Alexandros Restaurant

1060 NY-25A, Mt Sinai
(631) 928-8600

Recent Reviews

Sort by
David

We had been to Alexandros once before, several years ago, and honestly, we can't believe we hadn't been back sooner. We went for our wedding anniversary and EVERYTHING was perfect. Food, service, atmosphere.. Staff couldn't have been more accomodating, food came out quick, it was absolutely *amazing*. We WILL be back and much sooner than last time!

JoeP

The food was outstanding! It felt like we were away, dining on the outdoor patio! The service was excellent and they could not be more accommodating. Thank you!

Yanni

Alexandros is a solid spot for classic Greek food. The gyros are excellent—tender meat, fresh toppings, and flavorful tzatziki on soft pita. Definitely one of the better gyro spots around. The baklava is also great—crispy, not overly sweet, with a good balance of nuts and honey. Worth saving room for. Service is friendly, prices are reasonable, and everything tastes freshly made. A reliable choice if you're craving Greek.

Lorraine

Outstanding service. From the person who greeted us, to the the girl who filled our water, everyone was very welcoming, friendly and attentive. One of our party used a walker, and the restaurant is accessible to both inside and out through the front. Food was good, hummus and tzatziki were a bit too garlicy for some in our party, but personally, I loved both. The moussaka and falafel were stand outs, both delicious!

joe

great lamb chops and oysters and clams app was outstanding wife had the halibut and loved it

Dutch

As someone who worked in the food industry and owned my own restaurants, I can’t say enough about this particular establishment. The food is not just good, it's truly excellent, showcasing a commitment to quality that is hard to find. The service matches the quality of the food—it's consistently great, reflecting the professionalism and courtesy of the staff. They possess excellent manners and are clearly dedicated to ensuring that all customers’ needs are met. While it’s understandable that some patrons may occasionally feel overlooked, especially during busy times, it's important to recognize that the staff can only attend to one table at a time. However, rest assured that eventually everyone is attended to, ensuring that each guest's experience is pleasant and satisfying.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Rita

Alexandros is our favorite “go to” place. My husband and I have never had a bad meal once. The food is always delicious and service is always on point. We especially enjoy eating in the outdoor patio area.

Diane

Wonderful place won't be disappointed. Tried it for restaurant week and one of the best in my opinion.

Kathy

Food is always so good, unfortunately the noise level was unbearable. Group of six people that were actually yelling which made another table turn up their volume. Met another couple as we were leaving who shared our disappointment with the volume.

Barbara Voss

We love this delightful Greek restaurant... the food and service is exceptional and constant. Also they make the best martini and Oysters...

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Spiced Lamb Chops and Lemon Potatoes, Orzo Salad

Samantha Vogel-Hespos

Great Greek restaurant locally. They also serve some American food as well. It’s on the pricey side but very well worth it. You will definitely enjoy your experience here.

Frank DiLernia

From the moment we walked into the restaurant we were warmly greeted. Katie our waitstaff was exceptional!! Food served in a timely manner to each course ?. Highly recommended, we'll be back !!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

John Gebbie

Old time Greek Restaurant serving traditional food indoors and outdoors. Dated bar and 60's music make the location special.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Monday Muscles Various Styles

JULIAN ORTIZ

New to the neighborhood, wanted to try it out. Came in for a quick bite on late sunday and did not disappoint. I was surprised to see the patio, really cute and cozy. Food was good. Octopus could’ve been a bit more tender, calamari sauce was to die for, wifey loved the fish tacos. Service was just enough. Will be back for sure.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Everything Calamari

Tom lieberman

Wheelchair accessibility: Entrance thru the front

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...