Buttercooky Bakery & Café
140 Plandome Rd, Manhasset
(516) 627-1600
Customers' Favorites
Seasonal Holiday Cupcake
Strawberry Shortcake
Traditional Tiramisu
Fresh Fruit Torte
Tres Leches Cake
Assorted Cookies
Classic Cupcake
Birthday Cake
Peach Supreme
Custom Order
Breakfast Pastries
Plain Croissant
Pain Au Chocolat
Almond Croissant
Brocooli & Egg Quiche Croissant Tart
Bacon & Egg Quiche Croissant Tart
Toasted Coconut Chocolate Bearclaw Croissant
Crème Brûlée Croissant Suprême (Croissant~Swirl)
Cronut (Jelly Filled Fried Croissant)
The Crookie (Croissant~Cookie)
Pecan Croissant
Whole Wheat Croissant
Blueberry Cheesecake Croissant Tart
Peaches & Cream Croissant Tart
Berries & Cream Croissant Tart
Lemon Meringue Croissant Supreme (Croissant~Swirl)
Strawberry Cheesecake Cruffin (Croissant~Muffin)
Banana Pudding Cruffin (Croissant~Muffin)
Pecan Danish
Cinnamon Bun
Cheese Danish
Blueberry Muffin
Corn Muffin
Banana Pecan Muffin
Bran Muffin
Cranberry Walnut Muffin
Chocolate Chip Muffin
Cappuccino Muffin
Apple Muffin
Carrot Muffin
Walnut Brownie
Chocolate Cigar
Peach Boat Puff Pastry
Apple Boat Puff Pastry
Lemon Loaf Cake (Slice)
Marble Loaf Cake (Slice)
Blueberry Scone
Raisin and Pecan Scone
Cranberry Walnut Scone
Chocolate Chip Scone
Fudge Brownie
1 lb Assorted Rugelach
Apricot, chocolate and raspberry.
Almond Horns
Jelly Donuts
Boston Cream Donut
Vanilla Glazed Donut
Chocolate Glazed Donut
Apple Turnover
Blueberry Turnover
Crumb Cake Slice
Blueberry Pudding Cake Slice
Raspberry Crumb Cake Slice
Brioche
Palmier (Elephant Ear Cookie)
Elephant ear cookie.
Sfogliatelle
Black & White Cookie
Hamantaschen
Linzer Tart Cookie
Breakfast Rings
Pecan Ring
Chocolate Horn Ring
Apple Horn Ring
Cheese Ring
Crumb Cake Square
Blueberry Pudding Square
Mousse Cakes
7" Tres Leche Cake
Silky smooth custard cream and dulce de leche set atop ultra-moist vanilla sponge famous for being soaked in our specially crafted three milk mixture blend, iced with pillowy-soft whipped cream and topped with fresh strawberries, peaches, raspberries, blackberries and blueberries.
7" Chocolate Mousse Cake
Light and airy chocolate mousse set atop a thin layer of soft chocolate cake, finished with rich chocolate ganache, a dark chocolate pencil and chocolate cake crumbs.
7" Hazelnut Chocolate Mousse Cake
Hazelnut and chocolate mousse set atop a thin layer of soft chocolate cake, finished with rich chocolate ganache, hazelnut whipped ganache, chocolate triangles and toasted hazelnuts.
7" Oreo Mousse Cake
Rich and creamy cookies n' cream loaded with chunks of oreo set atop a thin moist chocolate cake, finished with a coating of crushed oreo and studded with oreo chocolate truffles & fresh strawberries
7" Vanilla Bean Mousse Cake
Light and airy vanilla bean mousse with a liquid vanilla sauce center set atop almond sponge cake lightly marinated in almond flavored syrup, finished with white chocolate triangles and crunchy wafers.
7" Pistachio Cherry Mousse Cake
Pistachio mousse and cherry crémeux set atop thin moist vanilla cake lightly soaked in cherry syrup finished with pistachio glaze, garnished with dollops of vanilla whipped ganache, toasted pistachio nuts & fresh cherries
7" Tiramisu Cake
Light and airy mascarpone cheese layered with ever-so-soft moist lady finger vanilla cake soaked in freshly brewed espresso coffee and a hint of coffee syrup, finished with a low peak of vanilla whipped cream dusted with cocoa powder and enclosed with lady fingers.
