Magic Fountain
9825 Main Rd, Mattituck
(631) 298-4908
Customers' Favorites
Sprinkled Ice Cream Sandwiches
Cookie Monster
Rainbow Cookie
Birthday Cake
Goat Cheese
Brownie
Chip
Menu
Photos
+54 photos
+53 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
The best ice cream I’ve ever had, hands down. Creative, ever-changing flavors and an extremely helpful staff. You’ll find yourself returning here again again and again. A true gem in the Northfork.
Best, ice cream on the North fork!
This place has been here since the '70s or as long as I can remember.
Very proud of the fact in 1979 when to make your own Sunday fad with a bunch of different toppings you could add was new, I invented (or so I believe in my own little world 🙂) the Oreo shake when I asked them to put a couple tablespoons of the crushed Oreo toppings into my soft serve milkshake. The lady working the counter looked...
This place has been here since the '70s or as long as I can remember.
Very proud of the fact in 1979 when to make your own Sunday fad with a bunch of different toppings you could add was new, I invented (or so I believe in my own little world 🙂) the Oreo shake when I asked them to put a couple tablespoons of the crushed Oreo toppings into my soft serve milkshake. The lady working the counter looked...
Love this place - amazing home made ice cream in interesting seasonal flavors! They have all the normal flavors and they're amazing. If you're up for something out of the ordinary, try their summer sweet corn and kulfi ice creams!
You May Also Like
Tony’s Fusion North - 9650 NY-25
![]()
Asian Fusion, Asian
Michelangelo Pizzeria - 10095 Main Rd
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Vegetarian
CJ's American Grill - 10095 Main Rd
![]()
American, Bar, Vegetarian