Maggie's eatery

465 NY-25A, Miller Place
(631) 828-5554

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Fried Chicken Bowl
Chicken Milanese
Maggie's Burger
Fried Fluke Gyro
Chopped Cheese
Steak Sandwich
Avocado Toast
Arugula Salad
French Fries
Shrimp Tacos

Appetizers
Wings
Your choice of Buffalo, BBQ, Sweet Thai Chili or "Slap Ya Mama" dry rub. Served with bleu cheese dressing and celery sticks. (8 per order).
Nachos
Three cheese blend, jalapenos and black beans, topped with Pico de Gallo, sour cream and guacamole.
Avocado Toast
Smashed avocado on toasted ciabatta topped with arugula, radish and everything bagel seasoning. (add queso fresco +1, add a fried egg +2).
Chips and Guac
Guacamole and Pico de Gallo served with homemade corn tortilla chips.

Salads
Greek Salad
Chopped iceberg lettuce, mixed Mediterranean olives, cucumbers, grape tomatoes, red onion and feta cheese with a Greek dressing served with toasted pita bread.
Bacon & Egg Salad
Baby arugula with hard-boiled egg, pickled red onion, crispy bacon, everything bagel seeds and spiced croutons in a red wine vinaigrette.
Spring Salad
Mixed greens, fresh strawberries, avocado and whipped ricotta. Dressed in a balsamic vinaigrette.

Handhelds
Steak Sandwich
Marinated skirt steak cooked to your liking on toasted garlic ciabatta bread, with mozzarella cheese, fried onions, and arugula served with your choice of French fries or a side salad.
Burger
6-ounce patty cooked to your liking on a toasted brioche bun with lettuce and tomato served with your choice of French fries or a side salad. Add: American, Cheddar, or Mozzarella +1.5 Bacon +2 Egg* +2 Guacamole +3 Make it a double +3
Lobster Salad Roll
Homemade lobster salad served on a toasted potato roll with your choice of French fries or a side salad.
Chopped Cheese
Chopped beef, caramelized onions, American cheese, shredded lettuce and diced tomato with special sauce served with your choice of French fries or a side salad.
Chicken Bahn Mi
Organic fried chicken, pickled vegetables, hoisin mayo on toasted ciabatta bread with your choice of French fries or a side salad.
Eggplant Sandwich
Crispy fried eggplant, herbed whipped ricotta, vinegar peppers, basil aioli on ciabatta bread served with your choice of French fries or a side salad.
Maggie's XL Tacos
Your choice of protein, chipotle mayo, corn salsa, queso fresco, guacamole and Napa cabbage. 2 per order.
Cubano
House roasted pork and pickles with Virginia ham on toasted ciabatta bread, with chipotle mayo, and aged Swiss served with your choice of French fries or a side salad.

Entrees
Salmon Bowl
Pan seared salmon cooked to your liking over sushi rice and seaweed salad with cucumbers, radishes, scallions, nori flakes and sliced jalapenos topped with a hoisin aioli.
Tuna Poke Bowl
Sesame soy marinated Ahi Tuna served over sushi rice and seaweed salad with edamame, cucumbers, radishes and guacamole topped with toasted sesame seeds.
Stir Fry
White rice, sauteed with fresh vegetables and ponzu sauce. Served with an over easy egg*.
Fish N Chips
Montauk Brewing Company beer battered Flounder, served with Maggie's tartar sauce and French fries.
Macaroni and Cheese
Cheesy macaroni with herbed breadcrumbs.
Lo Mein
House roasted pork, stir fry vegetables, sesame sauce, and @Happynoodle208 noodles.

Kids
Chicken Fingers
Three fried chicken fingers served with French fries.
Grilled Cheese
Inside out burger bun with American cheese served with French fries.
Kids Fish N Chips
Batter fried Cod served with Maggie's tartar sauce and French fries.

Drinks
Ginger Ale
16 oz
Sprite
16 oz
Water Bottle
Diet Coke
16 oz

Dessert
Churros
Caramel Filled Churros

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: google
+21 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+20 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Highly recommend! Our food was deeeeelicious!! So many options on the menu that I wanted that I will need to come back to try more! What a gem. We went here after visiting the farmstands and we are so happy that we did. What a treat. Staff was super friendly and accommodating.
September 2024
My wife and I stopped here earlier on a whim. We were so glad we did. My wife had the avocado toast and I had a chopped cheese. Both were amazing. We'll definitely be returning. Also...the fries are heavenly lol Some of the best I've ever had. Thanks again!
September 2024
Maggie's Eatery is our go-to spot in Miller Place! The food is consistently delicious, with a menu that offers something for everyone. From the moment you walk in, you're greeted with a warm, friendly atmosphere. The staff at Maggie's are attentive and genuinely care about their customers, ensuring that you'll be satisfied. The locally-owned charm and commitment to quality are evident in every dish they serve. We absolutely love Maggie's Eatery and highly...
August 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Papa Juan Deli - 451 Rte 25A Store #12
Deli, American, Spanish, Greek
Buffalo Wild Wings - 385 Rte 25A
Chicken Wings, Sports Bar, American, Vegetarian
Wendy's - 380 Rte 25A
Fast Food, Burgers

Maggie's eatery

465 NY-25A, Miller Place, NY 11764
(631) 828-5554