Cindy's Pies

5 Academy St, Naples
(585) 374-6122

Recent Reviews

Customers' Favorites

Apple Pie
Grape Pie

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: google
+37 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+36 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

This place was amazing. You go, you ring the bell, the door opens (just the top), he says “how many pies” you say, “one pie”, he says “flavor”, you say “STRAWBERRY RHUBARB”, he says “classic crust or crumb crust”, you say “CRUMB CRUST” he says “$20” you say “nevermind I’ll take two”. He leaves. He returns. You have two INCREDIBLE pies. We will stop at Cindy’s Pies on every trip to the finger lakes from here forevermore.

One...
July 2025
A new favorite place to go. Every fall we take a drive to Naples, enjoy the foliage and pick up a grape pie from Monica's. This year though when I searched for Monica's website to see what hours they were open I found out they had closed their doors for good. Well I still wanted to get a grape pie and Cindy's Pies came up in my search so that is where we went. The grape pie was mouth watering, better than I have ever had. We also grabbed 8 tarts of different flavors...
December 2024
I've met Cindy! A super nice lady who knows her way around a pie. Great stuff. Highly recommend you make the drive down to Naples and check it out for yourself. You won't be disappointed.
June 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Subway - 145 N Main St
Sandwich Shop, Fast Food
Naples Wood Fired Pizza & Smokehouse BBQ - 120 N Main St
Pizza, Italian, Barbeque, Vegetarian, Chicken Wings
Luigi's - 101 N Main St
Pizza, Italian, Chicken Wings, Pet Friendly

Cindy's Pies

5 Academy St, Naples, NY 14512
(585) 374-6122