Binnekill Tavern
746 Main St, Margaretville
(845) 586-4884
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
Best place to celebrate a great settlement in my favor, a very big one! I wanted to eat like 90k oysters, but it is closed!
Still giving it 5 stars, in hopes that the new owners are better than the last ones.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Waited for dining on the deck because we had our dog. They said 5 minutes, they would come out to get us, and 15 minutes later we were still waiting with the deck cleared except 1 table. Had to go in and ask again. Was sat right in the sun and after 20 minutes with just water we asked if we could move in the shade. We were told no because they had to hold them in case bigger parties came. He didn't want to get in trouble again. It was 2:30 in the afternoon so it was unlikely and that proved true as there were 4 tables in the shade open at all times while we waited for over an hour to get our food. One waiter complained the whole time about the other one. It was generally an unpleasant experience. 1.5 hours sitting in direct sunlight left me sunburned and pretty unhappy. The food was good but I would never go back. Wasn't worth it at all. And what kind of manager reprimands staff for something like that.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Because it was Labor Day weekend, we reserved our table ahead of time. When we arrived we waited almost 10 minutes before anyone even acknowledged us. After being seated, we realized the restaurant was seriously understaffed and were ready to be patient and understand the server's position. There was no management on the floor, only two servers and a bartender. Our server took our drink and food order and brought the drinks over. Shortly after we were brought my husband's Ceaser salad. Then we waited over an hour and watched as tables that came in after us got appetizers, entrees and actually (we believe) OUR dinners. So, we decided to leave. We gave our server cash to cover our drinks and salad and a tip. The topper was our server actually trying to guilt us into staying by telling us SHE would be forced to pay for our dinners if we left. We will NEVER return to this establishment. Very poorly run and we have no idea what the food tastes like because we never had a chance to find out. The salad was okay, at best.
The server we had was absolutely ridiculous. I do believe he for got to place our food order we witnessed other tables come in after us and were served and finished their food before we were served. This is only to blame our server The food was fine I was there to celebrate my 9 yr old grandsons birthday and even he said several times where is our food? I waited patiently because of his birthday otherwise I would have gotten up and left.
What a hidden gem! The hanger steak and potatoes were to die for! I walked in and was pleasantly surprised by the atmosphere and the service I received from the workers there
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
This will forever be my comfort place. The waiters are great and the service from them was the best Ive seen in a while. Those jumbo chicken wings are just what one needs as a comfort meal or at the end of a tiring day.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings
It did take a minute for food, However it was worth the wait. I received the Catskill trout as an appetizer and a haddock for a meal. They were both excellent. One of the better places around here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Catskill Smoked Trout Salad
This was possibly one of the worst dining experiences of my life. Waited over an hour for our food. They missed numerous items. Burger was tough, vegetable rice noodle dish was a pile of brown, and drinks were terrible. Asked for a manager on duty and was told that only manager was one of the cooks. So many mistakes, took forever, and the food was terrible. The buffalo wings were the only redeeming part of the meal. All the staff seemed miserable.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings
Received great service from Christie (?sp). She was attentive and really cared that we had a great experience! Delicious food, salmon bowl and steak sandwich were delicious!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hadn't been back in 3 years and so glad we returned. More than met our expectations- great happy hour drinks, schnitzel delicious and server Christine - the BEST We'll definitely return very soon
Restaurantji Recommends
the place looks nice,
but the food is mediocre. the servers are not trained, and the prices are super expensive.
This would be all okay for a small town restaurant, but when you're charging $20 for an entree, you better make sure that your food is good.
will not visit again. do not recommend.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Crab Cakes, Chicken Wings
We had the escargot and it was absolutely delicious with nice crisp bread, great salad and the hamburgers. The food was great and the service was fantastic. I would definitely go back when I’m upset again.????❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bacon Cheddar Burger on a Brioche Bun
Just walked in on a Saturday afternoon 3:50pm 7/6/24 and told they couldn’t seat the 5 (2 are children) of us… too many people without a reservation and was practically empty! WTH? ??♀️
Ever hear of a restaurant turning people away when they have no patrons?
Service: 1
Honestly if it wasn't for Christine our waitress we probably would have left. She was beyond apologetic for the ridiculous wait. But the food once it came was surpriseingly good!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
No service. Undercooked food. Never go here.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Loading...