Papa Johns Pizza
152 NY-25A, Mt Sinai
(631) 928-6666
Customers' Favorites
12 Original Crust Pizza Medium
10 Orginal Crust Pizza Small
Pan - Hawaiian BBQ Chicken
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Cinnamon Pull Aparts
Garlic Bread Sticks
Chocolate Brownie
The Works
Menu
Photos
+38 photos
+37 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
So far so good ..food is always hot and good' they be on time with delivery. Forgot soda with order n made sure to bring one to me asap did not wait long..very nice on the phone. If you like papa John's this location seems to be very well on point
Order from here at least once a week. Never any problem with my order, always on time delivery and I appreciate that they still deliver for cash payment!! Papa John's over dominos all the way. Always get the pepperoni stuffed crust with extra pepperoni and it's bomb. Also the chocolate brownie is basically a tray of homemade brownies and they're so yum.
Vegetarian options: All veggie pizza is a thing
Vegetarian options: All veggie pizza is a thing
My go to movie night pizza is the Mount Sinai Papa. Love the staff, very friendly, they even remembered my usual order! Pizza always cooked the exact same, perfect way. Never had a complaint at this location yet.
You May Also Like
Mount Sinai Sushi - 166 Rte 25A
![]()
Sushi, Sushi Bar, Vegetarian
Go Burger MOUNT SINAI - 271 NY-25A
![]()
Fast Food, Burgers, Cheesesteaks, Hamburger, Vegetarian
Midori Sushi & Steakhouse - 271-6 NY-25A
![]()
Japanese, Sushi Bar, Vegan, Vegetarian