Bagels Your Way

331 Rte 25A #10, Mt Sinai
(631) 473-8266

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Big Meaty

food's real good, prices are real bad, and there's a serious attitude problem here.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 3

Chet Soni

I spoke to William here on the phone prior to placing an order on an app to make sure they can customize what I wanted - I placed the order only after he said he can do it - and then when I came for pick up he back said he cannot. I would not have come here was i not for the discounts being offered through the app - now I will not be coming for any reason - thanks William.

Service: 1

Masiel Rodriguez

I normally go right on your site and make my order but now the site is down is there some place else to see the catering

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Dave Fry

I don't write reviews really but, the bagels were very large light and fluffy. They were great and Anna the girl that helped me was such a nice person. It was a great experience

Ryan Munkwitz

I’ve tried pretty much every deli in the area and they make the best Breakfast sandwich so far.

Shelley Smith

Excellent egg sandwich this morning. Home fries are absolutely delicious! Will be back again!

PETER RODOLFY

THE SERVICE WAS OK THE COFFEE WAS HOT the bagel they forgot the tomatoes and onion. But charged me for it

Echo Five Photography

This place is amazing. Big and fresh bagels

XONDA BEATS

Pickles not that bad

AnnMarie Pszybylski

VERY grateful to Brian for waiting after closing for me to pick up my order. Not a good week for a multitude of reasons and I forgot I placed my order for pick up. I called, he said no worries, if not today another time I can pick up a replacement order. THIS is why I travel there. So kind, accommodating and always a kind word. And let's not forget the yummy bagels. ALWAYS a hit in my household. Oodles of thanks Bagels Your Way, we will be back.

K C

Absolutely disgusting!! Gave me olive cream cheese instead of veggie! How do you mess that up. It’s not that hard to put cream cheese on a bagel! Food is gross and service is even more terrible.

C C

Used to love this place, was my go to for an egg sandwich with turkey sausage. Today I received a pathetic sandwich that didn’t taste good at all. They went from a great, full-sized, flavorful sausage patty to these dry, tiny little sausage discs. For the price, not worth it. The saving grace here is the crispy potatoes, still good. Unsure if I will return.

Sean Mcnally

Excellent

J

Great bagels but would be nice if an egg sandwich came with eggs!!! Ordered 7 egg sandwiches and 4/7 came with no egg on it! Not to mention we gave them a note with everything written down!

mark lewandowski

Good food friendly staff prices skyrocketed from 5.75 to 8.50 for a simple bacon egg a cheese on roll which is an absolute insult to customers but apparently everyone in the country has to screw the consumer these days

Loading...