McNulty's Ice Cream Parlor

More than just delicious homemade ice cream! Organized, flexible, and very willing to make sure your party has all you want and need to be a hit!

Had to choose 3 times 3 different types of ice creams . They didn't have the stuff needed for ice cream. Ordered the long islander and it was missing chocolate chips. Ordered strawberry shortcake and it was missing crumbs. Did not get what was advertised. 1 star because it was ice cream.

There seasonal flavors are fantastic

We recently hosted a birthday party at McNutly’s Ice Cream, and it was absolutely perfect! From start to finish, everything was seamless and fun. Gail, the owner, went above and beyond to make sure every detail was taken care of. The space was clean, festive, and welcoming, and the kids had the best time. The ice cream, of course, was a huge hit—delicious and so many toppings to choose from. I can’t recommend McNutly’s enough for a celebration. Thank you, Gail and the rest of your team, for making the day so special!

Fabulous

This is one of my favorite Ice Cream parlors on Long Island. They make their own Ice Cream in-house and the prices are fair. In the summer, the lines for service can be long. But there’s a reason for that. Give them a shot of you’re in the area. You won’t be disappointed.

Great place.. they make great cakes and they show support to charities that help people..

wonderful place , wonderful people , wonderful ice cream..
Give it a try

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Butter Pecan, Cherry Pistachio, Black Raspberry Truffle, Cappuccino Fudge Crunch, Strawberry, Milk Shake Float, Dishes, Ice Cream Soda, Old Fashion Waffles and Ice Cream, Sundaes, Banana Split, James' Carmel Creation, Raspberry Truffle, Waffle Bowl, Mom mc Nulty's Traditional Style, Jame's Carmel Creation

Great homemade ice cream

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Excellent home made ice cream

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great local homemade icecream staff is very friendly prices are reasonable.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This ice cream shop is usually packed in the summer time. But if you got some loose cash, it’s well worth the wait.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Waffle Bowl Ice Cream

Sorry to write this because I’m local but so damn tired of being ripped off. The absolute worst ice cream I’ve ever had!! $18.50 for 1 small cup and 1 large I might have just as well ripped up my money or better… go to 7-11 and buy off brand ice cream way better. So disgusted but go ahead people.. in theory. It’s a cute place to bring kids to if have throw away money! Sorry. I’m pissed off

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 1

Very nice!!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Let me start off by saying I’ve been coming here for the past 6 years now and have never turned around and walked out without anything. I walked in at 10:12 pm when the website and maps said they close at 10:30 pm. I ordered a milkshake, and the young guy said, "I’m sorry, we closed at 10 pm, but we can give you hard ice cream quickly if you want." I said, "I looked at the map, and it said you guys don’t close until 10:30 pm, though," and he said, "Well, it’s 10 pm." I was very disappointed and shocked that I was basically told no.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 1

Great ice cream. Poorly trained staff.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 3