Magic Fountain
9825 Main Rd, Mattituck
(631) 298-4908
Customers' Favorites
Sprinkled Ice Cream Sandwiches
Cookie Monster
Rainbow Cookie
Birthday Cake
Goat Cheese
Brownie
Chip
Menu
Photos
+51 photos
+50 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Love this place - amazing home made ice cream in interesting seasonal flavors! They have all the normal flavors and they're amazing. If you're up for something out of the ordinary, try their summer sweet corn and kulfi ice creams!
Did you know this spot use to be a Dairy Queen? All the way back in 1977. Love that it has turned into a long running mom and pop shop. It is certainly a staple in the community - with a line around the block! They've got some eclectic flavors - like kulfi, goat cheese, vegan options and no sugar added options.
Skip the toppings, the star lost was for the stale topping - so just skip it. Because the ice cream is the star of the show and was a good consistency and...
Skip the toppings, the star lost was for the stale topping - so just skip it. Because the ice cream is the star of the show and was a good consistency and...
10/10 service, live up the street from them, there is a reason the lines are out the door because it’s so good, only thing I dislike is the hours but still have no complaints magic fountain is the way to go
You May Also Like
Tony’s Fusion North - 9650 NY-25
![]()
Asian Fusion, Asian
Michelangelo Pizzeria - 10095 Main Rd
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Vegetarian
CJ's American Grill - 10095 Main Rd
![]()
American, Bar, Vegetarian