Strong Island Ice Cream

127 Smithtown Blvd, Nesconset
(631) 656-5930

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Butter Pecan
Waffle Cone
Strawberry
2 Scoops
1 Scoop
Oreo

Menu

Featured items
2 Scoop Sundae
2 scoops of ice cream, a topping of your choice, homemade whipped cream and a cherry.
Double Scoop
Single Scoop
Choose one flavor and add some toppings if you'd like!
Brownie Sundae
2 scoops of ice cream, one topping of your choice, homemade whipped cream and a cherry served on top of a warm brownie.
Cookie Sundae
2 scoops of ice cream, one topping of your choice, homemade whipped cream, and a cherry served on a warm homemade cookie.
Waffle Sundae
2 scoops of ice cream, one topping of your choice, homemade whipped cream, and a cherry served on a homemade waffle.
Waffle Bowl
Banana Split
3 scoops of ice cream, one topping of your choice, homemade whipped cream and a cherry served in between a banana.
Dipped Waffle Cone w/ Peanuts
Waffle Cone dipped in chocolate and covered with peanuts
Chocolate Covered Pretzels
3 pretzels covered in chocolate.
Acai Bowl
2 scoops of acai raspberry sorbet, granola, strawberries, bananas, blueberries and honey.
Giant Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup
Peanut Butter & Jelly Milkshake
Mini Waffle Sundae
One scoop of ice cream, one topping of your choice, homemade whipped cream, and cherry served on a quarter of a homemade waffle.
Dark Chocolate Raspberry Jellies
Dark chocolate infused with raspberry jelly inside.

Ice Cream
Double Scoop
Single Scoop
Choose one flavor and add some toppings if you'd like!
Doggy Ice Cream
This ice cream is 100% safe for dogs to enjoy while you enjoy your ice cream too!
Pint
6 Pack Chocolate & Vanilla Flying Saucers
6 Pack Chocolate & Vanilla Chipwiches
3 chocolate & 3 vanilla
Quart
Vanilla Chipwich
Chipwich with vanilla ice cream
6 Pack Flying Saucers with Sprinkles
3 vanilla with rainbow sprinkles & 3 chocolate with chocolate sprinkles.
Chocolate Chipwich
Chipwich with chocolate ice cream

Sundaes
2 Scoop Sundae
2 scoops of ice cream, a topping of your choice, homemade whipped cream and a cherry.
Cookie Sundae
2 scoops of ice cream, one topping of your choice, homemade whipped cream, and a cherry served on a warm homemade cookie.
Banana Split
3 scoops of ice cream, one topping of your choice, homemade whipped cream and a cherry served in between a banana.
Brownie Sundae
2 scoops of ice cream, one topping of your choice, homemade whipped cream and a cherry served on top of a warm brownie.
Mini Waffle Sundae
One scoop of ice cream, one topping of your choice, homemade whipped cream, and cherry served on a quarter of a homemade waffle.
Acai Bowl
2 scoops of acai raspberry sorbet, granola, strawberries, bananas, blueberries and honey.
Wet Walnut Delight
2 scoops of ice cream, wet walnuts, homemade whipped cream and a cherry.
Waffle Sundae
2 scoops of ice cream, one topping of your choice, homemade whipped cream, and a cherry served on a homemade waffle.
Pound Cake Sundae
2 scoops of ice cream, one topping of your choice, homemade whipped cream, and a cherry served on a warm slice of pound cake.
1 Scoop Sundae
One scoop of ice cream, a topping of your choice, homemade whipped cream and a cherry.

Milkshakes
Milkshakes (24 0z)
24 ounces of whatever flavor you want!
Peanut Butter & Jelly Milkshake

Homemade Chocolates
Giant Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup
Dark Chocolate Raspberry Jellies
Dark chocolate infused with raspberry jelly inside.
Chocolate Covered Pretzels
3 pretzels covered in chocolate.
Dark Chocolate Cordial Cherries
Dark chocolate with cordial cherries inside.
Nonpareils
Dark Chocolate Almond Bark
Giant Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup
Dark Chocolate Salted Caramel
Smooth, creamy caramel encased in dark chocolate with sea salt sprinkled on top
Peanut Butter Cup Cookie
A chocolate chip cookie with peanut butter cups inside.
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Rocky Road Brownie
Chocolate brownie with peanut butter chips and walnuts
Chocolate Chip Brownie
Chocolate brownie with chocolate chips.
Sugar Free Dark Chocolate Raspberry Jellies

Cones
Waffle Bowl
Waffle Cone
Dipped Waffle Cone w/ Peanuts
Waffle Cone dipped in chocolate and covered with peanuts
Dipped Waffle Bowl w/ Sprinkles
Waffle Bowl dipped in chocolate and covered with rainbow sprinkles
Wafer Cone
Sugar Cone
Dipped Waffle Cone w/ Sprinkles
Waffle Cone dipped in chocolate and covered with rainbow sprinkles
Dipped Wafer Cone w/ Sprinkles
Wafer Cone dipped in chocolate and covered in rainbow sprinkles

Extra Toppings
Oreo's (1/4 lb)
Rainbow Sprinkles (1/2 lb)
Chocolate Sprinkles (1/2 lb)
Gummy Bears (1/2 lb)
Peanuts (1/2 lb)

Nostalgic Candies
Nik L Nips
Vanilla Turkish Taffy
Pop Rocks
Candy Necklace
Razzles
Banana Turkish Taffy
Fun Dip
Candy Butons
Big League Chew
Necco Candy Wafers
Bazooka Gum

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: facebook
+36 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+35 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

This is hands down the best ice cream ive ever had. Unique flavors. A little pricey but worth it. Tried ube (tastes almost like cake batter), banana and dark chocolate. So good cant wait to try more
July 2025
The staff was very friendly and helpful; she was also very patient as my kids asked to try some of the flavors. All their flavors were amazing - even simple and classic flavors like strawberry was special and definitely worth a try. We got the Nutella, strawberry, banana cream pie, and s’mores. They were all great choices and everyone finished their flavors in a hot second. Can’t wait to go back.
June 2025
Hands down best homemade ice cream in the area. There's always a unique new flavor to try! The coffee tastes like a real cup of coffee, it's got a kick to it but don't expect it to be sickly sweet, it's perfect for coffee lovers. The dark chocolate is my all time favorite, fiancee loved the cinnamon while it was around. Strawberry cheesecake was fantastic, Ube as well. The sorbet tastes like fresh fruit, refreshingly tangy and cold and sweet- perfect for a...
May 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Nesconset Pizza & Pasta - 127 Smithtown Blvd ste 3
Italian, Pizza, Seafood
Farm To Table Catering and Cafe by Filomena - 127 Smithtown Blvd #11
Caterers, Cafe, Vegan
Akropolis - 127 Smithtown Blvd #16
Greek, Salad, Soup

Strong Island Ice Cream

127 Smithtown Blvd, Nesconset, NY 11767
(631) 656-5930