Banana Bread Co

250 Old Country Rd, Melville
(631) 424-2011

Recent Reviews

Treasure Juanita Arquieta

Just received a wonderful gift of two banana dark chocolate chip loaves and they are simply heavenly! They are the best I have ever tasted! I will be ordering from this company for future gifts.

john eng

Way over priced banana nut loaf, cost over $14. Taste the same as a 1.99 entenmanns loaf.

Marga Diaz

I truly love their breads especially the apple crumb and my son loves the Oreo one as well!! They truly put lots of love into their pastries and pies that truly makes your mouth drool just looking at them!!

Charlene Sorrentino (The Dog Chick)

The pies and the breads are the best I’ve ever had. Every gathering, every holiday in my family always includes something delicious from White Post Farms!!!!

Shelley Kraft

Best banana bread on Long Island. Delicious.

Cheeta X

the banana bread is moist and delicious same with the hot chocolate bread!

Melly G

Best. Banana Nut Bread. EVER! Moist, jaw-dropping deliciousness! Expectations utterly and completely exceeded! An absolute MUST!

Michael Meehan

Why don't you give the weight of your breads...

Elaine Slocum

Great banana bread; great zucchini bread; awesome pumpkin spice bread! Thank you Banana Bread Co!

Karina

I bought some bread while visiting the farm next door and I’ve been obsessed ever since. I make sure to get some banana bread every time I’m there. I also just ordered and it came the very next day nicely packaged. If you like banana bread they have the best.

Karina Giyasov

I bought some bread while visiting the farm next door and I’ve been obsessed ever since. I make sure to get some banana bread every time I’m there. I also just ordered and it came the very next day nicely packaged. If you like banana bread they have the best.

Ron Brooks

Is a good place to get a variety of pies when they have them. Bakery staff has changed not as nice as past staffers

Susan Dorsey

The chocate cheesecake bread and hot chocolate & oreo bread are a hit.

Brian Geber

If you are a foodie with high standards, you'll be disappointed but your casual banana bread fan may enjoy this since it's better than grocery store bakery bread. From order to delivery it took over a week for us. Delivery is through a slow priority mail box so the bread and cookies came dry with about 2 days of being edible left. They won't ship faster and ignore calls and order comments offering to pay more to get it faster. They don't call back or reply so you are on your own after you order. In the future I'll avoid slow ship bakeries like this.

Load More