7" Red Velvet Cake
Pillowy-soft cream cheese set atop a thin moist velvet cake, finished with white chocolate red velvet sprayed curls and velvet cake crumbs.
7" Silk and Satin Cake
Silky chocolate mousse infused with our famous New York style cheesecake set atop a thin moist chocolate cake, finished with a nest of chocolate ganache, gold dusted lines and lathered in roasted almond slices.
7" Cannoli Cake
Our signature cannoli filling set atop layers of moist vanilla cake, enclosed by a thin ring of rainbow cookies, finished with a light coating of chocolate ganache and diced rainbow cookies.
Buttercream Cakes & Whipped Cream Cakes
Carrot Cake
Smooth and silky cream cheese sandwiched between moist layers of carrot cake baked golden with raisins, finished with luscious cream cheese icing, walnuts, marzipan carrots & lathered in toasted coconut flakes
Chocolate Shadow Cake
Rich chocolate buttercream set atop alternating layers of soft chocolate and vanilla cake, finished with a chocolate ganache swirl resting on smooth chocolate buttercream icing
Vanilla Shadow Cake
Ever-so-light vanilla buttercream set atop alternating layers of soft vanilla and chocolate cake, finished with a top coat of rich chocolate ganache dripping down the side of the silky vanilla buttercream icing
Funfetti Cake
Smooth and silky vanilla buttercream set atop thin layers of funfetti cake baked golden and moist, finished with a wave of funfetti colors and lathered in funfetti sprinkles
Devil's Food Cake (Epic Chocolate Cake)
Moist yet dense chocolate cake rich in color and powerful in taste layered with silky-smooth chocolate fudge, iced in heavenly chocolate frosting and topped with a mountain of cocoa dusted dark chocolate shards
Malibu Coconut
Vanilla crémeux set between layers of fluffy vanilla cake lightly soaked in malibu coconut creme brûlée syrup, iced in smooth coconut cream cheese and lathered in golden toasted coconut flakes giving the dessert a caramel-nutty-like flavor
Chocolate Flower Cake
Light and rich chocolate pudding set atop thin layers moist chocolate cake, iced in creamy chocolate fudge & finished with three handcrafted buttercream flowers and chocolate cake crumbs
Vanilla Flower Cake
Alternating layers of creamy vanilla buttercream and rich chocolate buttercream set atop thin layers of moist vanilla cake, iced in vanilla buttercream & finished with three handcrafted buttercream flowers and vanilla cake crumbs
Seven Layer Cake
Mini Birthday Cake Vanilla
Sweet vanilla buttercream set atop thin layers of moist vanilla cake iced in smooth vanilla buttercream, garnished with colorful buttercream balloons & funfetti sprinkles
Mini Birthday Cake Chocolate
Rich chocolate buttercream set atop thin layers of moist chocolate cake iced in smooth chocolate buttercream, garnished with colorful buttercream balloons & funfetti sprinkles
Fresh Fruit Salad
Pillowy-soft whipped cream loaded with freshly chopped strawberries, bananas, peaches and pineapples jam set atop thin layers of vanilla cake lightly soaked in simple syrup, garnished with dashes of vanilla chantilly cream & fresh berries
Strawberry Shortcake
Pillowy-soft whipped cream loaded with freshly chopped strawberries set atop thin layers of vanilla cake lightly soaked in strawberry syrup, garnished with vanilla chantilly cream & fresh strawberries
Brown Derby
Pillowy-soft whipped cream loaded with freshly chopped bananas and strawberries set atop thin layers of chocolate cake, finished with a combination of whipped cream swirls and fresh strawberries and lathered in chocolate cake crumbs.
French Pastries & Eclairs
Chocolate Mousse
Light and airy chocolate mousse set atop a thin soft chocolate cake finished with a layer of rich chocolate ganache, dark chocolate curl and a fresh raspberry.
Strawberry Cheesecake
Smooth and silky cream cheese finished with fluffy whipped cream and a fresh strawberry (gluten-free).
New York Cheesecake
Smooth and silky cream cheese (gluten-free).
