Who cares how nice the interior is. Absolutely the worst pizza I have ever had anywhere in any state of the USA. Spinach and artichoke look liked they just dumped a can of soup on it. The slice of cheese I took one bite and couldn't eat it. Went to the park next door and fed it to the ducks and they passed on it.
Imagine Halyard
I love the fact that I have so many gluten free options! And it’s really good, I’ve ordered there a couple times but it’s definitely better in person. If your gluten free I highly recommend
Robbie R
Something is up. This place use to be great. Went down hill fast. Food not that good.
Big Meatty
The pizza is ok very greasy and sometimes undercooked. The workers are kind of rude but the inside is very nice
K Lol
Good pizza but the some of the workers are rude
Cecilia Yee
Always excellent food! The owner Joe, is the best. When he found out my husband was in a severe accident, he sent free food to our house to help out. A nicer man could not exist!
Robert Tuozzo
I don’t like the pizza here (cheese is moldy and pizza is typically undercooked), but the interior is very nice
Chris V.
The food was rocky when new management took over a year ago. Owner called directly which was very considerate to let them work through the change and things seemed to get better. Ordered again today and we're just done. This was the last time we order. Calamari tastes like cardboard flavor, pizza was undercooked. Hero was meh.
SKCYCLES
Sandwich was 12 dollars. Hardly any meat on it. Bread wasn’t fresh. Plenty of other Italian places around. Stay away from this one.
Michelle R.
I placed an order through Uber Eats for a salad and two meals...all three items were wrong....they completely left the salad out, replaced a chicken dish with veal, and gave the wrong other meal completely...when the restaurant was contacted, whoever I was put on the phone with was extremely rude, laughed at me, and offered only for me to pick up a new order in an hour when I originally had delivery. He couldn't have cared less about my issue as a paying customer. Unbelievable that the man I spoke to is in the service industry.
Best pizza I’ve ever had. Have eaten here many many times and the quality is always excellent. When I walk in the restaurant I feel like I’m in Italy. Truly a wonderful experience.
Pro DJ Productions & Photo Booths
One of our favorite go to spots for local pizza and Italian food.
A Mc
I have celiac disease so when I saw the large variety of gluten free options I was excited to try since it’s very hard to find a restaurant that takes the responsibility of accommodating and ensuring Allergies and special dietary requirements since most places don’t want that responsibility on their hands. I ordered the gluten free penne alla vodka which I thought was delicious but shortly after eating I started to not feel right, I checked the leftovers I had and sure enough I found a piece of regular spaghetti in it. It’s very frustrating when places claim to be safe for people with special restrictions and it’s not. Not to mention I spent over 30$ to have to throw it away and now I’ll be very sick for a few days. DONT CLAIM TO BE GLUTEN FREE WHEN ITS NOT! That Includes cross contamination, it could be fatal to some people which is why most restaurants don’t take on that liability.
Jimmy D.
Stop in for a couple of slices before grocery shopping, what a mistake. This has go to be the worst pizza I have ever eaten. I'm thinking the high school across the street is the only reason this place is still open. Never again.
Mindy M.
Crostini Pizzeria and Restaurant SOUTH GATE Shopping Center 4952 Merrick Road Massapequa Park NY 11762 516 797 4747 I stopped in a few weeks ago and ordered a regular cheese pie. I had to wait a bit as the Pizza was made fresh and was good. I had a menu some time ago with coupons listed expiration date as 5 1 21. It noted New Ownership and Come dine with us. So some time ago I did get the menu. Their menu does note gluten free for those who wish to order that. The menu does say they sell 12 inch personal pies too. The man who served me gave me a Cater your next even menu as well. This flyer notes 3, 4, or 6 foot heroes and various Christmas packages. The Elf Catering Package with Salad, a choice of Pasta a choice of one half tray entrée and bread for 8-10 people, the Reindeer package of salad, one half tray of appetizer, pasta, one half tray, entrée one full tray and bread and the Santa Claus pack of salad, one full tray of appetizer, one and an half tray of pasta an entrée also one and a half tray, the later for 25 to 30 people. Prices and selection vary to the need. They have these specials for Christmas and are opened Christmas Eve. I believe he did say they are closed on Christmas day... This review is too late for tomorrow is Christmas Day. (See pix*) But, perhaps these specials will be available thereafter for those who may want to order instead of cook.
