Bake Me a Cake! by Angela (made to order custom cakes)

If you’re looking for the best custom cakes on Long Island, look no further than Bake Me a Cake by Angela! I’ve been ordering from Angela for nearly 10 years, and she’s done every birthday cake and special dessert for my entire family. Her cakes are not only beautifully designed but also incredibly delicious. Always a hit at every celebration. Whether it’s a kid’s party, milestone birthday, or special event, Angela always delivers on time and goes above and beyond. She’s truly the best cake baker around!

First of all, the cake Angela made for my daughter's engagement was absolutely delicious!!! We picked moist yellow, strawberries and whipped cream filling and buttercream frosting. It was heavenly in taste and beautiful in looks. Sometimes a gorgeous cake disappoints in taste, but not Angela's. Everyone raved about it! Secondly, Angela was a pleasure to work with and I will be getting all my cakes from her. I am so thankful that I found her!

I am so lucky I was able to work with Angela and get a custom cake made for my husband’s birthday! She was able to accommodate my needs within a short time frame and after asking a few questions came up with some awesome ideas. Angela is so creative and was amazing to work with, executing the perfect presentation. She quickly answered all of my questions and was super flexible and responsive. My husband was blown away by the cake and it far exceeded my expectations. On top of all that, it was delicious! I will definitely be ordering from Angela in the future and couldn’t recommend her more. Thank you, Angela!

Angela makes the most Beautiful, most Delicious cakes and desserts Ever! I've been a repeat customer for years and will continue to look to her for any and every special occasion!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

10/10! Angela never fails to amaze me with her incredible work and is always a crowd pleaser. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

This is our 3rd cake by Angela and again it was amazing. She is very talented and her cakes are delicious aside from being beautiful to look at and better to eat!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Wedding Cake

Angela made a bus themed cake for our daughter’s 2nd birthday. We asked for some special characters to be riding the bus and Angela graciously accommodated our requests! The cake was absolutely gorgeous and tasted wonderful too! Besides our daughter, it was the star of the party. We highly recommend Angela and will definitely be requesting her services again in the future!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

I ordered a Barbie themed cake and gluten free cupcakes for my daughter's 5th bday and the flavors were incredible! The Barbie cake was strawberry cake with strawberry buttercream filling with vanilla frosting while the gluten-free cupcakes, which I refuse to share with anyone, were a chocolate cupcake with cannoli filling and almond frosting. My family are so happy there are leftovers. Highly recommend for any special occasion!

Dietary restrictions: Gluten free

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Cupcakes

No one better!! So very talented !

Dietary restrictions: She can do Non - dairy also ! Which is amazing :)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We got our wedding cake from Angela and it was AMAZING!! I would highly recommend getting a cake from her for any occasion. We ordered some tasting cupcakes to determine which flavor combo to go with and it was so hard to choose - the flavor and texture of her cakes are outstanding! Lots of compliments and questions where we ordered it from from our guests. Also, Angela was so helpful and easy to work with.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We got our wedding cake from Angela and it was AMAZING!! I would highly recommend getting a cake from her for any occasion. We ordered some tasting cupcakes to determine which flavor combo to go with and it was so hard to choose - the flavor and texture of her cakes are outstanding! Lots of compliments and questions where we ordered it from from our guests. Also, Angela was so helpful and easy to work with.

Angela truly rocks! Three times I've used her and always get absolutely fabulous and delicious cakes every time I've ordered. Everyone I know raves about how good her cakes are, once they've tasted them. They are always moist & flavourful as well as beautifully decorated.She's my forever, go to cake lady!Karen M. (Long Island)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

She fantastic cakes from my gender reveal to my daughters birthdays christening ect. Prices are so fair and her work is unbelievable!!!! Thank you.

I ordered a 2-tier cake from Bake Me A Cake by Angela for my daughter’s birthday, and it exceeded all expectations! The combination of cannoli filling that my lil one requested added a delightful twist to my cake, and I ordered some tres leches cupcakes which she matched to perfectly complement the theme. The flavors were rich, the presentation was impeccable, making them a standout centerpiece for the celebration. Highly recommend for anyone looking to elevate their cake experience! Was delivered locally and on time for the party, my future go to for cakes and party treats. Already booked my Valentine’s Day box!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Cupcakes, Wedding Cake

I am so happy we found Angela. She made us a beautiful and unique nautical cake for my father’s birthday. It was not only gorgeous to look at but was delicious as well. She was very pleasant in our interactions and I look forward to using her again. It also made me happy to support a small business and someone who is passionate about the work they are putting out as opposed to giving our money to a big chain bakery.