Oreo Cheesecake
Smooth and silky cream cheese loaded with chunks of oreo set atop a thin layer of oreo cookie crust, finished with chocolate fudge, chocolate ganache and an oreo.
Red Velvet
Pillowy-soft cream cheese set atop a thin moist velvet cake, finished with a dollop of fluffy cream cheese frosting.
Silk & Satin
Silky chocolate mousse infused with our famous New York style cheesecake set atop a buttery chocolate shortbread cookie, finished with chocolate ganache and lightly lathered in chocolate cake crumbs.
Smore's Cream Puff
A cream puff filled with light and airy milk chocolate mousse dipped in rich milk chocolate, rolled in graham cracker crumbs and finished with toasted marshmallow fluff.
Strawberry Shortcake
Light and airy strawberry crémeux and strawberry jam set atop layers of lemon vanilla cake dipped in strawberry white chocolate & finished with strawberry and vanilla whipped ganache
Crème Brûlée
Slowly baked custard cream perfectly doused in sugar that is torched to a golden brittle crust finished with an assortment of fresh berries.
Opera Cake
Espresso whipped ganache and dark chocolate crémeux set between layers of chocolate biscuit cake lathered in espresso syrup, finished with dark chocolate glaze & crunchy chocolate wafer
Key Lime Pie
Creamy key lime pie filling set atop the most wonderful crunchy, sweet and buttery bed of graham cracker crust, finished with whipped cream and decorative lime sugar pieces.
Lobster Tail Pastry
Crispy flaky shell baked gorgeously golden filled with light and delicious Bavarian cream.
Tres Leche Bowl
Vanilla cake soaked in three milks custard and caramel filling whipped cream icing with fresh fruit on top.
Chocolate Tiramisu
Light and airy chocolate mascarpone cheese loaded with chunks of chocolate chips layered with ever-so-soft moist lady finger chocolate cake soaked in freshly brewed espresso coffee and a hint of coffee syrup, finished with a dark chocolate curl & chocolate cake crumbs.
Oreo Mousse
Rich and creamy cookies n' cream loaded with chunks of oreo set atop a buttery oreo sablé cookie, finished with vanilla whipped ganache and studded with vanilla & dark chocolate shards
The Honeycomb
Light and airy honey crémeux set atop a white chocolate wafer crunch, finished in golden burnt honey glaze & topped with a white chocolate honeycomb studded with raw honey
Salted Caramel Brownie
A soft chocolate brownie base with one layer of chocolate truly topped with a layer of our famous salted caramel crémeux, studded with roasted buckwheat and a chocolate triangle.
Flourless Milk Chocolate Brownie
Milk chocolate mousse set atop decadent gluten free chocolate cake dipped in crunchy dark wafer chocolate, finished in dark chocolate glaze and studded with gold leaf & candied lavender flowers
Cheesecake Brownie
A rich edgy chocolate brownie base topped with a layer of smooth and silky cream cheese finished with perfectly whipped New York cheesecake and a chocolate stick.
Cappuccino Mousse
Cappuccino mousse infused with chocolate crémeux dipped in dark chocolate set atop a buttery chocolate sablé cookie, finished with espresso whipped ganache, chocolate shards & a gold studded espresso bean
Hazelnut Mousse
Hazelnut mousse dipped in crunchy hazelnut wafer chocolate set atop a buttery chocolate sablé cookie, finished with hazelnut whipped ganache.
Matcha~Misu (Matcha & Tiramisu)
Lady finger matcha cake soaked in matcha syrup set between layers of matcha whipped ganache and mascarpone cheese, finished with dollops of vanilla whipped ganache, matcha glaze & dipped in crunchy pistachio chocolate
Pistachio Cherry
Pistachio mousse and cherry crémeux dipped in crunchy raspberry wafer chocolate set atop a buttery chocolate sablé cookie, finished with pistachio whipped ganache, crushed pistachio & fresh raspberries
Custard Eclair
Pâte á Choux filled with madagascar vanilla crémeux, topped with dark chocolate whipped ganache & a white chocolate plaque
Nutella Caramel Eclair
Pâte á Choux dual filled with nutella mousse and salted caramel crémeux, topped with chocolate fudge & garnished with caramel chocolate discs
Saint Honoré Eclair (Vanilla & Praline)
Pâte á Choux dual filled with vanilla diplomat crème and nutty praline crémeux, topped with vanilla whipped ganache & salted caramel cream puffs
Tarts & Cake Slices
Lemon Meringue Tart
Citrusy lemon filling in a buttery vanilla sablé tart shell, topped with fluffy vanilla meringue.
