Bagel Cafe
248 Smithtown Blvd #9, Nesconset
(631) 366-2362
Customers' Favorites
Ham Egg and Cheese Pumpernickel Everything Bagel
Bacon Egg and Cheese Everything Egg Bagel
Plain Bagel Bacon Egg and Cheese
Plain Cream Cheese on a Bagel
Any Tuna Salad on a Wrap
Strawberry Cream Cheese
1 Dozen Assorted Bagels
Build Your Own Sandwich
Philly Cheesesteak Hero
Bagel Cream Cheese
Bagels
Bagels
Individual Bagels. Please do not add toppings
1 Dozen Bagels
Breakfast Spreads by the 1/2 LB
1/2 lb. Butter
1/2 lb. Plain Cream Cheese
1/2 lb. Vegetable Cream Cheese
1/2 lb. Scallion Cream Cheese
1/2 lb. Lox Spread
1/2 lb. Olive Cream Cheese
1/2 lb. Cinnamon Raisin Walnut Cream Cheese
1/2 lb. Apple Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese
1/2 lb. Chocolate Chip Cream Cheese
1/2 lb. Sun-Dried Tomato Jalapeno Cream Cheese
1/2 lb. Strawberry Cream Cheese
Breakfast Spreads on a Bagel
Butter
Plain Cream Cheese
Vegetable Cream Cheese
Scallion Cream Cheese
Lox Spread
Olive Cream Cheese
Cinnamon Raisin Walnut Cream Cheese
Apple Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese
Chocolate Chip Cream Cheese
Sun-Dried Tomato Jalapeno Cream Cheese
Strawberry Cream Cheese on a Bagel
Hot Breakfast from the Grill
2 Eggs on a Bagel
2 Eggs with Meat
2 Egg Whites on a Bagel
2 Egg Whites with Meat
Heart Attack Hero
3 eggs, ham, bacon, sausage and cheese on a hero.
Challah French Toast
Served with Butter, Syrup and a dusting off powdered sugar.
The Nesc-Skinny
Egg whites, grilled turkey, fresh spinach, swiss cheese, avocado on a whole wheat wrap.
Hot Breakfast Wraps
Breakfast Wrap 1
3 egg whites, spinach, mushrooms and broccoli.
Breakfast Wrap 3
3 egg whites, sliced lox and caramelized onions.
Breakfast Wrap 4
3 egg whites, pepper turkey, ham, peppers, onions and hot sauce.
Breakfast Wrap 6
6 egg whites and grilled chicken with jalapenos and cheddar cheese.
Appy's
1/4 lb. Hand Carved Nova Scotia Lox
1/2 lb. Chunky White Fish Salad
1/2 lb. Classic Tuna Salad
1/2 lb. Egg Salad
Please Specify Regular Egg Salad or Spinach Egg White Salad
1/2 lb. Chicken Salad
Sliced Cold Cuts by the 1/2 LB
Sliced Cheese by the 1/2 LB
Grilled or Fried Chicken (1 LB)
Fried Eggplant (1 LB)
Potato Knish
Served hot.
Side Salads (1 LB)
Macaroni Salad (1 LB)
Potato Salad (1 LB)
Coleslaw (1 LB)
Bean Salad (1 LB)
Cucumber Salad (1 LB)
Pasta Primavera Salad (1 LB)
Israeli Salad (1 LB)
Sandwich Suggestions
Novalicious
Sliced nova, scallion cream cheese, tomatoes, red onions and cucumber.
Whitefish Salad on a Bagel
Any Salad Sandwich
Choose any Tuna, Chicken or Egg Salad
Build Your Own Sandwich
BLT Sandwich
Bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise.
Turkey Time Sandwich
Turkey salad, bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise.
Chicken Time Salad
Chicken salad, bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise.
Philly Cheesesteak on a Hero
Sizzling Roast Beef, sauteed onions and peppers, and your choice of cheese served on a Hero.
Americana Sandwich
Ham, turkey, roast beef, American and Swiss cheeses, lettuce, tomatoes and coleslaw.
The Soprano Sandwich
Ham, cappicola, salami, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomato, roasted peppers, oil and vinegar.
Chicken Tuscany Sandwich
Grilled or fried chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, romaine lettuce, tomatoes, roasted peppers, red onions and housemade balsamic.
Big Bird Sandwich
Chicken cutlet, melted American, lettuce, tomato and Russian dressing.
Bubbalicious Sandwich
Fried chicken cutlet, melted mozzarella, bacon and spicy BBQ sauce.
