Went for a supper club, which was so great. Highly recommend. Came home with a slice of bread pudding. Three days later, I warmed it it the microwave and it might be the best thing I’ve ever eaten. Bravo, Alison and Fritz!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marie L.
Every time I order from Ali Katz Kitchen I am not disappointed. This recent order of mac & cheese was excellent. Although it was frozen solid when I picked it up, it cooked up perfectly. This simple dish is just one example of the consistent quality of every thing made at Ali Katz.
Mark Wasserman
What a gem! So sorry we didn't find this treasure sooner. Everything looked freshly baked and tasty - We had croissants, scones and coffee. We couldn't decide which was better! Absolutely delicious. We will certainly be back. It's always nice when you get to meet the actual owners. Everything made from scratch a few feet from where we bought it from - A rarity these days. Highly recommended! My wife wants to come back this weekend for the fried chicken.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John H.
I stopped in Ali Katz Kitchen with my wife, this past spring.What a unique boutique bakery and more!The Rugelach and Cookies were unforgettable, just writing about them has me salivating.I wish I had pictures to share!Everything tasted like the real deal made with care and quality ingredients, like my grandma would make.We are excited to return again in the fall.
Julia C.
If you haven't visited, it's a must for some of the best cookies, fresh salads, sweet treats and the best tchotchkes around! Don't forget to hang around for a bit! Fritz may come out of the kitchen and sing a tune or two with you! It's what local businesses are and should be about! They got us through pandemic and we haven't forgotten about them! Check out of Ali's talent!
Peg Kramer
Delicious rugelach!
Mijo L.
Best bakery in North Fork. NYC standards baked goods, not that sweet. Very fresh and small batch. The reason I give this place a 3 stars is the owner itself, Ali Katz. Very rude, cranky old lady that doesn't have an idea how customer service works. Her husband is very nice and should work at the cashier and the desk interacting with customers, explaining things to them and have a good attitude. The old lady should sit in the kitchen and do what she does best, make baked goods. I don't understand why the owner and the other decent baker in North Fork (Jundas) have big egos and make the customer think that they are doing us a favor for cooking baked goods. We can live without them but they can't live without us customers!!
Jeffrey M.
The tomato galette and the crostatas, made with the local fruits at peak season each week, are among the very best foods I have ever eaten. We serve them to guests, who are always amazed by how wonderful they are. Ali also makes the beat linzer tarts I have ever eaten.
Wendy K.
NoFo Long Island review: Best Sat. Night Fried Chicken Dinner! Best Potato Salad! Best Biscuit! Best Sunday morning Scones! And The Nicest people. Thank you Aly & Fritz Wendy & John
Daniel Schmidt
Amazing homemade small batch goodies!! The mix berry scones are to die for!! Can’t wait to try the chocolate chip cookie
What a treat to have this gem in my neighborhood. Truly amazing, well prepared, delicious food. You will not be disappointed. Deserts are delectable, soups so savory, dressings to die for...basically everything is amazing.
Arlene Merkelson
What can I say about this place. 2 almost stale cupcakes where the icing fell off from the bottoms. $5 each. 2 little chocolate Bundt cakes, individualSize portions $8 each. Nothin special. Not incredibly moist or anything to differentiate them fromAny other chocolate muffin. A Bag of oatmeal cookies. These were the best of the 3 but $12 for a little bag. Come on! $38 total. It was a joke. To top it off I asked if I could try one piece of Rugalach which I was willing to pay for. I was told ,no, we only sell them in six pieces portion. really? They were baked on a tray sitting right there! This was the owner! Needless to say, we will not be returning!
Evan Buzzerio
Croissants are TRULY UNBELIEVABLE. Order a day ahead of time. You will not regret it. Ours were warm at pickup. I’m not ashamed to say I had more than I should have and it was worth it!
