Ice Cream Cottage

1590 Montauk Hwy, Mastic
(631) 395-3580

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Assorted Ice Cream
Banana Nut Crunch
Rainbow Cookie
Sundae 5 Scoops
Assorted Gelato
Birthday Cake
Blackberry

Featured items
Super Sundae
Quart Cup (32 oz)
Pint Cup (16 oz)
If you want pint with toppings, you can order as super sundae.
Sundae (5 Scoops)
Bonnet cone Box of 4
Regular Saucers
Pack of 6.
Sprinkle Deluxe Saucers
Pack of 6.
Mini Sundae Box of 6
3 choc with chocolate sprinkles and cherry and 3 vanilla with rainbow sprinkles and cherry.
Neopolitan Cake (8-10 Servings)
Chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry ice cream layered with crunchies in between the layers.
Chocolate Chip Deluxe Saucers
Pack of 6.
Canoli Box of 4
2 plain and 2 dipped in chocolate shells filled with our canoli ice cream.
Banana Barge
Toni Box of 6
Vanilla ice cream topped with toasted coconut and a cherry.
Oreo Deluxe Saucers
Pack of 6.
Spumoni Box of 4
Choc Chip Cookie Deluxe Saucers
Pack of 6.

Cups
Medium Cup (3 Scoops)
Small Cup (2 Scoops)
Super Sundae
Large Cup (4 Scoops)
Sundae (5 Scoops)
Pint Cup (16 oz)
If you want pint with toppings, you can order as super sundae.
Banana Barge
Quart Cup (32 oz)

Cakes
Small Round Cake (8-10 Servings)
Vanilla and chocolate layered with chocolate crunchies in the middle.
Deluxe Bartman Cake (8-10 Servings)
Bartman ice cream with hot fudge, peanut butter, and butterfinger on top.
Sprinkle Delight Cake (8-10 Servings)
Vanilla ice cream with rainbow sprinkles in the middle and on top.
Neopolitan Cake (8-10 Servings)
Chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry ice cream layered with crunchies in between the layers.
Large Round Cake (10-12 Servings)
Vanilla and chocolate layered with chocolate crunchies in the middle.
No Fat No Sugar Added Cake (8-10 Servings)
Vanilla and chocolate no fat no sugar added ice cream layered with chocolate crunchies in the middle.
Chocolate Overdose Cake (8-10 Servings)
Chocolate overdose ice cream with hot fudge, chocolate chip, and brownie pieces on top.
Oreo Cake (8-10 Servings)
Cookies and cream ice cream with hot fudge and Oreos on top.
Small Sheet Cake (18-22 Servings)
Vanilla and chocolate layered with chocolate crunchies in the middle.
M&M Cake (8-10 Servings)
Vanilla M&M ice cream with hot fudge and mini M&Ms on top.
Mint Chip Cake (8-10 Servings)
Mint chocolate chip ice cream with chocolate crunchies in the middle, hot fudge, and chocolate chips on top.

Novelties
Spumoni Box of 4
Bonnet cone Box of 4
Toni Box of 6
Vanilla ice cream topped with toasted coconut and a cherry.
Mini Sundae Box of 6
3 choc with chocolate sprinkles and cherry and 3 vanilla with rainbow sprinkles and cherry.
Canoli Box of 4
2 plain and 2 dipped in chocolate shells filled with our canoli ice cream.
Tartufo Box of 4

Saucers
Sprinkle Deluxe Saucers
Pack of 6.
Choc Chip Cookie Deluxe Saucers
Pack of 6.
Oreo Deluxe Saucers
Pack of 6.
Chocolate Chip Deluxe Saucers
Pack of 6.
Regular Saucers
Pack of 6.
Regular Strawberry Saucers
Pack of 6.
Regular Pistachio Saucers
Pack of 6.

Other items
Take Home Dry Toppings (8 oz)
Empty Waffle Cones
Take Home Wet Toppings (8 oz)
Empty Wafer Cone

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+84 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+83 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Visited this establishment today, and ordered a pralines and cream in a cup, and my significant other had a strawberry cheesecake cone. The ice cream was delicious (better than Mr. Softee) and the price is much better too. Significantly cheaper. We got the same thing from Mr. Softee and it was almost $20 bucks. This place was 1/2 the price. Four stars because the floor had topping on it and I thought i stepped on something. Lol. But I'd visit again.
August 2025
First off have loved Ice Cream Cottage for 30+ years but frankly they need to do some upgrades. Went in there today and all ice creams were melted when when they served them to us, by the time we got home it was soup. The freezers weren't cutting it and venting into the shop made it hotter than the heat wave. Customer service was subpar today but usually is good. Overall great flavor as usual, but ice cream being cold is important to the experience.
June 2025
This place was very nice. I tried many flavors and they were all delicious. The flavors were not only good but incredibly accurate. The cappuccino chip flavor had actual cinnamon in it, and each flavor was the same, crafted to taste just like the flavor it was and with a homemade touch that cannot be faked. I give it four stars because the ice cream wasn't kept cold enough for my liking. It was too soft, in my opinion, but it tasted delicious so that made up for it. Taste-wise,...
October 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Frank & Son Bakery - 1575 Montauk Hwy
Bakery, Gluten-Free
Jimmy's Diner - 1535 Montauk Hwy
Diner, American, Comfort Food, Vegetarian
Happy King Kitchen - 1692 Montauk Hwy
Chinese

Ice Cream Cottage

1590 Montauk Hwy, Mastic, NY 11950
(631) 395-3580