We went to buy a case of crab legs. Last time we bought them, they were rubbery and not really good. We realized this time, they are ALREADY COOKED. Simply steam for about 15 mins and they were perfect!
Joe Bamb
Freshest seafood around. Salmon was out of this world. Everyone that worked there was friendly and helpful- will be a lifetime customer.
paul quimbo
Best fresh fish for your money.
No. 7
Been coming here since 1989 and they’ve never let me down. The best. Fresh seafood always with fair prices and excellent customer service. This place has kept its charm intact. Highly recommended!
Ronald Cristani
This place is great every time I go
Pam Penta
They weren't friendly here. I didn't find the clams all that good
Roseann Liotta
We come here occasionally, when in the neighborhood. They have a great variety of fresh seafood.
K M
Great seafood shop
James Armstrong
My first time going to mastic seafood and I will tell you this place superced my expectations got 2 dozen blue claw crabs 2dozen clams and mussels everything was nice and fresh they have a large selection of everything you could possibly want customer service was excellent also so good I am going tomorrow morning love this place prices are great also what more can you ask for when you are a seafood lover if you haven't been there you better get there awesome 👍
Yolanda Knight
This place is excellent!! Great service and an a great selection of seafood, super fresh !!
The Davis Park Fire Dept. Fire Island. Recently had a lobster dinner. I was in contact with Jim the owner. A smooth process. I ordered 60 1.5lbs lobsters. They delivered to the ferry. Packed with ice and newspapers. He called me to tell me they were on the ferry. That's why they get great reviews. Look forward to doing business with you soon.
l franzese
Great prices, fish is always fresh
Krista Baroncelli
Hidden gem! Totally worth the ride, fresh, flavorful seafood that hits every time. Friendly staff, and prices that don’t hurt. Don’t sleep on this spot!
Gary Mayhew
The best seafood place on Long Island. Always fresh fish because they have a fast turnover. I highly recommend
We went to buy a case of crab legs. Last time we bought them, they were rubbery and not really good. We realized this time, they are ALREADY COOKED. Simply steam for about 15 mins and they were perfect!
Freshest seafood around. Salmon was out of this world. Everyone that worked there was friendly and helpful- will be a lifetime customer.
Best fresh fish for your money.
Been coming here since 1989 and they’ve never let me down. The best. Fresh seafood always with fair prices and excellent customer service. This place has kept its charm intact. Highly recommended!
This place is great every time I go
They weren't friendly here.
I didn't find the clams all that good
We come here occasionally, when in the neighborhood. They have a great variety of fresh seafood.
Great seafood shop
My first time going to mastic seafood and I will tell you this place superced my expectations got 2 dozen blue claw crabs 2dozen clams and mussels everything was nice and fresh they have a large selection of everything you could possibly want customer service was excellent also so good I am going tomorrow morning love this place prices are great also what more can you ask for when you are a seafood lover if you haven't been there you better get there awesome 👍
This place is excellent!! Great service and an a great selection of seafood, super fresh !!
Restaurantji Recommends
The Davis Park Fire Dept. Fire Island. Recently had a lobster dinner. I was in contact with Jim the owner. A smooth process. I ordered 60 1.5lbs lobsters. They delivered to the ferry. Packed with ice and newspapers. He called me to tell me they were on the ferry. That's why they get great reviews. Look forward to doing business with you soon.
Great prices, fish is always fresh
Hidden gem! Totally worth the ride, fresh, flavorful seafood that hits every time. Friendly staff, and prices that don’t hurt. Don’t sleep on this spot!
The best seafood place on Long Island. Always fresh fish because they have a fast turnover. I highly recommend
Never been here before I have to give it a try
Loading...