Cirella's Restaurant

14 Broadhollow Rd, Melville
(631) 385-7380

Recent Reviews

Adam Pullar

Nolan was fantastic andnthe food was even better. This was my second time while traveling for business and I highly recommend it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

LarryVIP

Suburban Italian with separate bar area. Seems popular with locals and regulars. Food comes in giant portions; salads were good; main courses not so much. Pleasant service. Desserts were good.

Everything about this place is amazing. Jennifer was our waitress and she gave the best recommendations and attentiveness. We have the artichoke soup, calamari, veal parmigiana and kale/quinoa salad. Everything was delicious!

Gemma L.

Always good food and great service. Who knew a place could serve great sushi and great Italian!

hbbchef

Seated immediately. Drinks arrived promptly. Had to ask for water refills, then they began to be automatic. Appetizers ordered. Good portions and delicious but a tad too much garlic on the baked clams. Salmon a bit dry. Small portion of ice cream for affogato , I've had larger. Noise level a bit high. Will return.

JoyceN

Food was excellent. I had Valentine's special pasta with blackened shrimp and pink sauce. Appetizers were baked clams and fried zucchini and both were delicious. Creme brulle was delicious but should be served warm. Prices were normal for this economy.

Randino

I highly recommend this restaurant every time. We went on Valentines night and the place was hopping. They had our table as soon as we walked in. We ordered drinks, got a glass of rose and an old Fashion. The we shared a flat bread with figs, arugula and truffle oil as an appetizer. Very filling. Then we had red snapper over risotto with asparagus and boneless short rib with toasted gnocchi and spinach. These dishes were amazing!! What also made the evening special was the service. Even while it was very busy, the waiter was attentive and we didn't have to go looking for him. Thank you for a terrific dinner out.

Karen Bird

Our waitress on Saturday evening was wonderful. Thank you Susan. We came to Cirella's with our children to celebrate our marriage. We are grateful to the other kind patrons that bought our wine and the wonderful food and service from Susan and the kitchen. Cirella's is our family place! Thank you!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Yikes... I have never written a review but they need to learn how to use open table. I chose standard dining for my reservation and they sat us outside, in their porch area, 20 feet away from the highway. It was covered and somewhat heated but at least specify I'll be eating on the road before I do. They play music super loud to cover the racing cars passing us. The food was good, the waiter was great until he was overbooked and couldn't keep up with the crowds. If we were in the dining room setting like I would have expected (given I made this reservation earlier than 2 weeks before our dinner), our experience would have been rated higher. Luckily management compensated us for the troubles and we made the most of it but there were so many little things that added up, to really give us a negative impact on our overall experience.

Tim Walsh

Excellent food and

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

RoccoMassapequa

First time here believe it or not.... service was good....manager checked in on us. Started with the Edamane which was plain... zucchini pasta with bolognese sauce was good... cheese Ravioli was good. The beef meatballs were supper hard .... drinks were good

JeffS

We have been to Cirella's before, but not recently. Food was terrific and there were so many good options, it was hard to choose what to get. Our waiter seemed to get "lost" often and we waited for him more than once during the meal. Not sure if this was the norm for a Tuesday night, but the restaurant was incredibly noisy, with several large parties talking loud enough for the entire room to hear. We were a small table of two in the middle of some large, loud parties, and I was happy to leave for some quiet at the end of our meal.

Tom DeMarco

I came here for lunch during the early afternoon. We got the chicken meatballs as an appetizer which was very tasty. The sushi & sashimi part of the menu was a surprise, and I decided to indulge. The sashimi was very good! Well I have not eaten dinner here, and this was my only meal at this establishment, based on what I had it's definitely recommended and I will be revisiting on my next trip out this way!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Spencer48

Neighborhood gem. Always a warm hello, inviting menu and interesting specials. We had our favorite server which also enhances the experience. Nolan could not been more helpful or professional as he welcomed us back, took our drink order, and explained the specials . Our selections were timed perfectly and delicious as usual. We will be back

Tom S

Great dinner experience last night. My parents used to come here back in the day, so I figured I'd have to try it as well.The staff were all very friendly to us upon entering. We were sat quickly with no reservation, and the waitress in training was excellent. The beer selection was decent, and they had plenty of mixed drinks and wine as well.We skipped appetizers this time, although they did have some nice items on the menu. We split the capellini dello and the brasato di manzo. Both excellent, couldn't choose a favorite. The brasato di manzo had just the right amount of sauce, and everything went together well. The spinach was cooked perfectly, the gnocchi was firm but not undercooked, and the short rib just melted in your mouth. The capellini dello came together very well. The tender eggplant in the pasta had such a great flavor and texture. The dish itself was large, and we ended up taking a lot home.They also had sushi, which I was skeptical about at first, but after watching dish after dish come out, I wouldn't mind trying some next time. Looked great.Parking: Decent size parking lot.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More