Benchwarmer's Tavern and Grill

23 Rte 25A, Mt Sinai
(631) 509-4077

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Salad
Sweet Potato Fries
French Onion Soup
Smothered Nachos
Marinated Burger
Waffle Fries
Potato Skins
Patty Melt
Mini Tacos
French Dip

Menu

Panini's
Grilled Chicken Panini
Grilled chicken marinated in our house marinade topped with melted mozzarella, spinach, and red roasted peppers. All paninis are served with your choice of side, pickle, and coleslaw.
Grilled Vegetables Panini
Grilled mushrooms, sauteed onions, spinach, and tomatoes topped with mozzarella cheese and topped and balsamic vinaigrette dressing. All paninis are served with your choice of side, pickle, and coleslaw.

Appetizers
Benchwarmers Sampler
Wings, mozzarella sticks, mini tacos, and potato skins.
Wings
Jumbo or boneless. Your choice of mild, medium, hot, teriyaki, or garlic parmesan, BBQ, or honey BBQ.
Marinated Steak Tidbits
Tender cuts of sirloin in our house marinade grilled to your liking and served with garlic bread and horseradish cream sauce.
Spinach and Artichoke Dip
Chopped spinach and artichoke hearts in a warm creamy garlic parmesan dip served with tortilla chips.
Smothered Nachos
Tortilla chips topped with melted cheddar cheese, chili, olives, jalapenos, tomatoes, and lettuce served with salsa and sour cream.
Mini Tacos
Crunchy hard shell tacos served with salsa, sour cream, and cheddar cheese dipping sauce.
Pretzel Sticks
Soft Bavarian pretzel twists baked with butter, topped with salt, and served with cheddar cheese dipping sauce.
Quesadilla
A melted cheddar cheese blend in a flour tortilla served with salsa and sour cream. Add chicken or steak for an additional charge.
Calamari
Fresh floured or buffalo-style calamari fried and served with a side of marinara sauce and lemon.
Potato Skins
Potato skins stuffed with melted cheeses and bacon served with a side of sour cream.
Mozzarella Sticks
Breaded mozzarella cheese served with a side of marinara sauce.
Chicken Fingers
Fried chicken tenders served with a side of honey mustard.
Shrimp Cocktail
Served chilled with a side of cocktail sauce and a lemon.

Soups and Salads
French Onion Soup
Bowl of our French onion soup topped with Swiss and mozzarella cheeses.
Bruschetta Chicken Salad
Romaine lettuce topped with golden fried chicken, diced tomatoes, red onions, fresh mozzarella cheese, olive oil, and drizzled with balsamic glaze.
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, and croutons drizzled with Caesar dressing.
Greek Salad
Iceberg lettuce topped with feta cheese, kalamata olives, capers, roasted red peppers, red onions, and tomatoes served with red wine vinaigrette dressing.
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Romaine lettuce topped with crispy buffalo chicken, tomatoes, red onions, and chopped bacon served with your choice of ranch or bleu cheese dressing.
Garden Salad
Large garden salad with lettuces, tomatoes, carrots, onions, and croutons. Served with your choice of dressing.
Chili
Bowl of our fresh chili.
Chicken Noodle Soup
Bowl of our homemade chicken noodle soup.
Cranberry Salad
Iceberg lettuce topped with dried cranberries, red onions, walnuts, tomatoes, and cucumbers served with your choice of dressing.