Vanilla Bean Tart
Almond cake lightly soaked in almond praline syrup with vanilla crème anglaise in a buttery vanilla sablé tart, topped with vanilla bean mousse & garnished with white chocolate, chopped toasted almonds & gold leaf
Raspberry Vanilla Tart
Raspberry crémeux resting on vanilla cake in a buttery vanilla sablé tart, topped with a vanilla mousse infused dome enclosed with raspberry whipped ganache & garnished with raspberry nibs, fresh mint and raspberries
Apple Crumb Tart
Fresh diced apples doused in soft cinnamon and sugar in a vanilla sablé tart shell topped & baked with golden buttery crumble.
Fresh Fruit Tart
Silky rich custard cream in a dark chocolate dipped buttery vanilla sablé tart topped with strawberries, raspberries, blueberries, blackberries, mandarin oranges and kiwi.
Blueberry Tart
Refreshing vanilla mousse in a buttery vanilla sablé tart shell, topped with fresh blueberries.
Seven Layer Slice
Rich chocolate buttercream sandwiched between seven layers of moist vanilla cake, finished with dark chocolate ganache.
Carrot Cake Slice
Smooth and silky cream cheese sandwiched between deeply moist carrot cake baked with golden raisins, finished with super soft and extra lush cream cheese icing & a marzipan carrot.
Tiramisu Slice
Light and airy mascarpone cheese layered with ever-so-soft moist lady finger vanilla cake soaked in freshly brewed espresso coffee and a hint of coffee syrup, finished with a low peak of vanilla whipped cream & dusted with cocoa powder.
Cookie Trays & Specialty Cookies by Weight
1 Pound Cookie Tray
1.5 pound Cookie Tray
2 Pound Cookie Tray
1 Pound Rainbow Cookies
1 Pound Assorted Italian Biscotti
1 Pound Pignoli Cookie
Cheesecakes - Large 10" & Small 6"
6" New York Cheesecake
6" Strawberry Cheesecake
6" Oreo Cheesecake
6" Marble Cheesecake
10" NY Cheesecake
10" Strawberry Cheesecake
Cupcakes, Macarons & Cake Pops
Classic Cupcake
Vanilla or chocolate cupcake with sprinkles and cherry on top.
Flower Cupcake
Vanilla or chocolate cupcake pink or purple roses.
Elmo Cupcake
Cookie Monster Cupcake
Oreo Cupcake
Seasonal/Holiday Cupcake
Princess Crown Cupcake
Chocolate Cake Pop
Red Velvet Cake Pop
Vanilla Cake Pop
Oreo Cake Pop
Coffee Macaron
Strawberry Macaron
Raspberry Macaron
Lemon Macaron
Caramel Macaron
Pistachio Macaron
Vanilla Macaron
Chocolate Macaron
Large Pies & Tarts
10" Key Lime Pie
10" Fresh Fruit Tart
Large Cookies
Rainbow Sprinkle Cookie
Chinese Cookie
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Sugar Cookie
M & M Cookie
Oatmeal Raisin
Black & White Cookie
Linzer Tart Cookie
Bread
Whole Wheat Italian Loaf
Kaiser Roll
Semolina
Egg Rolls
Italian Bread
French Baguette
Sourdough/Ciabatta
Bagel
Gluten Free Items
6" Marble Cheesecake
6" Strawberry Cheesecake
10" NY Cheesecake
NY Cheesecake pastry
6" NY Cheesecake
10" Strawberry Cheesecake
Almond Horn
Créme Brûleé
Pistachio Macaron
Vanilla Macaron
Chocolate Macaron
Strawberry Macaron
Raspberry Macaron
Lemon Macaron
Caramel Macaron
Custom Order (Cake, Bread, Cupcakes, Cookies, Etc..)
