This restaurant has great pizza and salad in an Italian style restaurant. They even have gluten free and vegetarian options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Haleigh Johnson
Friendly service and order was delivered on time and accurate. Pizza and wings were very good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Card
Beautiful place, delicious pizza, and timely service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Timothy Morse (Tim)
Large slices for a good price
Rochelle Peabody
Consistently delivering excellent eats! Love the wings *crispy* and the pizza is always great! Friendly phone service, convenient online ordering and delivery.
Elliott Bassett
Had the margarita pizza xl and a couple beer- very good
Halle Bristol
Good Lord this place was tasty. Amazing staff too!!
scott
The food is good but kind of expensive
Brianna Halstead
So I’ve tried this place 3x and each time I was kind of disappointed. Cheese pizza is good, but the pepperoni was swimming in grease, the “brownie” I had was ligit the exact same thing as another big chain restaurant (they listed as cake tho) had my bf try it just to make sure I wasn’t insane. He agreed. Had the cheesecake with the strawberries and I don’t think I’ve ever had a cheesecake so tangy and with no crust, I actually didn’t finish it. There’s a few other problems but they do try to fix them when told about it.
Charles David
Already ate some before this pic but they were amazing. Great food. Friendly staff.
I took my son to Stefanos in Mexico NY tonight because it’s close by, and it’s Italian and I love it there. I wasn’t let down, and I never have been. This restaurant consistently just lays it down when it comes to fair prices, excellent food, and a nice atmosphere. Any dish you order will be a generous portion, and will be hot and delicious. The pizza is sooooooo good. The crust is killer, never over cooked, and perfect each time. The sauce is fantastic and compliments the crust with an amazing gum line, and the toppings are always fresh. The Buffalo chicken wings were to die for, cooked just right, with a nice sauce with a bite to it, hot, but not overbearing. There was also a pleasant slight sweetness to the sauce, and you just have to try it. The restaurant itself is always clean, and the staff are courteous. I would take anyone to Stefanos without concern that an amazing meal would be served. Solid, consistent, and amazing.
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Wings
Joshua Pittsley
U guys are awesome!!! U guys always have a smile on ur face. There is no competition at all. Hands down. Cleanliness is a 10/10 not to mention word around town is damiano's has cockaroaches. They were spotted in an upstairs apartment and a bad experience with a customer to make a long story short.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Apollo Starr
Staff is very kind but the food is very blah. Pizza isn't the best and the bread sticks are just thick bread. I also thought for the quality the food was overpriced.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
Candy Shortsleeve
Sorry was not done on my review. They place smelled of pot were someone had been smoking before or during our dinner.with all this said I don't blame the waitress she was doing everything she could to keep it all going.They need more staff and better food. The new menu doesn't leave much to choose from , they hand no desserts or salad bar, or hot foods buffet, guess we will have to find a better place to eat dinner.
shannan Bennett
I have to say after not ordering from this location for quite some time, it was such a nice welcome back tonight. The girl who answer the phone was pleasant, knowledgeable and did an over all great job taking my order. When picking up, the staff was cheerful, welcoming and on top of their game. Such a wonderful turn around from the last time we ordered! We will definitely be ordering again!
This restaurant has great pizza and salad in an Italian style restaurant. They even have gluten free and vegetarian options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Friendly service and order was delivered on time and accurate. Pizza and wings were very good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Beautiful place, delicious pizza, and timely service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Large slices for a good price
Consistently delivering excellent eats! Love the wings *crispy* and the pizza is always great! Friendly phone service, convenient online ordering and delivery.
Had the margarita pizza xl and a couple beer- very good
Good Lord this place was tasty. Amazing staff too!!
The food is good but kind of expensive
So I’ve tried this place 3x and each time I was kind of disappointed. Cheese pizza is good, but the pepperoni was swimming in grease, the “brownie” I had was ligit the exact same thing as another big chain restaurant (they listed as cake tho) had my bf try it just to make sure I wasn’t insane. He agreed. Had the cheesecake with the strawberries and I don’t think I’ve ever had a cheesecake so tangy and with no crust, I actually didn’t finish it. There’s a few other problems but they do try to fix them when told about it.
Already ate some before this pic but they were amazing. Great food. Friendly staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Slice
Restaurantji Recommends
I took my son to Stefanos in Mexico NY tonight because it’s close by, and it’s Italian and I love it there. I wasn’t let down, and I never have been. This restaurant consistently just lays it down when it comes to fair prices, excellent food, and a nice atmosphere. Any dish you order will be a generous portion, and will be hot and delicious. The pizza is sooooooo good. The crust is killer, never over cooked, and perfect each time. The sauce is fantastic and compliments the crust with an amazing gum line, and the toppings are always fresh. The Buffalo chicken wings were to die for, cooked just right, with a nice sauce with a bite to it, hot, but not overbearing. There was also a pleasant slight sweetness to the sauce, and you just have to try it. The restaurant itself is always clean, and the staff are courteous. I would take anyone to Stefanos without concern that an amazing meal would be served. Solid, consistent, and amazing.
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Wings
U guys are awesome!!! U guys always have a smile on ur face. There is no competition at all. Hands down. Cleanliness is a 10/10 not to mention word around town is damiano's has cockaroaches. They were spotted in an upstairs apartment and a bad experience with a customer to make a long story short.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Staff is very kind but the food is very blah. Pizza isn't the best and the bread sticks are just thick bread. I also thought for the quality the food was overpriced.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
Sorry was not done on my review. They place smelled of pot were someone had been smoking before or during our dinner.with all this said I don't blame the waitress she was doing everything she could to keep it all going.They need more staff and better food. The new menu doesn't leave much to choose from , they hand no desserts or salad bar, or hot foods buffet, guess we will have to find a better place to eat dinner.
I have to say after not ordering from this location for quite some time, it was such a nice welcome back tonight. The girl who answer the phone was pleasant, knowledgeable and did an over all great job taking my order. When picking up, the staff was cheerful, welcoming and on top of their game. Such a wonderful turn around from the last time we ordered! We will definitely be ordering again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...