Cusimano's Pizzeria

11358 Maple Ridge Rd, Medina
(585) 798-6288

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Chris Martin

thank you Cusimano's for the awesome service and fixing us up with a few slices to go! you made my pregnant wife very very happy as always! highly recommended if you are in the area.

Chris Gardner

Ordered 4 items. They got my sub wrong, order a blue cheese and an Italian dressing for other 2 items and didn’t get those. I went back to get the correct sub and the dressings. When I got back home That sub wasnt made right either. COME ON PEOPLE!! it’s not that complicated!! What the sub looks like when you get it

Food: 1

Mersades Coffta (Moments With Mersades)

The fries are wet. Lumpy soggy fries. I guess they think that's okay. Obv not oven. Def not deep fried. Probably microwaved fries. A cheeseburger sub does not come with ketchup or mayo. Fries are extra. 50$ for sub fries and mozz sticks. No. Not good.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 4

games_ be_laggin

We order from Cusimano’s on a fairly regular basis. We continue to return as customers because their food and service are AMAZING. From the pizza, to the wings, to one of the best beef on wecks I've had in a very long Iong time. Everything is ALWAYS excellent!! Highly recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wings, Sheet Pizza

Creig Shockley

So I placed an online order tonight for a supreme pizza with pepperoni ham bacon and onions only asked for square cut no Italian sausage and square cut. Even specified square cut a second time. Get the pizza and looking it over it's not square cut and there was Italian sausage on at least on 2 slices. I asked the girl that brought it to me if that was in fact sausage and that it wasn't square cut she said I don't believe it said no sausage but when she checked... it did say no sausage so she offered to remake it real quick. Ten minutes later new pizza. I verified square cut not thinking it would have the sausage after it being remade. Get it home and open it up... Sausage everywhere so my wife calls politely and asks to speak to the manager. Ends up he's the owners brother and very rude saying there's no sausage and he's looking at it come show him the sausage so we drive back up and on the way back I gave a detailed location on the pizza that the sausage was at to the wife. Surprise when we arrive and he shows us the pizza he conveniently threw those two slices in the garage that I told my wife it was on. Claims he cancelled the charge to my card and was extremely rude. They lost our business for sure even though they were the only ones in town that we buy pizza from. Extremely poor customer service and very disappointed

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Chris Clark

Ordered 2 orders of mild wings for pick up. There was minimal sauce, the wings were rubbery and just not good. We tossed them out half way through.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Connie Denk

Pizza wasn't bad overall. But for a kids size pizza made to order with bacon, pineapple and ricotta cheese. It has way to much ricotta. Made it really messy and over powered the pizza itself.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Frog People

Delicious pizza

Brooks Boyle

Great food, great people with a ton of culinary expertise and experience.

Melissa a Curtis

First/last time customer. My order was messed up. I was given the wrong Pizza. I ordered mild wings stated that they were for two kids and they were pretty much suicidal hot. Both of my kids who are 10 said the chicken tasted funny and was rubbery and burning their lips off 😂And it's pricey...I thought we would try it. It was a complete waste of my money.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 4

Sam Valimohamed

Well done guys!!! Looking forward to having this pizza again and again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

david waterfield

First time here... let me just start with the simplest of rules... any time there are no prices on the menu... prepare to pay more...
2 half subs and a Fri was 30$.... that's absolutely crazy...considering it's 1 ftlong sub and frys...
The steak sub was/is not shaved steak.. it's pre cooked fake steak. And the fries came with a generic brand of ketchup.. the sub is not a full 6" morelike 5... and the entire experience has left me with the same thing I knew when I walked in.. that I would never ever come back... what a scam... chops pizza shop offers a half sub fries and a 20oz for 8.99 Andis 10 mins away.....

Amanda Molina

Friendly service,nice atmosphere but foods not that great....ordered a chicken parmasean sub extra mozzarella and it hadn't cheese on it they made a new one and the new one had no cheese either and was soaked in garlic spread.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 5

Lura Kenward

We ordered a medium pizza with no cheese for my vegan son. The manager called us back to let me know the sauce had cheese in it as she was worried someone had a food allergy. So we ordered it with marinara no cheese, jalapenos, pineapple and olives. My son said it was a good pizza but I was a bit surprised that it cost me $25.00, other than that the experience was decent

Bradley Wilson

If I had 10 more minutes to live I wouldn’t go see my family or friends. I’d go have pizza and wings at this place again one last time

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sheet Pizza, Wings, Salad

Loading...