Case-Nic Cookies is a Medina institution, a testament to everything that is good and true about small town life. This locally run shop has been creating delicious baked goods for almost 30 years. I love the frosting on their freshly made birthday cakes! Case-Nic’s offers outstanding quality and value relative to baked goods found at chain supermarket stores.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
madymay4
I bought 2 dozen cupcakes and a giant cupcake for my daughters 6th birthday party and they came out so amazing!! They were fully customized for a Bluey color theme and they absolutely nailed it!! They took so much care with the order and made sure the giant cupcake was taped down so well, it lasted until we got it back home. These were the most delicious cupcakes I have ever had, they truly taste homemade and with so much love and care. I will definitely be ordering again for any and all baking needs, their website is so clear and concise and they really do make EVERYTHING!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kelli Birch
We have used Case Nic for the last 3 of my daughter’s birthday parties and the cupcakes are fabulous every time! Not only are they beautifully decorated, they taste great also!! Thank you again!
Danny Lambert
I ordered a raspberry chocolate cake 2 days before my wife's birthday they did a fantastic job on the cake it was amazing I will use them again thank you very much fair price and amazing
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
teresas716
Love this place so much! Every year I order cookies for my kids birthday's. They make just what we were looking for, and have it packaged and ready to take to school. Worth the half hour drive for me!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jesse Kelly
Cookies from here are sooooo DRY, they taste old.
Food: 1
Rapple Smith
Cookies from here are sooooo DRY, they taste old.
Food: 1
Colleen Sherman
Had these cookies and cupcakes for a graduation party they went above and beyond ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jamie Lotze
Delicious cookies! Dock your boat in Medina, Ny grab your cookies to go!
Food: 5
Cataldo Scarantine
They make some of the best cut-out cookies here! … and they will custom decorate them for any occasion!!
I live in Owensboro, KY. A colleague was back home in New York visiting her family over the holidays - while there, she stocked up on some cookies! She was kind enough to bring half a dozen over to me after she returned - she said it’s her favorite New York bakery. They freeze well and are positively the most delicious decorated cookies I’ve ever had! Planning to order and have some more shipped to me for a next special occasion! Hopefully I’ll be able to visit in-person some day. You have a fan all the way down in Kentucky!
Cheryl Wengrzycki
Friendly fast service. Yummy cookies, balloons, delivery
Theresa Neale
Super friendly service. Quick response and delicious cookies.
Lewanne Nettles
We’ve used Case-Nic Cookies for years! Their cookies always look great but more importantly taste delicious ! The owner is super easy to work with and their cookies are the perfect addition to any party!
Case-Nic Cookies is a Medina institution, a testament to everything that is good and true about small town life. This locally run shop has been creating delicious baked goods for almost 30 years. I love the frosting on their freshly made birthday cakes! Case-Nic’s offers outstanding quality and value relative to baked goods found at chain supermarket stores.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I bought 2 dozen cupcakes and a giant cupcake for my daughters 6th birthday party and they came out so amazing!! They were fully customized for a Bluey color theme and they absolutely nailed it!! They took so much care with the order and made sure the giant cupcake was taped down so well, it lasted until we got it back home. These were the most delicious cupcakes I have ever had, they truly taste homemade and with so much love and care. I will definitely be ordering again for any and all baking needs, their website is so clear and concise and they really do make EVERYTHING!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We have used Case Nic for the last 3 of my daughter’s birthday parties and the cupcakes are fabulous every time! Not only are they beautifully decorated, they taste great also!! Thank you again!
I ordered a raspberry chocolate cake 2 days before my wife's birthday they did a fantastic job on the cake it was amazing I will use them again thank you very much fair price and amazing
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love this place so much! Every year I order cookies for my kids birthday's. They make just what we were looking for, and have it packaged and ready to take to school. Worth the half hour drive for me!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cookies from here are sooooo DRY, they taste old.
Food: 1
Cookies from here are sooooo DRY, they taste old.
Food: 1
Had these cookies and cupcakes for a graduation party they went above and beyond ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious cookies! Dock your boat in Medina, Ny grab your cookies to go!
Food: 5
They make some of the best cut-out cookies here! … and they will custom decorate them for any occasion!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Great experience and delishousness abounds.
I live in Owensboro, KY. A colleague was back home in New York visiting her family over the holidays - while there, she stocked up on some cookies! She was kind enough to bring half a dozen over to me after she returned - she said it’s her favorite New York bakery. They freeze well and are positively the most delicious decorated cookies I’ve ever had! Planning to order and have some more shipped to me for a next special occasion! Hopefully I’ll be able to visit in-person some day. You have a fan all the way down in Kentucky!
Friendly fast service. Yummy cookies, balloons, delivery
Super friendly service. Quick response and delicious cookies.
We’ve used Case-Nic Cookies for years! Their cookies always look great but more importantly taste delicious ! The owner is super easy to work with and their cookies are the perfect addition to any party!
Loading...