One10

569 Broadhollow Rd, Melville
(631) 694-3333

Recent Reviews

Sort by
alan krawitz

Took my wife here for her birthday, last Saturday, and was not disappointed! First visit and just about everything was spot-on, just as you'd expect at a Scotto venue.

Started with a specialty cocktail, she had a Cosmo and I had a Grey Goose, expertly blended. For dinner, she went with the classic chicken Parmigiana and I opted for filet mignon with mushrooms marsala. Both excellent. We added two sides: sauteed spinach and mashed garlic potatoes. Generous portions but most importantly, you can tell that both dishes were prepared by experience chefs who know what they're doing.

We ended dinner splitting a chocolate cake with peanut butter moose and One10 added a comp. homemade, nutella donut with a candle! Service was friendly and super-attentive.

Overall, a great experience. We'll definitely be back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

john bila

Top of the line restaurant
Amazing food, service and experience, a little pricey but the quality is worth it. Amazing clean. Worth the treat.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Tatiana St

Stay away from this place.
The restaurant is severely understaffed, and the service reflects it. Everything was extremely slow — I had to repeatedly ask for water, drinks, and even takeout boxes.

The steak was not edible.

When the check arrived, I noticed they had added a 20% tip twice. When I pointed it out to the waiter, he told me I was being “nasty” and walked away. Another employee tried to “figure it out” with a calculator and still struggled. It took nearly half an hour for them to fix the mistake.

To make matters worse, I now see multiple charges on my credit card.

As someone who hosts many business events, this was one of the most horrendous dining experiences I’ve ever had. Double-check your bill — or better yet, avoid this place altogether

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 1

Chris Olberding

The perfect spot for a long over due meet up for friends / family !!!! Besides the wonderful atmosphere the service and food were spectacular. Tom and Jack not only made us feel welcomed but took all of our questions into consideration. We went with two specials and the halibut and everything was great. Can’t say enough good things about this restaurant! We will be back !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

amanda causa

I made reservations at One 10 for our anniversary The waiters Joe and Mauricio were fantastic very attentive and professional! The cocktails were on point . The food was amazing , We had the special appetizer flank steak with tortellini , For main course we had Bronzino and chicken milanese . The dessert was so delicious warm zeppoli‘s with side sauces of Nutella Carmel and apple. They even brought out a warm doughnut with nutella and wrote on the plate Happy Anniversary ! Everything even down to the coffee was Fantastic !! We will be coming back soon ,We will request Joe and Mauricio they made our experience at One 10 Perfect !!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cassandra Quinlan

So, this review is difficult! Firstly I forgot my servers name ( but she looks like Emma Stone!) she was absolutely amazing! She accommodated our allergies, dislikes and seat change with poise and respect, consistently checked on us, just simply a joy! The atmosphere was inviting ( though a large space) it was not overwhelming and loud. I have been in hospitality for 30 years! As well as my partner whose birthday we came to celebrate. We are not the types to mention what we do, great service should be a given regardless. That service includes the food! This is where One10 fell short! Now when I started out in fine dining decades ago, salt and pepper on the table was a no no! Food should leave the kitchen perfectly seasoned, which is a huge feat considering that we all have different palates and preferences. However, the basic use of salt and pepper specifically when cooking meat! Is essential, I am grateful that salt and pepper in this instance was at the table! Although you can not properly add what is needed after the meat is cooked! We were collectively disappointed as this was our first time here, would we be back? Ehh, possibly to sit at the bar, not sure we would eat the food again, as I use to tell my cooks, that red box in the pantry ( kosher salt) is your best friend! Use it!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Latosha Talavera

We (husband & I) dined at One10 for the first time tonight for our little brother's birthday and had a wonderful time! Our usual Anthony Scotto restaurant is Rare650, but the food, service, and ambiance at One10 was definitely one to remember.

We were served by Lindsay, and she was quite fun and pleasant. She and the other woman (I sincerely apologize for not directly asking for your name) entertained our obnoxious family as we order ample appetizers, drinks, and Entrées.

Our family ordered majority of the items from the 5 bar plus signature cocktails, special items of the night, and of course, two Wagyu Tomahawks (one for each brother lol).

Thank you for the perfect round table and time for us to share Roaring laughs and animated conversations.

We truly appreciate the extra care taken to bring in our surprise cheesecake to end the night on a special note. Looking forward to visiting again, I'll remember that Lindsay only graces the floor on Saturdays ❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

ToniMarie Chiavola

I came to One10 for dinner to celebrate my friend’s birthday and we had such an amazing experience. We ordered a ton of food and everything came out so quickly. We even had two waiters Mauricio and Dom taking care of us, and the service was on point the entire night.

The restaurant itself is beautiful and clean, with a great steakhouse vibe and plenty of options for both food and drinks. Be ready to spend some money but it is worth it for a nice night out. Every dish we ordered was fresh, flavorful, and absolutely delicious. We didn’t have a single issue from start to finish.

Overall, an incredible dining experience. I’ll definitely be back and highly recommend One10 to anyone looking for great food, great service, and a great atmosphere!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joey Neto

Dom and Mauricio took great care of us tonight making our birthday celebration that much more special! Food, atmosphere, and especially service was 10/10

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mike Hunt

Went here for a birthday, had a really nice evening and experience! Overall a great place !

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

David Revilla

Great ambiance, attentive bar staff, definitely deserves another visit

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Christian Roula

Not worth the money. For 2 persons with a total check including tip amounted to $300, there is many other options at that price range. Our thanksgiving dinner was a total culinary ripoff— the food at best was Cafeteria grade, very mediocre, pretentious in appearance to mask the lack of experience in ownership and employees— A TOTAL BUST.

If you are a foodie this not the place to frequent. Again what do you expect from a Long Island Restaurant even tho Mr. Scotto is more of a caterer than a restauranteur.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

michael maher

Jack and Tommy were outstanding : Professional , courteous and they knew the food and drink list very well . It was an overall perfect experience. This is real New York style Italian food that we lack in AZ !!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

peter winick

We went for happy hour. Great wine, wonderful charcuterie and the bartender was fantastic.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jack Reisinger

Had a great dinner tonight here at One10. Food was very delicious, I had the porterhouse it definitely itched the steak crave. Drinks were great and my server Mauricio was helpful as well. Will be back again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...