm and clean. The owner/management wonderful customer service /so warm and appreciative of customers. The desert to be trialed at end of meal melts in the mouth. Will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matteson Family
Best pizza and wings in the area. Nice little hometown restaurant. Small town
Terrible pizza and absolute worst experience with a business in years . Read the messages for yourself and you decide . As for these reviews she says the negative ones help so I sincerely hope you save your $77 and grab a Stewart’s pizza instead where its service with a smile.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Hi! Fellow Italian here! Camping with family at whetstone and was told by the owners daughter for $77 for a large pizza and 20 wings it would be the best I've ever had. I'm sooo disappointed both by the food and also the fact us Italians don't do this to others. I have taken pictures of my burnt onion and half cheese pizza and will take it to the appropriate party since we cannot coincidentally post a picture here. Wonder why.
Update: since the owners 2 daughters read my review they proceeded to blow up my phone all night until 10pm arguing with me over the food I received. I was offered a remade pizza (a different day like we weren't hungry now) but the soggy wings I was to be stuck with. $77 for a large 2 topping and 20 wings. The daughters are rude and crude and I could not believe a business owner would text their customers for hours arguing with them. I think this review will need to be escalated to the better business bureau. Too small of a town to treat people like that and feed them crappy pizza. Our convenience stores in town do a better job.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
The pizza was excellent, especially the crust. The owners were very kind and worked very hard to make sure that we got our pizza quickly, and when we did, it was fresh and hot. This was very authentic New York pizza. We will definitely be going back again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We visited the town lowelville and stoped at new york pizzeria their pizza was awesome!!! Best puzza ive had in years. The staff was very friendly and attentive thank you for a awesome pizza
I really appreciated the service i received today. The owner was very nice and willing to remake my pizza after my son mishandled the first. When going to pick up the 2nd pizza everyone welcomed me with a smile, i didn't feel like a burden or annoyance. Thank you so much NY PIZZERIA, will be ordering from there again soon!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My favorite pizza place. FB Food Blog Eating in Upstate New York and Beyond
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The way pizza tasted when you were a kid. I can't wait to come back to this town and get it again.
Crispy crust, vibrant veggies, gooey cheese — every bite bursts with fresh flavor. A perfect, satisfying pizza for plant-based cravings!
$80.00 worth of food 20 wings and a large pizza with pepperoni sausage and onions soupy like bad and I bought calazones last time over 100 dollars and they weren't even done all the way through it food sucks it was good first couple times but not anymore the only good thing on this order was the 2 liter of soda and also
The quality of the cheese on this pizza is beyond what one might expect in a small town—I don’t think people fully appreciate the exceptional ingredients used here. From the dough to the sauce, the cheese, and the meats, every component is top-notch. Naturally, the price reflects this level of quality—you’re paying for excellence. If you’re not looking for authenticity, you might as well stick with a frozen pizza and miss out on something truly special.
P.s. we get EXTRA EXTRA cheese
Restaurantji Recommends
We live in Pa., but travel to Lowville frequently to visit family. We usually pick up a pizza on our way. Best I’ve ever had. Consistently. The food is great, and so is the service.
Great food and price me and my wife enjoyed the food
So I thought I had ordered the large calzone, but when I arrived it was the calzone pizza. Um.. it was even better than the traditional calzones and was perfect for feeding a small group for lunch. I definitely recommend this if you haven’t tried it.
So impressed. The service was wonderful ,as soon as we walked in the door we were acknowledged and seated. Our waiter couldn’t have been any better., he gave his all for being a stand out waiter( attentive, smiling, friendly, and courteous). The food was so delicious, and portion plentiful. The atmosphere quaint, warm and clean. The owner/management wonderful customer service /so warm and appreciative of customers. The desert to be trialed at end of meal melts in the mouth. Will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza and wings in the area. Nice little hometown restaurant. Small town
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...