Sides of Sauce
Ranch
2 ounces side. Extra sides of sauce.
Sour Cream
2 ounces side. Extra sides of sauce.
Signature Bw Sauce
2 ounces side. Extra sides of sauce.
Buffalo Wing Sauce Hot
2 ounces side. Extra sides of sauce.
Honey Mustard
2 ounces side of honey mustard. Extra sides of sauce.
Thousand Island
2 ounces side. Extra sides of sauce.
BBQ Sauce
2 ounces side. Extra sides of sauce.
Buffalo Wing Sauce Mild
2 ounces side. Extra sides of sauce.
Blue Cheese
2 ounces size of blue cheese. Extra sides of sauce.
Maple Mayo
2 ounces side. Extra sides of sauce.
Salsa
2 ounces side. Extra sides of sauce.
Caesar Dressing
2 ounces side. Extra sides of sauce.
Horseradish Sauce
2 ounces side. Extra sides of sauce.
Balsamic Dressing
2 ounces side. Extra sides of sauce.
Marinara
2 ounces side. Extra sides of sauce.

Burgers
Cheese Burger
Burger served with your choice of melted American, Swiss, mozzarella, or cheddar cheese. All burgers are 8 ounces of fresh ground sirloin. Served with your choice of side, coleslaw, and a pickle. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Plain Burger
Freshly ground beef grilled and served to your liking. All burgers are 8 ounces of fresh ground sirloin. Served with your choice of side, coleslaw, and a pickle. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Marinated Burger
A charbroiled burger marinated in our house recipe and grilled to your liking. All burgers are 8 ounces of fresh ground sirloin. Served with your choice of side, coleslaw, and a pickle. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Cajun Burger
Lightly cajun burger topped with crispy fried onion straws and drizzled with buffalo sauce. All burgers are 8 ounces of fresh ground sirloin. Served with your choice of side, coleslaw, and a pickle. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Turkey Burger
8 ounces of freshly ground turkey grilled to perfection. All burgers are 8 ounces of fresh ground sirloin. Served with your choice of side, coleslaw, and a pickle. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Patty Melt Burger
Burger smothered with melted Swiss cheese and sautéed onion served on toasted marble rye bread. All burgers are 8 ounces of fresh ground sirloin. Served with your choice of side, coleslaw, and a pickle. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Boca Burger
Chopped vegetables are made into a delicious burger substitute. All burgers are 8 ounces of fresh ground sirloin. Served with your choice of side, coleslaw, and a pickle. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses especially if you have certain medical conditions.

Sandwiches and Wraps
French Dip
Warmed boar's head roast beef served on a toasted bun with melted mozzarella and served with a side of au jus for dipping. All sandwiches and wraps are served with your choice of side, pickle, and coleslaw. All wraps are served with your choice of whole wheat or flour tortilla. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Reuben
Your choice of thin sliced corned beef or turkey topped with sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and Russian dressing on grilled thick rye bread. All sandwiches and wraps are served with your choice of side, pickle, and coleslaw. All wraps are served with your choice of whole wheat or flour tortilla. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Steak Hero
Tender sliced steak topped with mozzarella cheese and crispy fried onions served on a toasted garlic hero. All sandwiches and wraps are served with your choice of side, pickle, and coleslaw. All wraps are served with your choice of whole wheat or flour tortilla. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish, or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Honey BBQ Chicken and Cheddar
Crunchy chicken tossed in our signature BBQ sauce served on a toasted hero with melted cheddar cheese. All sandwiches and wraps are served with your choice of side, pickle, and coleslaw. All wraps are served with your choice of whole wheat or flour tortilla. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Crispy buffalo chicken mixed with lettuce, tomato, and bleu cheese dressing. All sandwiches and wraps are served with your choice of side, pickle, and coleslaw. All wraps are served with your choice of whole wheat or flour tortilla. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled sliced chicken mixed with romaine lettuce, croutons, pecorino romano cheese, and Caesar dressing. All sandwiches and wraps are served with your choice of side, pickle, and coleslaw. All wraps are served with your choice of whole wheat or flour tortilla. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Avocado Chicken Wrap
Grilled sliced chicken wrapped with crispy bacon, tomato, onion, and avocado. All sandwiches and wraps are served with your choice of side, pickle, and coleslaw. All wraps are served with your choice of whole wheat or flour tortilla. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Blackened Chicken Fajita Wrap
Blackened chicken wrapped up with sauteed peppers and onions, jack cheese, and avocado. All sandwiches and wraps are served with your choice of side, pickle, and coleslaw. All wraps are served with your choice of whole wheat or flour tortilla. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses especially if you have certain medical conditions.

