Ice Cream Cottage

1590 Montauk Hwy, Mastic
(631) 395-3580

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Yoan Cruz

Best ice cream I ever had

ray wood

Outstanding local find. Mom and pop. Definitely worth a stop...

I B

Visited this establishment today, and ordered a pralines and cream in a cup, and my significant other had a strawberry cheesecake cone. The ice cream was delicious (better than Mr. Softee) and the price is much better too. Significantly cheaper. We got the same thing from Mr. Softee and it was almost $20 bucks. This place was 1/2 the price. Four stars because the floor had topping on it and I thought i stepped on something. Lol. But I'd visit again.

Corina Jackson

We love this place!!!

Kemeisha Patterson

Always great flavors…. Love this place.

Ash

Great food

darcy cocozza

The ice cream was absolutely delicious and the value you get for your money is next level!

Matthew Longo

Best ice cream in Suffolk

Vincent Pina

Had a great big shake that was so delicious. Very friendly and really good ice cream and snacks.

Bryan Wilkinson

The best ice cream cakes around.

Alisher Nazarov

Great ice cream, wide varieties of choices and crazy affordable! Great job!

Matt Warner

First off have loved Ice Cream Cottage for 30+ years but frankly they need to do some upgrades. Went in there today and all ice creams were melted when when they served them to us, by the time we got home it was soup. The freezers weren't cutting it and venting into the shop made it hotter than the heat wave. Customer service was subpar today but usually is good. Overall great flavor as usual, but ice cream being cold is important to the experience.

Karen Baynes

Absolutely Delicious and the buy one get one free deals.on Tuesdays are worth it

P Guarino

Usually go to Ralph’s but they close for the winter, so tried the cottage I hear so much about. Honestly it sucked, ordered a Sunday soft ice cream with peanut butter sauce and chocolate crunch. So for $9.95 I got a cup of ice cream with literally 1squirt of peanut butter on top and a teaspoon of chocolate crunch. RIPOFF!!! Was really disappointing. Ralph’s put toppings bottom, middle and top, all I got here was a cup of ice cream with PRACTICALLY NOTHING ON IT! I don’t know do the employees have to pay for toppings they put on people’s Sundays???? I’m done with this place, DEFINITELY DO NOT RECOMMEND

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 3

Ana Lisama

SOOOO good dawg

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...