Strathmore Bagel Of Mount Sinai

My favorite bagels on Long Island! Plus friendly staff that always know my order.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great food and the service is fantastic!!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

All I have to say is that they have the best/most consistent hungry man I have ever had. It is so good without fail, if you're looking for a egg sandwich GO HERE for it !

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Lately my ‘go to’ bagel place in Mt.Sinai. Friendly staff, great food. Their sandwiches are huge and deliciously fresh!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Bacon Egg and Cheese

Even though the catalogue said 1/2 lb of cream cheese free (it even said inside the store), the rude employee said no, not any more without explaining why. I left very disappointed not for not getting the cheese but at the rude attitude of him. Terrible place. Fortunately for me it was a great day outside weatherwise.

Customer service over the phone is the terrible the guy named Jose or josue very rude and unprofessional taking the order , when he doesn’t understand something start saying Omg and talking over the

Service: 1

This place is terrible. Used to be a great spot. New owners r horrible. Good reviews r from old owners who were great. Stay away!!!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Spoke with William and Edgar to place a catering order. They were both extremely helpful and patient with me as I was trying to decide. The presentation when delivered was second to none and I appreciate their help and delicious bagels and salads. everything was perfect from start to finish. Thank you again.

My go to bagel place. Fav is toasted super egg bagel w cream cheese. Egg sandwiches are good, service and pricing are good as well.

Guy didn't even know the menu when I called. Messed up my order. Place is shot.

We only go here when we decide to use TooGoodToGo. So far, pretty good surprise bags but it's really a dangerous parking area/exit.

This is my new go-to place. It's so clean, the staff is so accommodating, and the choices are perfect. I tried the avocado toast today and I'm in love! Reasonable prices compared to other places also. You should go see for yourself and support their business.

Doesn’t take much to hire a cleaning crew these days. While the bagels are good the place itself it filthy. And I’ll never understand the glove situation- if you’re not putting a fresh pair on in between every customer what’s the point of wearing them? Judging by the place and the bathroom I can only imagine how dirty the kitchen is.

Used to love Strathmore bagels and get them every time is was in town. They are not the same anymore. Must be different recipe. Also everything bagels no longer have salt which means they really aren't everything.

Not even close to the same quality that I used to get at the old Strathmore Bagels in East Setauket AND to make things worse, they have a sticker that is slang for “Fu** You” and often used in bigoted contexts, on their window right above the door handle. Based on other reviews about the owners bad attitude and refusing to correct unacceptable orders, this is not surprising. It’s a certain personality type that puts up such a sticker saying “FU” to every customer who enters the store.I will never go back there again. And I won’t be missing much. The bagels are not the same as the old Strathmore bagels. The bagels, at this location at least, are more like rolls.