Buffalo Bill Sandwich
Chicken cutlet, hot sauce, lettuce and blue cheese dressing.
The Reuben
Hot Pastrami, Turkey or Corn Beef melted Swiss, coleslaw and Russian dressing. Served with a pickle and a side salad of your choice.
Royale Sandwich
Hot roast beef or turkey with melted mozzarella on garlic bread.
Wraps
Caesar's Revenge Wrap
Grilled chicken with lettuce, tomato and Caesar dressing.
Grilled Vegetable Medley Wrap
Grilled Vegetables with Hummus.
Jillian's Delight Wrap
Grilled chicken, roasted peppers, melted mozzarella with balsamic.
Santa Fe Pepper Turkey Wrap
Roasted peppers and grilled onions with spicy jalapeno mayo.
The Sailor
Grilled Chicken or Honey Mustard Chicken Salad with lettuce, tomato and Honey Mustard dressing. Served with a pickle and a side salad of your choice.
The Oceansider
Turkey Breast, Alpine Lace Swiss, Avocado and coleslaw on your choice of wrap. Served with a pickle and your choice of side salad.
Any Chicken Salad Wrap
Your choice of Chicken Salad with lettuce and tomato in your choice of wrap. Served with a pickle and your choice of side salad.
Any Tuna Salad on a Wrap
Your choice of Tuna with lettuce and tomato on your choice of wrap. Served with a pickle and your choice of side salad.
Chop it Up Salad Bar
Chop it Up Salad Bar
Small. Choice of base, choice of 5 toppings, and choice of dressing. Additional toppings and extras for an additional charge.
Hot Soup
Chicken Vegetable Soup (16oz.)
Served Hot
Misc.
Yogurt Parfait with Granola
Rice Pudding with Whipped Cream
Chocolate Parfait Cups
Fruit Cup
Watermelon Cup
Trail Mix Cup
Small bag of Potato Chips
Bakery Department
Black and White Cookie
Apple Turnover
Chocolate Cigar
Muffins
Choice of flavor. Corn, Chocolate Chip, Blueberry
Homemade Crumb Cake
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Coffee
Hot Coffee (16oz.)
Please Specify how you like your Coffee. Otherwise sent Black!
Iced Coffee (24oz.)
Please Specify how you like your Coffee. Otherwise sent Black!
Iced Coffee (32oz.)
Please Specify how you like your Coffee. Otherwise sent Black!
Box of Coffee
10-14 cups.
Beverages
Soda
Gatorade (20oz.)
Red Bull
Snapple
Choice of flavor.
Poland Spring Water Bottle
Fountain Drink (24oz.)
Please Choose: Regular Iced Tea, Unsweetened Iced Tea, or Pink Lemonade
Fountain Drink (32oz.)
Please Choose: Regular Iced Tea, Unsweetened Iced Tea, or Pink Lemonade
Nesquik
Choice of flavor.
Yoo-Hoo Bottle
Tropicana Juice
12 oz. with choice of flavor: Original, Homestyle, Calcium, Apple, Cranberry
1/2 Gallon Orange Juice
1/2 Gallon Milk
Pint of 1/2 and 1/2
Hard to Get Essentials
1/2 Gallon Regular Milk
1/2 Gallon OJ
Carton 1 Dozen Eggs
12 in Whole Wheat Wraps (12pc Count)
Bananas (1pc)
Head of Iceberg Lettuce (1pc)
5x6 Tomato (1pc)
Photos
+31 photos
+30 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Given that my place of birth is Brooklyn I would like to think I know a good bagel when I eat it. The bagels and other foods in LI Bagel Cafe are outstanding and the staff work hard to make eating here a fine experience.
December 2025
Went here for first time today and have to say the BEC was excellent. And not sure why so many comments on here about “rude staff”. The guy who served me was pleasant, seemed happy to be there, had a smile and was a pleasure. Only complaint is that it costs $8.17 cash price and didn’t include a coffee or OJ but other than it being a bit over priced I will definitely be going back - the sandwich was probably top 5 that’s I’ve had on the Island, at least made by this gentleman...
December 2025
Love this place! The bagels are some of the best on the island. Every time I go anywhere else I wish I went here! The side salads are amazing too plus the sandwiches. I’ve been going here for years and I’ve always found the employees to be very nice & accommodating!
October 2025
You May Also Like
Gino's of Nesconset - 248 Smithtown Blvd
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Vegetarian
Swirls & Twirls - 248 Smithtown Blvd
![]()
Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Custom Cakes
Dragon Chinese Resta - 248 Smithtown Blvd #3
![]()
Chinese, Vegan