The ice cream at magic fountain is amazing especially the hard shell they dip it in. Ice cream in the cold weather you can never go wrong
Lorenzo Cast
not so magical as they say
Anna-Kaye Rowe
Love this ice cream shop. It's the perfect place for a treat, they have so many yummy flavors. On my most recent trip I tried the almond joy and hazelnut biscotti. 10/10!
Maya Kahane
The best ice cream I’ve ever had, hands down. Creative, ever-changing flavors and an extremely helpful staff. You’ll find yourself returning here again again and again. A true gem in the Northfork.
Janice Egan
Amazing so many choices. Worth every penny, and the 45 minute drive
Stephen Pratel Sr.
Best, ice cream on the North fork!
This place has been here since the '70s or as long as I can remember.
Very proud of the fact in 1979 when to make your own Sunday fad with a bunch of different toppings you could add was new, I invented (or so I believe in my own little world 🙂) the Oreo shake when I asked them to put a couple tablespoons of the crushed Oreo toppings into my soft serve milkshake. The lady working the counter looked at me like I was crazy but I talked her into it. Then when I was home visiting during college I saw they had it on their menu 🤣🤣🤣
Anyhow, it's wonderful to see this place still open and doing great business. If you're out on the East end or North fork, come to Mattituck and enjoy this local treasure.
George L.
Delicious ice cream. Some of the best on the island!
So many delicious and unique ice cream flavors! Their rotating seasonal options are especially exciting. Sweet corn in the summer is one of my favorites.
Jeneane Solz
This ice cream is staple to our north fork visits! They have awesome and creative flavors of hard ice cream, but don’t sleep on their soft serve which is so creamy and delicious!
Great ice cream friendly staff
The ice cream at magic fountain is amazing especially the hard shell they dip it in. Ice cream in the cold weather you can never go wrong
not so magical as they say
Love this ice cream shop. It's the perfect place for a treat, they have so many yummy flavors. On my most recent trip I tried the almond joy and hazelnut biscotti. 10/10!
The best ice cream I’ve ever had, hands down. Creative, ever-changing flavors and an extremely helpful staff. You’ll find yourself returning here again again and again. A true gem in the Northfork.
Amazing so many choices. Worth every penny, and the 45 minute drive
Best, ice cream on the North fork!
This place has been here since the '70s or as long as I can remember.
Very proud of the fact in 1979 when to make your own Sunday fad with a bunch of different toppings you could add was new, I invented (or so I believe in my own little world 🙂) the Oreo shake when I asked them to put a couple tablespoons of the crushed Oreo toppings into my soft serve milkshake. The lady working the counter looked at me like I was crazy but I talked her into it. Then when I was home visiting during college I saw they had it on their menu 🤣🤣🤣
Anyhow, it's wonderful to see this place still open and doing great business. If you're out on the East end or North fork, come to Mattituck and enjoy this local treasure.
Delicious ice cream. Some of the best on the island!
Simply the best ice cream around!
Always a good treat
Restaurantji Recommends
Rainbow cookie ice cream!!!!!!!!!
Magic Fountain had the best ice cream!
So many delicious and unique ice cream flavors! Their rotating seasonal options are especially exciting. Sweet corn in the summer is one of my favorites.
This ice cream is staple to our north fork visits! They have awesome and creative flavors of hard ice cream, but don’t sleep on their soft serve which is so creamy and delicious!
Best ice cream on the island!
Loading...