Big Jay's Pizzeria

9250 River Rd, Marcy
(315) 982-9536

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Riggies Wednesday Special

Slice of Pepperoni Pizza

Keto Cauliflower Pizza

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Big Jay Stuffed Pizza

Chicken Wings Combo

Eggplant Parmigiana

Upside Down Pizza

Chicken Alfredo

Chicken Riggies

Photos

+41 photos

+40 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Grubhub

Doordash

Slicelife

Bigjayspizzeriamenu

Recent Reviews

This review is overdue, I have gotten many things from Big Jays since they have opened, have even ordered for smaller parties. Their pizza and wings are by far some of the best in the area. The one and only time I had an issue with an order, the employees (multiple) went way above and beyond to ensure it was corrected - and it wasn’t even a big error on their part at all. Will return as a happy customer!

March 2026

Today I decided I wanted a chicken cesar wrap and ordered one from Big Jay's I noticed that they have fried cheese curd and decided to try that too. The wrap was huge! I had trouble finishing 1/2! Flavor was on point too! But the cheese curd with sweet chili dipping sauce stole the show! After eating 1/2 a wrap I couldn't eat too many but they were fantastic! And that dipping sauce was perfect! I have never been unhappy with anything I have had a Big Jays, I think today...

February 2026

I'm from Queens, NYC and this pizza is as good as my neighborhood pie spot! It's literally the best pizza I've ever had outside of NYC and better than some places in NYC!
The lady who helped me place my order was friendly and helpful. I ended up with a small pie which was DELICIOUS!! I couldn't decide between the pizza or a stromboli. I'll go back tomorrow for lunch and get the stromboli.
The owner appears to be a big football fan. Numerous...

February 2026

More Reviews

Restaurants in Marcy, NY

Big Jay's Pizzeria

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Order Online

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Big Jay's Pizzeria