Who cares how nice the interior is. Absolutely the worst pizza I have ever had anywhere in any state of the USA. Spinach and artichoke look liked they just dumped a can of soup on it. The slice of cheese I took one bite and couldn't eat it. Went to the park next door and fed it to the ducks and they passed on it.
I love the fact that I have so many gluten free options! And it’s really good, I’ve ordered there a couple times but it’s definitely better in person. If your gluten free I highly recommend
Something is up. This place use to be great. Went down hill fast. Food not that good.
The pizza is ok very greasy and sometimes undercooked. The workers are kind of rude but the inside is very nice
Good pizza but the some of the workers are rude
Always excellent food! The owner Joe, is the best. When he found out my husband was in a severe accident, he sent free food to our house to help out. A nicer man could not exist!
I don’t like the pizza here (cheese is moldy and pizza is typically undercooked), but the interior is very nice
The food was rocky when new management took over a year ago. Owner called directly which was very considerate to let them work through the change and things seemed to get better. Ordered again today and we're just done. This was the last time we order. Calamari tastes like cardboard flavor, pizza was undercooked. Hero was meh.
Sandwich was 12 dollars. Hardly any meat on it. Bread wasn’t fresh. Plenty of other Italian places around. Stay away from this one.
I placed an order through Uber Eats for a salad and two meals...all three items were wrong....they completely left the salad out, replaced a chicken dish with veal, and gave the wrong other meal completely...when the restaurant was contacted, whoever I was put on the phone with was extremely rude, laughed at me, and offered only for me to pick up a new order in an hour when I originally had delivery. He couldn't have cared less about my issue as a paying customer. Unbelievable that the man I spoke to is in the service industry.
Restaurantji Recommends
Best pizza I’ve ever had. Have eaten here many many times and the quality is always excellent. When I walk in the restaurant I feel like I’m in Italy. Truly a wonderful experience.
One of our favorite go to spots for local pizza and Italian food.
I have celiac disease so when I saw the large variety of gluten free options I was excited to try since it’s very hard to find a restaurant that takes the responsibility of accommodating and ensuring Allergies and special dietary requirements since most places don’t want that responsibility on their hands. I ordered the gluten free penne alla vodka which I thought was delicious but shortly after eating I started to not feel right, I checked the leftovers I had and sure enough I found a piece of regular spaghetti in it. It’s very frustrating when places claim to be safe for people with special restrictions and it’s not. Not to mention I spent over 30$ to have to throw it away and now I’ll be very sick for a few days. DONT CLAIM TO BE GLUTEN FREE WHEN ITS NOT! That Includes cross contamination, it could be fatal to some people which is why most restaurants don’t take on that liability.
Stop in for a couple of slices before grocery shopping, what a mistake. This has go to be the worst pizza I have ever eaten. I'm thinking the high school across the street is the only reason this place is still open. Never again.
Crostini Pizzeria and Restaurant SOUTH GATE Shopping Center 4952 Merrick Road Massapequa Park NY 11762 516 797 4747 I stopped in a few weeks ago and ordered a regular cheese pie. I had to wait a bit as the Pizza was made fresh and was good. I had a menu some time ago with coupons listed expiration date as 5 1 21. It noted New Ownership and Come dine with us. So some time ago I did get the menu. Their menu does note gluten free for those who wish to order that. The menu does say they sell 12 inch personal pies too. The man who served me gave me a Cater your next even menu as well. This flyer notes 3, 4, or 6 foot heroes and various Christmas packages. The Elf Catering Package with Salad, a choice of Pasta a choice of one half tray entrée and bread for 8-10 people, the Reindeer package of salad, one half tray of appetizer, pasta, one half tray, entrée one full tray and bread and the Santa Claus pack of salad, one full tray of appetizer, one and an half tray of pasta an entrée also one and a half tray, the later for 25 to 30 people. Prices and selection vary to the need. They have these specials for Christmas and are opened Christmas Eve. I believe he did say they are closed on Christmas day... This review is too late for tomorrow is Christmas Day. (See pix*) But, perhaps these specials will be available thereafter for those who may want to order instead of cook.