Baskets
Fish and Chips
Beer-battered cod fillets cooked until golden brown with a side of French fries and tartar sauce. Add melted cheese or chili to any basket for an additional cost. Add gravy for an additional cost. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses especially if you have certain medical conditions.
French Fries Basket
Tater Tot Basket
Waffle Fries Basket
Onion Rings Basket
Sweet Potato Waffle Fries Basket
Served with a side of homemade maple sauce. Add melted cheese or chili to any basket for an additional cost. Add gravy for an additional cost. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Chicken Fingers Basket (4 pcs)
Chicken fingers served over a basket of French fries with a side of honey mustard. Add melted cheese or chili to any basket for an additional cost. Add gravy for an additional cost. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses especially if you have certain medical conditions.

Kids Menu
Kids Burger
Served with fries. Under 12 years old. Includes soft drinks and dessert. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Chicken Fingers
Served with fries. Under 12 years old. Includes soft drinks and dessert. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Pasta
with butter or marinara sauce. Under 12 years old. Includes soft drinks and dessert. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Grilled Cheese
Served with fries. Under 12 years old. Includes soft drinks and dessert. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Mac & Cheese
As a meal. Under 12 years old. Includes soft drinks and dessert. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Hot Dog
Served with fries. Under 12 years old. Includes soft drinks and dessert. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses especially if you have certain medical conditions.

Dessert Menu
Cheesecake
Creamy New york style cheesecake topped with whipped cream and raspberry drizzle. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Chocolate Chip Brownie
Warm fudge brownie drizzled with chocolate syrup, whipped cream, and your choice of vanilla or chocolate ice cream. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Tartufo
Vanilla and chocolate ice cream in a chocolate shell with a cherry and walnut center. This menu item can be cooked to your liking. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illnesses especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Vanilla Ice Cream
Chocolate Ice Cream

Beverages
Soda
Coke, diet coke, sprite, root beer, seltzer, ginger ale, lemonade, and iced tea.
Orange Juice
Apple Juice
Coffee
Iced Tea
Milk
Tomato Juice

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+15 photos
Photo credit: ubereats
+14 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Went here for the 1st time to celebrate a friend's birthday last friday night. There were 20 of us, so we didn't call ahead of time or anything, so we were scattered into small groups. What was GREAT is that people there who were sitting at tables actually got up and made room for us to all to sit down or even take the space by the back wal area near the bar.Food EXCELLENT, service EXCELLENT, Atmosphere, AMAZING. We had a blast. Thank you, Benchwarmer's. Vincent.

Parking:...
January 2024
Parking: Free large parking lot on the left side of the place.

Kid-friendliness: This place has a dining area that's separated from the bar so you can bring your kids or lunch dinner etc, they also have kids menu.
July 2023
Fun place with lots of tv"s that have LOTS of good stuff on them to watch. Quickdraw is extroadinatily fun there too - can't exactly say why. Probably because of the customers --- must of whom were playing at the bar and laughing out up.Didn't eat there this time, but the chicken wings someone sitting next to me got looked and SMELLED amazing!! (Others were commenting those wings too! Yum!Charise, behind the bar is OUTSTANDING!! Doesn't miss a beat.Go have...
June 2023

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Mountain Sea Asian Bistro - 33 NY-25A
Chinese
Renzo's Pizzeria & Restaurant - 37 NY-25A
Pizza, Italian, Chicken Wings, Vegan, Vegetarian
ATM 7ELEVEN, INC. - 120 Rte 25A
Coffee & Tea

Benchwarmer's Tavern and Grill

23 Rte 25A, Mt Sinai, NY 11766
(631) 509-4077