Lori Usak
I ordered 2 butternut galettes ( best thing I’ve ever eaten) and an assortment of soups and orzo with veggies for a house party. Everything was fresh and delicious. Will be ordering again. Thank you for quality and incredible taste. Hoping you expand this business
Went for a supper club, which was so great. Highly recommend. Came home with a slice of bread pudding. Three days later, I warmed it it the microwave and it might be the best thing I’ve ever eaten. Bravo, Alison and Fritz!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Every time I order from Ali Katz Kitchen I am not disappointed. This recent order of mac & cheese was excellent. Although it was frozen solid when I picked it up, it cooked up perfectly. This simple dish is just one example of the consistent quality of every thing made at Ali Katz.
What a gem! So sorry we didn't find this treasure sooner. Everything looked freshly baked and tasty - We had croissants, scones and coffee. We couldn't decide which was better! Absolutely delicious. We will certainly be back. It's always nice when you get to meet the actual owners. Everything made from scratch a few feet from where we bought it from - A rarity these days. Highly recommended! My wife wants to come back this weekend for the fried chicken.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I stopped in Ali Katz Kitchen with my wife, this past spring.What a unique boutique bakery and more!The Rugelach and Cookies were unforgettable, just writing about them has me salivating.I wish I had pictures to share!Everything tasted like the real deal made with care and quality ingredients, like my grandma would make.We are excited to return again in the fall.
If you haven't visited, it's a must for some of the best cookies, fresh salads, sweet treats and the best tchotchkes around! Don't forget to hang around for a bit! Fritz may come out of the kitchen and sing a tune or two with you! It's what local businesses are and should be about! They got us through pandemic and we haven't forgotten about them! Check out of Ali's talent!
Delicious rugelach!
Best bakery in North Fork. NYC standards baked goods, not that sweet. Very fresh and small batch. The reason I give this place a 3 stars is the owner itself, Ali Katz. Very rude, cranky old lady that doesn't have an idea how customer service works. Her husband is very nice and should work at the cashier and the desk interacting with customers, explaining things to them and have a good attitude. The old lady should sit in the kitchen and do what she does best, make baked goods. I don't understand why the owner and the other decent baker in North Fork (Jundas) have big egos and make the customer think that they are doing us a favor for cooking baked goods. We can live without them but they can't live without us customers!!
The tomato galette and the crostatas, made with the local fruits at peak season each week, are among the very best foods I have ever eaten. We serve them to guests, who are always amazed by how wonderful they are. Ali also makes the beat linzer tarts I have ever eaten.
NoFo Long Island review: Best Sat. Night Fried Chicken Dinner! Best Potato Salad! Best Biscuit! Best Sunday morning Scones! And The Nicest people. Thank you Aly & Fritz Wendy & John
Amazing homemade small batch goodies!! The mix berry scones are to die for!! Can’t wait to try the chocolate chip cookie
Restaurantji Recommends
What a treat to have this gem in my neighborhood. Truly amazing, well prepared, delicious food. You will not be disappointed. Deserts are delectable, soups so savory, dressings to die for...basically everything is amazing.
What can I say about this place. 2 almost stale cupcakes where the icing fell off from the bottoms. $5 each. 2 little chocolate Bundt cakes, individualSize portions $8 each. Nothin special. Not incredibly moist or anything to differentiate them fromAny other chocolate muffin. A Bag of oatmeal cookies. These were the best of the 3 but $12 for a little bag. Come on! $38 total. It was a joke. To top it off I asked if I could try one piece of Rugalach which I was willing to pay for. I was told ,no, we only sell them in six pieces portion. really? They were baked on a tray sitting right there! This was the owner! Needless to say, we will not be returning!
Croissants are TRULY UNBELIEVABLE. Order a day ahead of time. You will not regret it. Ours were warm at pickup. I’m not ashamed to say I had more than I should have and it was worth it!
I ordered 2 butternut galettes ( best thing I’ve ever eaten) and an assortment of soups and orzo with veggies for a house party. Everything was fresh and delicious. Will be ordering again. Thank you for quality and incredible taste. Hoping you expand this business
Noodle bowl was very tasty.