Custom Order
Please provide us with the following information: 1) full name on order form 2) method of order (via phone [631-424 -4034] or in person) 3) brief description of order details.
Smoothies
Tropical Paradise
peaches, pineapples, bananas, greek yogurt
Banana Blues
bananas, blueberries, greek yogurt
Overnight Oats
oats, granola, bananas, peanut butter, honey, greek yogurt
Peach Delight
peaches, greek yogurt, whipped cream
Strawberry Banana Bash
strawberries, bananas, greek yogurt
Berry Balance
blackberries, blueberries, strawberries, raspberries, greek yogurt
Shakes
Oreo Mountain Shake
vanilla gelato, oreo cookies, oreo crumbs, chocolate sauce, whipped cream
M&M Shake
chocolate gelato, m&m's, chocolate sauce, whipped cream
Buttercooky Shake
vanilla gelato, vanilla cake, rainbow sprinkles, whipped cream
COFFEE + ESPRESSO + WELLNESS LATTE
Small Drip
Large Drip
Small Herbal Tea
Large Herbal Tea
Small Hot Chocolate
Large Hot Chocolate
Small Nutella Hot Chocolate
Large Nutella Hot Chocolate
Espresso
Macchiato
Cortado
Small Cappuccino
Large Cappuccino
Flat White
Small Café Latte
Large Café Latte
Small Mocha
Large Mocha
Small Americano
Large Americano
Small Cold Brew
Large Cold Brew
Small Oatmilk Draft Latte
Large Oatmilk Draft Latte
Small Oat Milk Vanilla Draft Latte
Large Oat Milk Vanilla Draft Latte
Small Black & Tan Draft Latte
Large Black & Tan Draft Latte
Freddo Espresso
Small Freddo Cappuccino
Large Freddo Cappuccino
Small Iced Coffee
Large Iced Coffee
Iced Macchiato
Small Iced Café Latte
Large Iced Café Latte
Small Iced Americano
Large Iced Americano
Small Iced Tres Leche Latte
Large Iced Tres Leche Latte
Small Iced Coconut Latte
Large Iced Coconut Latte
Small Matcha Latte
Large Matcha Latte
Small Iced Mactha Latte
Large Iced Matcha Latte
Small Chai Latte
Large Chai Latte
Small Iced Chai Latte
Large Iced Chai Latte
Nutella Frappé
Mocha Frappé
Caramel Frappé
Photos
+81 photos
+80 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
As someone who grew up in Boston with nice homemade bakeries available , to my delight I found my childhood dream at the Butter Cookie Bakery and Cafe in Manhasset , Nassau County ,New York .
At reasonable prices , salads , specially breakfast and lunch items of the quality made and freshness I remember and cherish growing up, specialty smoothies and heavenly coffees are there to provide a country bakery experience with freshness from all the ingredients .
An...
At reasonable prices , salads , specially breakfast and lunch items of the quality made and freshness I remember and cherish growing up, specialty smoothies and heavenly coffees are there to provide a country bakery experience with freshness from all the ingredients .
An...
November 2025
A little disappointed today. Ordered egg and cheese sandwiches. They were ok, but on the smaller side. And the roll was a kaiser roll... Huntington definitely has them beat here, as their rolls are terrific!!)
Also got an iced latte, which was excellent.
The table we sat at was dirty and had someone's food left on it... which I cleaned. But, the crumbs under the table? Well... definitely not cleaned all day... Wish I could post pix...but there didn't...
Also got an iced latte, which was excellent.
The table we sat at was dirty and had someone's food left on it... which I cleaned. But, the crumbs under the table? Well... definitely not cleaned all day... Wish I could post pix...but there didn't...
October 2025
You May Also Like
Schout Bay Tavern - 118 Plandome Rd
![]()
Gastropubs, American, New American
Villa Milano - 168 Plandome Rd
![]()
Italian, Seafood, Pizza, Vegetarian
Herb&Olive - 172 Plandome Rd
![]()
Greek, Specialty Food, Mediterranean, Vegan
SERVICE: the waitress who served us dropped our cutlery in front of us like it was a ball and not silverware. when we asked for napkins which were not originally given, she...